A bottle held in the hand
Paris, 23 November 1813. Three French chemists bring an Englishman a bottle.1
Britain and France were at war, but the English chemist Humphry Davy had come anyway, to collect a medal Napoleon had awarded him, with a young assistant called Michael Faraday.1, 2 Faraday called it "a strange venture", trusting themselves to a hostile country where "the slightest suspicion would be sufficient to separate us for ever from England, and perhaps from life." At the Paris police prefecture the clerks wrote Faraday down with a round chin, a brown beard, a large mouth and a great nose.1
The visitors were André-Marie Ampère, Nicolas Clément and Charles Desormes. Their bottle held small shining scales, a violet so deep it was almost black, with the look of pencil lead. Held in the hand, the bottle soon turned violet inside. Davy set to work on it with his travelling apparatus.1
It came from a Paris saltpetre works. Bernard Courtois made saltpetre for gunpowder, and the war had made wood ash scarce, so makers like him had turned to the ash of seaweed from Normandy and Brittany.3 Towards the end of 1811 the liquid from the seaweed ash was eating his copper vessels. Searching for the cause, he added sulphuric acid to what was left after the washing soda had been taken out, and a vapour of a beautiful violet rose and settled as crystals with the colour and lustre of graphite.3, 4
He found it made a powder that exploded when treated with ammonia. Then the busy saltpetre trade kept him out of the laboratory, and he handed the work to Clément.5 It was a new element. Its story would be told in necks.
Our English philosopher
Davy worked fast. So did the French chemist Joseph Louis Gay-Lussac, whom Clément had asked to carry the research on. On 6 December Gay-Lussac told the Institute that the substance was an element like chlorine. He proposed calling it iode, for the beautiful violet colour of its vapour.5
An English journal soon printed that the substance had been found two years before, "but such is the deplorable state of scientific men in France, that no account of it was published till the arrival of our English philosopher there."5
Gay-Lussac called it a strange assertion, and said Davy had seen his results more than a week before publishing his own.5 Davy had heard the French name as ione, and worried that it would give English compounds called "ionic" and "ionian", words English already used. He made it iodine, from the Greek for violet-coloured, to sit beside chlorine and fluorine.4
Both men named Courtois as the discoverer.3 Peace in 1815 brought cheap saltpetre from India. By 1822 he was making iodine and its salts, and struggling to make a living. The Academy of Sciences gave him 6,000 francs in 1831. He died in Paris in September 1838 with nothing to leave his widow and son, and went into a temporary grave. Nobody knows what became of his remains.3 A Paris journal's notice of his death said that if he had taken out "a certificate of invention, he would have realized a large estate."6
Burnt sponge
Geneva had long had a cure for goitre, the swollen thyroid in the front of the neck that was common in the city. It was burnt sea sponge.7, 8
Jean-François Coindet, chief physician of the city's hospital, had learned it as a student in Edinburgh.9 Then he read that the English doctor Richard Russell had given a seaweed for goitre, and seaweed ash was where iodine came from. Sponge came from the sea too, and in 1819 Andrew Fyfe had found iodine in it. Coindet guessed that iodine was the working part of both.7, 10
In the summer of 1820 Coindet reported that goitres began to soften and shrink within eight days. Iodine also, he found, stirred the appetite and acted as an aphrodisiac.9
A most virulent poison
Geneva took to it at once. In 1824 the doctor William Gairdner wrote that its reputation "flew over the city and neighbourhood," and people took it "with the utmost levity, with and without medical advice."7 By 1821 Coindet reckoned from the pharmacies' sales that about a thousand people had taken it.9
Then came the vomiting, the cramps in the legs, and a wasting "so rapid and so extreme as to strike terror into the minds both of patients and physician." A Geneva magistrate, "robust, corpulent, and of an athletic form," lost so much flesh that his oldest acquaintances did not know him.7 The Geneva physician Colladon reported that six of his nine iodine patients had fallen badly ill, and a lady of the city's high society died after two months of it.9 "Several persons paid for their temerity with their lives," Gairdner wrote.7 In January 1821 the city's doctors, surgeons and pharmacists agreed that iodine be sold only on prescription. Coindet blamed the reckless use, and said none of his own patients had come to serious harm.7, 9
Gairdner saw the poison at first hand in Paris. An English girl at boarding school there had a goitre, and her brother, a medical student, tried the new remedy on her. The swelling shrank to a small hard knot, and he pushed on to get rid of it. Gairdner was called one morning and found her in cramps, vomiting dark green streaked with blood. Within ten days her thighs were not much thicker than her wrists had been. Months later only opium eased her stomach spasms. Gairdner called her "a miserable monument of the effect of iodine."7
Mountain air on the Abendberg
In the worst Alpine valleys goitre came with cretinism, the old name for children whose bodies and minds were stunted by a thyroid that failed from birth, usually for lack of iodine.11
In 1841 a young Zurich doctor, Johann Jakob Guggenbühl, opened a home to cure cretin children on the Abendberg, an alp near Interlaken. He liked to tell how, on a walk through a village in Uri, he had met a young cretin kneeling before a holy picture and stammering a prayer, and seen that such children had souls to be woken.12
He treated them with mountain air and sunshine, gymnastics, baths and rubbing, herb teas and minerals, an iodine salt among them. Visitors came from all over Europe and wrote him up as the saviour of cretins, and the king of Bavaria gave money.12
Bern's inspectors were less sure. In 1849 they reported that two poor children the canton had placed there had never had cretinism at all. In 1858, after an Englishman complained of what he had seen, two doctors found that Guggenbühl had been away for six months without leaving anyone in charge. An anonymous attack in a Bern newspaper painted him as a swindler, and the Swiss naturalists' society voted unanimously to drop him. The home closed when he died in 1863.12
Wallets of flesh
Edward Whymper, the Englishman who made the first ascent of the Matterhorn, found the valley of Aosta fertile and charming, and knew no other so lovely with so many cretins.13, 14 He put their number at about two thousand and wrote of them, with the contempt of his day, as "more like brutes than men."13
In Britain, Whymper wrote, a goitre was thought a misfortune. In the Alps it was "a positive advantage", because it got a man out of military service. It was "worth so much hard cash."13
When Savoy became French in 1860, the new government found its acres many and its conscripts few.13, 15 It cleaned the villages, tested the water and gave schoolchildren iodine lozenges. Of five thousand children with goitre, it was said, two thousand were cured in eight years and two thousand more improved. More would have been, if parents had not fought it "in order to preserve the privilege of exemption from military service." The parents, Whymper sneered, preferred their "wallets of flesh", Shakespeare's words for the swellings at mountaineers' throats.13
The easiest disease to prevent
In 1915 the American pathologist David Marine called endemic goitre "the easiest known disease to prevent".10, 16 From 1917 he and O. P. Kimball set out to show it in Akron, Ohio, giving iodine to about five thousand schoolgirls aged eleven to eighteen. Far fewer of them developed goitres than girls who went without.10, 16, 17
Switzerland began putting iodine in its salt in 1922.18 In Michigan, doctors led by David Murray Cowie won over the salt makers, who could not afford to iodise salt for Michigan alone. Iodised salt went on sale in Michigan in May 1924, and Morton was selling it nationwide by autumn.17, 18
It killed people. A thyroid starved of iodine for years can be driven into overdrive when iodine suddenly floods in, sometimes fatally.17 Deaths from exophthalmic goitre, an overactive thyroid with bulging eyes, nearly doubled in the United States between 1921 and 1926, and in 1926 women died of it at six times the rate of men. Three economists estimated in 2013 that iodised salt caused at least ten thousand extra deaths between 1925 and 1942, mostly among older people. "The treatment designed to help goiter sufferers sometimes ended up killing them," they wrote.17
The same paper found that in the quarter of the country lowest in iodine, more of the young men born after the salt arrived went into the Army Air Forces in the Second World War, which drew men with above-average scores on the Army's tests. The authors read that as a large rise in intelligence.17
The emperor's seaweed
A 2012 review of iodine in the United States opens its history in "early Chinese medical writings in approximately 3600 B.C."19 A McGill University page says almost four thousand years ago, and a health news site 2700 BC.20, 21
The 2700 BC trail runs through a 2011 review in an Indian journal back to a 1960 history of goitre for the World Health Organization. There the Bratislava endocrinologist P. Langer wrote that one of the oldest references to goitre is "attributed to the legendary Chinese emperor Shen-Nung", whose herbal "is said to mention" seaweed for it. He added that there were "doubts about the very existence of Shen-Nung".10, 21
Today the name is written Shennong. He is the Divine Farmer of Chinese myth, said to have taught people farming and the use of herbs. The herbal that carries his name was written down in the first or second century AD, and the original no longer exists.22 In a Qing-dynasty scholar's reconstruction, its entry for seaweed says it is bitter and cold and governs goitre and lumps under the neck. A commentator of the early 300s described the plant as "like tangled hair, growing in the sea."23
The recipes come later, with names on them. Ge Hong was a Daoist alchemist who brewed elixirs of immortality on Mount Luofu in the 300s.24 His handbook of emergency remedies has one for a lump that suddenly forms under the neck and slowly grows into a goitre. It says to wash the salt out of the seaweed, put it in a silk bag, steep it in clear wine, and sip it, letting it trickle down little by little.25
The seaweed remedy for goitre is genuinely old, about two thousand years. The emperor said to have found it nearly five thousand years ago belongs to myth. Fifteen centuries after Ge Hong, a saltpetre maker in Paris poured acid on seaweed ash and saw the violet.
Salt on the table
Switzerland still iodises its salt a century on, and the iodine deficiency of its valleys is gone.18 The studies of iodine in people are in the Research tab.26
And the violet is still there. Hold a bottle of iodine crystals in a warm hand and the inside turns violet, as Faraday saw in Paris in 1813.1