NR-007Ingredient Atlas entry · Spice

Black pepper extract

Piper nigrum, a climbing vine whose dried fruit is the peppercorn

A Gothic king's ransom, a pharaoh's nose, a friar's dinner plate and a Danish physicist's test paper. For three thousand years people crossed oceans, and burned ships, for a wrinkled black berry. The rotten meat it was meant to hide never turns up.

  • Part used: fruit (peppercorn)
  • Most tested: 20 mg piperine
  • Often days, not weeks
A pile of whole black peppercorns
A pile of whole black peppercorns. Photo by Hubertl, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Three thousand pounds of pepper

Rome, 408. Alaric, king of the Goths, has the city surrounded.1

He held the Tiber, and nothing came up from the port. The Romans cut the grain ration to half, then to a third. Famine brought plague, and because the enemy held every road out, the dead could not be carried beyond the walls for burial, so the city itself became their grave. People came close to eating one another.1

The Senate sent two envoys. Basilius, a Spaniard and a provincial governor, went with Johannes, head of the imperial notaries, because Johannes knew Alaric. They warned him that Rome's people had armed and were ready to fight.1

"The thickest grass is more easy to cut than the thinnest," Alaric said, and laughed at them long and hard.1

His price for leaving was all the gold and silver in the city, every household good and every barbarian slave. One envoy asked what that would leave the citizens. Alaric answered, "Their souls."1

They settled, in the end, on five thousand pounds of gold, thirty thousand pounds of silver, four thousand silk robes, three thousand scarlet-dyed skins and three thousand pounds of pepper.1 The city had no treasury to pay from, and a levy on the senators' property fell short, so the Romans stripped the statues of their gods and melted some of the gold and silver ones down. One was Virtus, Courage herself.1 Two years later Alaric came back and sacked Rome anyway.1

Gold, silver, silk and scarlet were the treasures of an empire. Pepper sat on the same list, and every grain of it had crossed an ocean. It is the dried fruit of a vine, and in the ancient world it came from one stretch of India's south-west coast.2, 3

A pharaoh's nose

The mummy of Ramesses II arrived at Le Bourget airport, outside Paris, on 26 September 1976, and France received him with the honours due a head of state.4

The king who had ruled Egypt for sixty-six years was in a pitiful state. Fungus had spread through the body, its linen and its coffin, and was slowly eating the king away.4, 5 About fifty specialists studied him for eight months at the Musée de l'Homme, and before he went home he was sterilised with gamma rays.4

X-rays looked inside the king's hooked nose. It was packed with tiny round grains, each about three millimetres across, behind a plug of resin. They were black peppercorns, pushed in by the embalmers to keep the nose from collapsing.4

Ramesses died in 1213 BC.5 Somehow, more than three thousand years ago, pepper from southern India had found its way to the embalmers of the Nile.3, 4

Gold in, pepper out

By the first century AD the road to the pepper ran to a timetable. Ships left Egypt's Red Sea coast in midsummer, carrying archers because the Indian seas swarmed with pirates. From the mouth of the Red Sea, with the monsoon behind them, they could reach Muziris in forty days, and they sailed for home in December.6

The Tamil poets watched the same ships from the other end. In one old love poem a man tells his heart he will not cross the wild country where bears raid the flowering trees, not even for easy riches, and leave his girl in tears. Tucked into the poem is a picture of prosperous Muziris, where "the fine ships the Yavanas brought, churning white foam on the great river of the Cheras, come with gold and go home with pepper."7

A Greek merchant's handbook of the same century agrees. Big ships went to those ports "on account of the great quantity and bulk of pepper," and they arrived carrying "a great quantity of coin."2 The pepper came down to the coast in boats hollowed out of single tree trunks.6

Archaeologists have found the Egyptian end of the line. At Berenike, a Roman port on the Red Sea, digs turned up more than three thousand peppercorns, and a large storage jar that held seven and a half kilograms more.8

Pliny the Elder could not see the point of it. Other foods won people over with their sweetness or their looks, he wrote, but pepper had nothing going for it except its bite, "and yet it is for this that we import it all the way from India! Who was the first to make trial of it as an article of food?"9 In Rome a pound of black pepper cost four denarii.9

The serpents of the pepper forest

Five centuries after Pliny, Bishop Isidore of Seville put a better story in his encyclopedia. The pepper tree grows in India, on the sunny side of the Caucasus. Serpents guard its forests. When the pepper is ripe the people set the forests on fire, the serpents flee the flames, and the fire turns the pepper black.10

In 1348 a Florentine friar saw the vines for himself. Giovanni de' Marignolli had left the Pope's court nine years before, as his envoy to the Mongol emperor of China. On his way home he landed at Columbum, today's Kollam, "where the whole world's pepper is produced," and stayed for fourteen months.11

The pepper grew on vines planted like vineyards. Its clusters were green at first, then almost like bunches of grapes, "and they have a red wine in them which I have squeezed out on my plate as a condiment." When the clusters had shrivelled on the vine in the heat, they were knocked off with sticks and caught on linen cloths.11

"These are things that I have seen with mine eyes and handled with my hands," he wrote. Nobody roasted the pepper, "as authors have falsely asserted," and it grew in gardens, not forests.11 The gardens and the public pepper scales belonged to the local Christians of St Thomas. As the Pope's legate he was paid out of the scales' takings, a hundred small gold coins a month, and a thousand when he left.11

Christians and spices

Calicut, May 1498. Vasco da Gama's ships had sailed round Africa to the coast where the pepper grew. He sent one of his convicts ashore, and two Moors from Tunis who spoke Castilian and Genoese greeted the man with "May the Devil take thee! What brought you hither?"12

He told them the Portuguese had come "in search of Christians and of spices."12

They found the spices. Calicut grew "much ginger and pepper and cinnamon" of its own.12 The Christians were a mistake. The Portuguese took the Hindus of Calicut for fellow Christians. Shown into a temple, João de Sá knelt beside da Gama and said, "If these be devils, I worship the true God." Da Gama smiled.12

Four years later he came back with some twenty ships, to avenge about fifty Portuguese killed when a crowd stormed their new trading post at Calicut.13 Off the coast he took a ship bringing pilgrims home from Mecca, stripped it of its goods, took its children to be made friars in Lisbon, and had it set on fire. The passengers put the fire out and fought back until dark. All night they could be heard calling on the Prophet to save them from the Christians. At dawn the ship was fired again. Of the three hundred left on board, thirty of them women, not one escaped alive.13

At Calicut the king sent out a Brahmin to talk peace, dressed in the habit of a friar killed there, so that the ships would let him near. Da Gama gave him a safe-conduct, then held him, and bombarded the city all day.14

When rice ships sailed in from the Coromandel coast, he had the hands, ears and noses of all their crews cut off, their feet tied, and their teeth knocked down their throats so they could not bite the knots loose. They were heaped in one boat under mats and dry leaves, and it was set on fire and sailed at the shore. One chronicler put their number at more than eight hundred.14

The Brahmin followed in a smaller boat with the severed pieces, mutilated the same way, his own hands hung round his neck with a palm-leaf letter. It told the king to have a curry made of what his friar brought him. On the beach people ran to put out the fire and pull out anyone still alive.14

A sharp taste in Copenhagen

Copenhagen, 15 February 1820. Hans Christian Ørsted, a chemist and physicist, writes to a German journal. The new alkaloids being found in plants had sent him back to an old study of pepper, and on taking it up again he "easily discovered" a new one. He called it simply piperine.15

Its solution tasted exceedingly sharp, and it turned turmeric paper brown, the chemists' test for an alkali.15 Piperine is what gives pepper its bite.16

Five months later Ørsted published the experiment that won him the Royal Society's Copley Medal, an electric current swinging a compass needle.17 Piperine waited a long time for its turn.

In 1981 C. K. Atal and two colleagues set out to test an old habit of Ayurveda. A great many of its prescriptions add trikatu, a mix of long pepper, black pepper and ginger. In their animal tests piperine more than doubled the level of a test drug in the blood.18 In 1998 a team in Bangalore gave volunteers curcumin, from turmeric, with and without piperine.19 Pepper and turmeric were back together, as on Ørsted's test paper. Most studies of piperine in people now pair it with curcumin or another active, and what they found is in the Research tab.20

The rotten meat that wasn't

Plenty of people still believe that medieval cooks heaped pepper on their meat to hide that it had gone off.3

Follow it back and the trail keeps arriving at the same book. In 1939 the biochemist Jack Drummond and his co-author Anne Wilbraham published The Englishman's Food. "The popularity of strong seasoning for meat," they wrote, "was undoubtedly due to the frequency with which it was necessary to mask taint."21 They gave no evidence for it. Their one example of a recipe for tainted meat was a 1594 tip for venison that was "greene". Green meant freshly killed, and the tip was a way to age it faster.21

Medieval London had its own answer to rotten meat. In November 1319 the market wardens brought the mayor two beef carcasses that William Sperlyng of West Ham meant to sell at the Stocks market. Sperlyng insisted the meat was good and clean. A jury found it "putrid and poisonous," from beasts that had died of disease. Sperlyng was put in the pillory, and the carcasses were burnt beneath him.22

And pepper was the expensive part of the dinner. Spices cost far more than fresh meat, and fresh meat was easy to come by.23 Pepper was never worth its weight in gold, either. Pliny grumbled that pepper and ginger grew wild, yet Romans bought them by weight, "just as if they were so much gold or silver." But a pound of gold was worth nearly three hundred times his four denarii.9, 24

One peppercorn a year

In the end a single peppercorn became the law's idea of next to nothing. In 1959 the House of Lords had to decide whether three chocolate wrappers could be part of the price of a record. Lord Somervell thought they could. "A peppercorn does not cease to be good consideration," he said, "if it is established that the promisee does not like pepper and will throw away the corn."25

Every April, in King's Square in St George's, Bermuda, the Freemasons pay the Governor their rent for the Old State House. He arrives to a seventeen-gun salute, and the rent is handed over on a velvet cushion. It is one peppercorn.26

Alaric wanted three thousand pounds of pepper to lift his siege. Bermuda's Governor takes one peppercorn, on a cushion.

See what modern trials found

Myths and facts

In the record, or legend?

Every story you will read about this plant, checked against the oldest source we could find.

  • Rome's ransom to Alaric in 408 included 3,000 pounds of pepper

    In the record

    Zosimus, New History 5.41, written about a century later1

  • Ramesses II was buried with peppercorns up his nose

    In the record

    The 1976-77 Paris study of the mummy, by X-ray and plant identification4

  • Rome paid India in gold for pepper

    In the record

    A Tamil poem says the ships came with gold, and a Greek merchant's handbook says they brought coin. Pliny's complaint about money flowing east covers all of India's goods, not pepper alone2, 6, 7

  • Serpents guard the pepper forests, and fire turns the pepper black

    Legend

    Isidore of Seville, early 600s. Marignolli, who lived among the vines around 1348, denied both the roasting and the forests10, 11

  • Da Gama's men came "in search of Christians and of spices"

    In the record

    The fleet's own journal, 1498. The words were spoken by the convict he sent ashore12

  • Pepper was worth its weight in gold

    Legend

    Romans bought it by weight, like gold. In Pliny's Rome gold cost nearly 300 times as much9, 24

  • Medieval cooks used pepper to hide rotten meat

    Legend

    Traced to a 1939 book that gave no evidence. Selling rotten meat could put you in the pillory, and spices cost more than meat21, 22, 23

In the record means a source from the time, or a scholar quoting one, says it. Likely means a named expert's reasoned identification. Told, not shown means one interested party says it and nothing checks it. Partly means a real event sits under a bigger story. Legend means the earliest source is far too late or missing. Wrong date means the event is real but the popular date doesn't match the record.

Notes

Every fact in the story points to one of these. Where a translation is ours, the note says so.

Show all 26 notes Hide the notes
  1. Zosimus, New History 5.39-42 (written in Constantinople in the early sixth century), in the anonymous English translation printed by W. Green and T. Chaplin (London, 1814), online at https://www.livius.org/sources/content/zosimus/zosimus-new-history-5/zosimus-new-history-5.40/ and https://www.livius.org/sources/content/zosimus/zosimus-new-history-5/zosimus-new-history-5.41/ (also https://www.tertullian.org/fathers/zosimus05_book5.htm ). 5.39: Alaric "having possessed himself of the river Tiber, prevented the arrival of necessaries from the port"; "they diminished the allowance of grain, and ordered that not more than half of the former quantity of provisions should be dressed each day and afterwards when the scarcity increased, only a third part"; the famine "was succeeded by a pestilence ... As the dead could not be interred outside the city, for the enemy was in possession of all the avenues, the city was made their sepulchre." 5.40.1: they were "in danger of being eaten by each other". 5.40.2-3: the envoys Basilius, "a Spaniard, and governor of a province", and Johannes, "the chief of the imperial notaries ... because he was acquainted with Alaric"; told that the people "having been exercised to arms were ready for war", Alaric "remarked, 'The thickest grass is more easy to cut than the thinnest.' Having said this, he laughed immoderately at the ambassadors"; his terms, "all the gold and silver in the city, all the household goods, and the barbarian slaves". 5.40.4: "One of the ambassadors observing, 'If you take all these, what will you leave for the citizens?' He replied, 'Their souls.'" 5.41.4: "five thousand pounds of gold, and thirty thousand of silver, four thousand silk robes, three thousand scarlet fleeces, and three thousand pounds of pepper" (the Greek word means skins dyed scarlet); "As the city possessed no public stock, it was necessary for the senators who had property, to undertake the collection by an assessment." 5.41.5: Palladius could not raise the whole sum. 5.41.6-7: they took the ornaments from the statues of the gods and "melted down some of them that were made of gold and silver. Among these was that of Valor or Fortitude, which the Romans call Virtus." 5.42: "the money was paid to the Barbarians", and they withdrew to Tuscany. The siege began in the autumn of 408 (Wikipedia, "Alaric I": "in September 408 he menaced the city"). The sack of Rome by Alaric's Goths began on 24 August 410: Wikipedia, "Alaric I", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaric_I . ↩
  2. W. H. Schoff (trans.), The Periplus of the Erythraean Sea (New York, 1912), section 56, pp. 44-45, https://archive.org/details/cu31924030139236 : "They send large ships to these market-towns on account of the great quantity and bulk of pepper and malabathrum. There are imported here, in the first place, a great quantity of coin ... There is exported pepper, which is produced in quantity in only one region near these markets, a district called Cottonara." The handbook dates from the first century AD. ↩
  3. Wikipedia, "Black pepper", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_pepper : "a flowering vine ... cultivated for its fruit (the peppercorn), which is usually dried and used as a spice"; native to "the tropical evergreen forests of the Malabar Coast in southwestern India"; the Malabar region was "the ancient world's sole geographic source of the spice". On the myth: "It is commonly believed that during the Middle Ages, pepper was often used to conceal the taste of partially rotten meat. No evidence supports this claim, and historians view it as highly unlikely." ↩
  4. Agnès and Thibault Monier, "La momie de Ramses II : étude paléopathologique d'un pharaon de la XIXe dynastie", Société française d'histoire de l'art dentaire, Actes, https://numerabilis.u-paris.fr/partenaires/sfhad/actes/la-momie-de-ramses-ii-etude-paleopathologique-dun-pharaon-de-la-xixe-dynastie/ . Translation ours. In 1975 Maurice Bucaille warned Egypt of the mummy's "état pitoyable" (pitiful state); "Le 26 septembre 1976, la momie de Ramsès II arrivait au Bourget où elle fut réceptionnée avec les honneurs dignes d'un chef d'état" (arrived at Le Bourget, where it was received with the honours worthy of a head of state); eight months at the Musée de l'Homme; "une cinquantaine de spécialistes" (about fifty specialists); the mummy, its linen and its coffin "étaient colonisés par des champignons qui provoquaient la dégradation lente mais continue de la dépouille" (were colonised by fungi causing the slow but continuous decay of the remains); sterilised with gamma rays at the Saclay nuclear centre; back in Egypt on 10 May 1977. The king's "profil d'aigle au nez bourbonien" (eagle profile with a hooked nose). X-rays by Clément Fauré and xerographs by Drs Bard and Massare: "Le nez est comblé par de petites structures de 3 mm de diamètre environ, d'origine végétale du poivre (piper nigrum) et l'ouverture des orifices narinaires est obstruée par une substance lenticulaire ... probablement un bouchon en résine" (the nose is filled with small structures about 3 mm in diameter, of plant origin, pepper, and the nostrils are blocked by a lens-shaped substance, probably a resin plug); the peppercorns were "destinés à éviter l'effondrement des tissus mous du nez après momification" (meant to stop the soft tissue of the nose collapsing after mummification). The full scientific report, La momie de Ramsès II. Contribution scientifique à l'égyptologie (Muséum national d'histoire naturelle, Paris, 1985), was not available to us. ↩
  5. Wikipedia, "Ramesses II": reign 1279 to 1213 BC in the usual chronology, "66 years, 2 months", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramesses_II . ↩
  6. Pliny the Elder, Natural History 6.26 (6.101-106 in modern numbering), trans. J. Bostock and H. T. Riley (London, 1855), https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:1999.02.0137:book=6:chapter=26 : "voyages are made to India every year: and companies of archers are carried on board the vessels, as those seas are greatly infested with pirates"; ships leave at the rising of the Dog-star, midsummer, reach Ocelis at the mouth of the Red Sea in about thirty days, and from there, "If the wind, called Hippalus, happens to be blowing, it is possible to arrive in forty days at the nearest mart of India, Muziris by name" (Bostock and Riley gloss the Hippalus as a west wind; it is the south-west monsoon, Wikipedia, "Hippalus", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hippalus ); pepper "is carried down to Barace in boats hollowed out of a single tree" from Cottonara; they sail home "at the beginning of the Egyptian month Tybis, which is our December". The same chapter says India drains the empire of a vast sum every year ("five hundred and fifty millions of sesterces" in Bostock and Riley), for all its wares, not pepper alone. ↩
  7. Akanāṉūṟu 149, attributed to Erukkāṭṭūr Tāyaṅkaṇṇaṉār. Tamil text from Project Madurai, https://www.projectmadurai.org/pm_etexts/utf8/pmuni0229.html . Translation ours. Lines 1-7: "சிறுபுன் சிதலை சேண்முயன்று எடுத்த நெடுஞ்செம் புற்றத்து ஒடுங்கிரை முனையின், புல்லரை இருப்பைத் தொள்ளை வான்பூப், பெருங்கை எண்கின் இருங்கிளை கவரும் அத்த நீள்இடைப் போகி, நன்றும் அரிதுசெய் விழுப்பொருள் எளிதினிற் பெறினும் வாரேன் - வாழி, என் நெஞ்சே!" (I will not go along the long wasteland road, where dark herds of big-pawed bears, tired of the termites hidden in the tall red mound the little termites worked so long to build, snatch the white flowers of the rough-barked iluppai tree, not even if the great wealth that is so hard to win came easily. Long may you live, my heart!). Lines 7-11: "சேரலர் சுள்ளியம் பேரியாற்று வெண்நுரை கலங்க, யவனர் தந்த வினைமாண் நன்கலம் பொன்னொடு வந்து கறியொடு பெயரும் வளம்கெழு முசிறி" (prosperous Muciri, where the fine ships the Yavanas brought, churning white foam on the Culli, the great river of the Cheras, come with gold and go home with pepper; the story leaves out the river's name). In the poem the Muciri lines belong to a longer picture of the Pandya king Celiyan, who besieged prosperous Muciri amid uproar ("ஆர்ப்பெழ வளஇ", line 11) and carried off its idol; the poem ends on her eyes filling with tears. Tamil Lexicon (University of Madras), p. 825, கறி sense 4, "pepper", and p. 3395, யவனர் "natives of Yavaṉam", citing this poem, https://dsal.uchicago.edu/dictionaries/tamil-lex/ . The Yavanas were westerners, Greek-speaking traders from the Roman world. Muciri is the Muziris of the Greek and Latin writers. Another English rendering is in H. Kulke and D. Rothermund, A History of India (4th ed., 2004), which we did not check. ↩
  8. A. Zuiderhoek, review of R. T. J. Cappers, Roman Foodprints at Berenike: Archaeobotanical Evidence of Subsistence and Trade in the Eastern Desert of Egypt (Los Angeles, 2006), Bryn Mawr Classical Review 2006.10.41, https://bmcr.brynmawr.edu/2006/2006.10.41/ : "C. discovered more than 3,000 black peppercorns at Berenike ... In addition, a large dolium (storage jar) was discovered containing 7.5 kg of black peppercorns." Cappers's book was not available to us. ↩
  9. Pliny, Natural History 12.14 (12.26-29 in modern numbering), trans. Bostock and Riley, https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:1999.02.0137:book=12:chapter=14 : "It is quite surprising that the use of pepper has come so much into fashion, seeing that in other substances which we use, it is sometimes their sweetness, and sometimes their appearance that has attracted our notice; whereas, pepper has nothing in it that can plead as a recommendation to either fruit or berry, its only desirable quality being a certain pungency; and yet it is for this that we import it all the way from India! Who was the first to make trial of it as an article of food? ... Pepper and ginger, both grow wild in their respective countries, and yet here we buy them by weight—just as if they were so much gold or silver." Prices: long pepper fifteen denarii a pound, white pepper seven, "and of black, four". Pliny wrote in the AD 70s. ↩
  10. Isidore of Seville, Etymologiae 17.8.8 (compiled in the early seventh century; Isidore died in 636). Latin text at The Latin Library, https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/isidore/17.shtml . Translation ours. "Piperis arbor nascitur in India, in latere montis Caucasi, quod soli obversum est ... Cuius silvas serpentes custodiunt, sed incolae regionis illius, quum maturae fuerint, incendunt, et serpentes igni fugantur; et inde ex flamma nigrum piper efficitur" (the pepper tree grows in India, on the side of Mount Caucasus that faces the sun ... serpents guard its forests, but when they are ripe the people of that region set them alight, and the serpents are driven off by the fire; and so the flame makes the pepper black). He adds a warning against "mercatorum fraus", merchants who sprinkle litharge or lead on old pepper to make it heavy. ↩
  11. Giovanni de' Marignolli, recollections of his travels, in H. Yule, Cathay and the Way Thither, new edition by H. Cordier, vol. 3 (London: Hakluyt Society, 1914), pp. 216-218, https://archive.org/details/cathaywaythither03yule : Columbum, "where the whole world's pepper is produced. Now this pepper grows on a kind of vines, which are planted just like in our vineyards. These vines produce clusters which are at first like those of the wild vine, of a green colour, and afterwards are almost like bunches of our grapes, and they have a red wine in them which I have squeezed out on my plate as a condiment. When they have ripened, they are left to dry upon the tree, and when shrivelled by the excessive heat the dry clusters are knocked off with a stick and caught upon linen cloths ... These are things that I have seen with mine eyes and handled with my hands during the fourteen months that I stayed there. And there is no roasting of the pepper, as authors have falsely asserted, nor does it grow in forests, but in regular gardens; nor are the Saracens the proprietors but the Christians of St. Thomas. And these latter are the masters of the public steel-yard, from which I derived, as a perquisite of my office as Pope's legate, every month a hundred gold fanam, and a thousand when I left." Marignolli's Latin calls the scales a statera, which Yule shows means a steelyard, a weighing beam (pp. 217-218, note). Later, retelling the legend of St Thomas at Mirapolis (Mylapore, on the other coast), Marignolli says the king there gave the apostle "a perpetual grant of the public steelyard for pepper and all aromatic spices" (p. 252). The fanam was a small gold coin; Yule puts Marignolli's at about 8d, so about £3 6s a month and £33 at parting (p. 218, note). Yule identifies Columbum as Quilon (now Kollam). The year is Yule's reckoning: following Kunstmann, he assumes Marignolli left China late in 1347, which puts the arrival around Easter 1348 (p. 216, note). Marignolli elsewhere calls his stay "a year and four months" (Yule's note). Marignolli, a Franciscan from a Florentine family, left the papal court at Avignon at the end of 1338 as one of four papal legates to the Mongol emperor, reached his capital, Khanbaliq, in 1342 and stayed three or four years: Wikipedia, "Giovanni de' Marignolli", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giovanni_de%27_Marignolli . ↩
  12. E. G. Ravenstein (trans.), A Journal of the First Voyage of Vasco da Gama, 1497-1499 (London: Hakluyt Society, 1898), Project Gutenberg #46440, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/46440 . Pp. 48-49 (21 May 1498): "the captain-major sent one of the convicts to Calecut", where he met "two Moors from Tunis, who could speak Castilian and Genoese", whose first greeting was "May the Devil take thee! What brought you hither?"; asked what he sought, "he told them that we came in search of Christians and of spices". P. 77: "The following spices are to be found in this city of Calecut, being its own produce: much ginger and pepper and cinnamon". P. 54, Ravenstein's note on the visit to a temple (the journal calls it a church), citing the chronicler Castanheda (i, p. 57): "when João de Sá knelt down by the side of Vasco da Gama, he said: 'If these be devils, I worship the true God'; at which his chief smiled." P. xxviii: the journal's author "looked upon the Hindus as fellow-Christians" and "shared that opinion with the other members of the expedition, including its chief". ↩
  13. Fernão Lopes de Castanheda, History of the Discovery and Conquest of India by the Portuguese (from N. Lichefild's English translation of 1582), in R. Kerr, A General History and Collection of Voyages and Travels, vol. 2 (Edinburgh, 1811), chapter 6, section 5, transcribed at https://franpritchett.com/00generallinks/kerr/vol02chap06sect05.html : the king sent the fleet "to revenge the injurious and treacherous conduct of the Zamorin"; "thirteen great ships and two caravels" sailed from Lisbon on 3 March 1502, and "a smaller squadron of five ships" under Estêvão da Gama sailed in May and joined them at Kilwa (Kerr's note, from Astley, gives ten, five and five); off Mount Dely "a ship belonging to the Moors of Mecca, and bound for Calicut"; its goods taken; "De Gama ordered all the children belonging to the Moors to be taken on board one of his own ships, and vowed to make them all friars in the church of our Lady at Belem"; the Moors shut "under the hatches" and the ship set on fire "to revenge the death of the Portuguese who were slain in the factory at Calicut"; "the Moors broke open the hatches, and quenched the fire", fought back and "even threw firebrands into our ship"; "Night coming on", the attack stopped, "and the Moors all night long were heard calling on Mahomet to deliver them out of the hands of the Christians"; at daybreak the ship was fired again, those who leapt into the sea "were slain in the water", the rest drowned as it sank; "Of 300 Moors, of whom thirty were women, not one escaped alive". That the ship was bringing pilgrims home from Mecca is from João de Barros, in H. E. J. Stanley (trans.), The Three Voyages of Vasco da Gama (London: Hakluyt Society, 1869), pp. 316-318 (see note 14 for the link): "many honourable Moors had gone in it in pilgrimage to ... Mekkah, and the ship was returning with these pilgrims"; Barros gives about 260 fighting men and more than fifty women and children, with some twenty children spared. Osório and San Román say the ship was outward bound (Stanley, pp. 315-316). The killings were at the trading post (factory) that Pedro Álvares Cabral's fleet set up at Calicut in 1500. Castanheda's account of that voyage, in Kerr, chapter 6, section 3, https://franpritchett.com/00generallinks/kerr/vol02chap06sect03.html : Aires Correa was "to remain as factor in Calicut"; in December the factory's people first thought to hold off "a mischievous rabble", then judged the attackers "at least four thousand men"; "Correa was slain, and fifty more of our men were either killed or made prisoners, twenty only escaping who swam to the boats". Wikipedia, "Pedro Álvares Cabral", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pedro_%C3%81lvares_Cabral : on 16 or 17 December 1500 the factory was attacked by Arabs and Indians, and "more than 50 Portuguese were killed"; other accounts give between 20 and 70 Portuguese wounded or killed. ↩
  14. Gaspar Correia, Lendas da Índia, in H. E. J. Stanley (trans.), The Three Voyages of Vasco da Gama, and His Viceroyalty (London: Hakluyt Society, 1869), pp. 329-332, https://archive.org/details/voyageroundworld01tayl : the king sent "a Brahman of his in a boat with a white cloth fastened to a pole, as a sign of peace. This Brahman came dressed in the habit of a friar, one of those who had been killed in the country", saying he wore it "that they might not drive me away from the ships"; the captain-major and everyone had been "joyful, thinking that he was one of our friars"; the captain-major "gave him a safe conduct", then "ordered the friar to be well secured"; "all day, till night, he bombarded the city"; rice ships "from Coromandel" taken; "the captain-major commanded them to cut off the hands and ears and noses of all the crews, and put all that into one of the small vessels, into which he ordered them to put the friar, also without ears, or nose, or hands, which he ordered to be strung round his neck, with a palm-leaf for the King, on which he told him to have a curry made to eat of what his friar brought him"; their feet were tied, "and in order that they should not untie them with their teeth, he ordered them to strike upon their teeth with staves, and they knocked them down their throats"; they were heaped in a vessel under "mats and dry leaves", which was set on fire with its sails set for the shore, "and there were more than eight hundred Moors"; the small vessel with the friar "was also sent on shore under sail, without being fired"; on shore "many people flocked together to put out the fire, and draw out those whom they found alive". Correia reached India in 1512 or 1514 (Stanley's introduction prefers 1514) and wrote decades later; the bombardment is also in Barros and Osório (Stanley's note, p. 330). ↩
  15. H. C. Ørsted ("Oerstedt"), "Ueber das Piperin, ein neues Pflanzenalkaloid", Journal für Chemie und Physik (Schweigger) 29 (1820): 80-82, dated "Kopenhagen den 15. Febr. 1820", https://archive.org/details/neuesjournalfur00meingoog . Translation ours. "Die Entdeckungen der neuen Alkalien in den Pflanzen haben mich auf eine alte Arbeit zurückgeführt, welche ich über den Pfeffer vor mehreren Jahren angefangen hatte, indem ich diese Untersuchung wieder aufnahm, entdeckte ich leicht darin eine neue alkalinische Substanz, die wir wohl Piperin nennen werden, ohne uns nach einem mehr aus der Natur der Sache gesuchten Namen umzusehen, da unsere Kenntniss der ganzen Classe von Stoffen, wozu dieser gehört, noch so neu und unvollständig ist" (the discoveries of the new alkalis in plants led me back to an old study of pepper I had begun several years ago; on taking it up again I easily discovered in it a new alkaline substance, which we may call piperine, without looking for a name drawn more from the nature of the thing, since our knowledge of the whole class of substances it belongs to is still so new and incomplete); "Die Auflösung schmeckt ausnehmend scharf; bräunt das Curcumäpapier" (the solution tastes exceedingly sharp, browns turmeric paper). Turmeric paper turning brown was the chemists' test for an alkali; Ørsted lists it among the signs that piperine behaves like the other new plant alkalis. Wikipedia, "Hans Christian Ørsted", calls him "a Danish chemist and physicist", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Christian_%C3%98rsted . ↩
  16. L. Gorgani, M. Mohammadi, G. D. Najafpour and M. Nikzad, "Piperine, the bioactive compound of black pepper: from isolation to medicinal formulations", Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety 16 (2017): 124-140, abstract: piperine "imparts pungency and biting taste" to pepper. https://doi.org/10.1111/1541-4337.12246 (free abstract also on PubMed, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33371546/ ) ↩
  17. H. C. Ørsted, "Experiments on the effect of a current of electricity on the magnetic needle", Annals of Philosophy 16 (1820): 273-276, signed "Copenhagen, July 21, 1820", https://archive.org/details/annalsofphilosop16phil . The Annals printed it in October 1820, translated from Ørsted's printed Latin account of 21 July. Wikipedia, "Hans Christian Ørsted": "For his discovery, the Royal Society of London awarded Ørsted the Copley Medal in 1820." ↩
  18. C. K. Atal, U. Zutshi and P. G. Rao, "Scientific evidence on the role of Ayurvedic herbals on bioavailability of drugs", Journal of Ethnopharmacology 4 (1981): 229-232, abstract, https://doi.org/10.1016/0378-8741(81)90037-4 (free abstract also on PubMed, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7311598/ ): "Experiments were conducted to evaluate the scientific basis of the use of the trikatu group of acrids (long pepper, black pepper and ginger) in the large number of prescriptions in Ayurveda"; "Under the influence of piperine ... sparteine blood levels increased more than 100%". The abstract does not name the animal; PubMed indexes the paper under "Animals" and "Rats". ↩
  19. G. Shoba, D. Joy, T. Joseph, M. Majeed, R. Rajendran and P. S. Srinivas, "Influence of piperine on the pharmacokinetics of curcumin in animals and human volunteers", Planta Medica 64 (1998): 353-356, abstract (Department of Pharmacology, St John's Medical College, Bangalore): curcumin was given with and without piperine to rats and to "healthy human volunteers". https://doi.org/10.1055/s-2006-957450 ↩
  20. Nooroots Ingredient Atlas, black pepper, Research tab, /pages/black-pepper-research : "Piperine added to curcumin or another active to raise its absorption counts as in a blend, and that is most piperine research." ↩
  21. J. C. Drummond and A. Wilbraham, The Englishman's Food: Five Centuries of English Diet (London, 1939); quoted by D. Myers from pp. 36-37 of the 1991 Pimlico edition (we have not seen the 1939 text), "Drummond's Rotten Meat: When Good Sources Go Bad", MedievalCookery.com, http://www.medievalcookery.com/notes/drummond.pdf . Myers: when a source for the myth is given, "the trail invariably leads to" this book. Drummond's lines: "It is not surprising to find that the recipe books of these times give numerous suggestions for making tainted meat edible"; Hugh Platt's 1594 advice for venison that was "greene", to be buried in a cloth "a yard deep in the ground for 12 or 20 houres"; "The popularity of strong seasoning for meat was undoubtedly due to the frequency with which it was necessary to mask taint." Myers calls Platt's tip "the one piece of evidence he sites [cites]" for the tainted-meat recipes, reads "greene" as unripe, meaning freshly killed, and calls the tip "a way to take a freshly butchered carcass and speed up the aging process"; for the strong-seasoning line, "No documentation or support of any kind is offered". Myers describes Drummond as a biochemist, "not a historian". We did not read Drummond's book ourselves. Myers leaves open whether Drummond reached the idea by misreading old texts or repeated "a common misconception at the time", and points to Samuel Pegge's 1780 introduction to The Forme of Cury as one possible source; the chain of references, he writes, goes back "to a single source". We found no earlier statement of the claim. ↩
  22. H. T. Riley (ed. and trans.), Memorials of London and London Life, in the XIIIth, XIVth, and XVth Centuries (London, 1868), pp. 132-133, "Punishment of the Pillory, for selling putrid beef", 13 Edward II, A.D. 1319, Letter-Book E, fol. xciv, https://archive.org/details/memorialsoflondo0000henr : on the Sunday after All Saints the wardens of the flesh-meat at the shambles called "les Stokkes" (the Stocks Market) brought before the mayor, Hamon de Chiggewelle, "two beef carcasses, putrid and poisonous ... taken from William Sperlyng of West Hamme, he intending to sell the same"; he said "the flesh thereof is good and clean, and fit for human food"; the jury found them "putrid and poisonous, and ... bodies that have died of disease"; he was "put upon the pillory, and the said carcasses burnt beneath him". ↩
  23. C. Kummer, "Posh spice", review of P. Freedman, Out of the East: Spices and the Medieval Imagination (New Haven, 2008), Yale Alumni Magazine, March/April 2008, https://yalealumnimagazine.com/articles/2044-posh-spice : "spices cost much more than fresh meat, which was generally available and in cold climates seldom went off before people could eat it." ↩
  24. Pliny, Natural History 33.13 (33.47 in modern numbering), trans. Bostock and Riley, https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:1999.02.0137:book=33:chapter=13 : under Nero the gold coin "was coined at the rate of forty-five to the libra" (the Roman pound); the translators' note gives the gold coin as worth 25 silver denarii. So a Roman pound of gold was worth about 1,125 denarii, some 280 times a pound of black pepper. Our sum, for first-century Rome; no source we used gives a later comparison. ↩
  25. Chappell & Co Ltd v Nestlé Co Ltd [1960] AC 87, House of Lords, 18 June 1959, speech of Lord Somervell of Harrow, https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKHL/1959/1.html : the offer was a record for "three wrappers from Nestlé's 6d. Milk Chocolate bars, together with postal order for 1/6"; "I think they are part of the consideration ... A peppercorn does not cease to be good consideration if it is established that the promisee does not like pepper and will throw away the corn." ↩
  26. Bermuda Tourism Authority, "Travel back in time at the Peppercorn Ceremony", https://www.gotobermuda.com/article/the-peppercorn-ceremony-freemasons-town-criers-only-bermuda-tale : each April in King's Square, St George's, "the formal handover of a single peppercorn by the Freemasons to the Governor of Bermuda" for the Old State House, built in 1620; the Governor arrives "accompanied by a 17-gun salute"; the peppercorn is presented "on a velvet pillow"; the custom dates to 1816. Wikipedia, "State House, Bermuda": leased to Lodge St George No. 200 for "one peppercorn" a year, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_House,_Bermuda . ↩