NR-017Ingredient Atlas entry · Trace mineral

Iodine

I, a trace mineral

A saltpetre maker's corroded vats, a bottle shown to an Englishman in an enemy capital, a Geneva craze that killed, a doctor's mountain home for cretin children, and Alpine parents who wanted their sons' goitres kept. For two centuries people paid for every lesson iodine taught. The emperor said to have prescribed seaweed for goitre nearly five thousand years ago is a figure of myth.

  • Found in: seafood, milk and iodised salt
  • Most tested: 150 µg a day
  • Mostly in pregnancy and childhood
Raw white fish fillets on ice at a market stall
Raw white fish fillets on ice at a market stall. Photo by Geoffrey Moffett on Unsplash

A bottle held in the hand

Paris, 23 November 1813. Three French chemists bring an Englishman a bottle.1

Britain and France were at war, but the English chemist Humphry Davy had come anyway, to collect a medal Napoleon had awarded him, with a young assistant called Michael Faraday.1, 2 Faraday called it "a strange venture", trusting themselves to a hostile country where "the slightest suspicion would be sufficient to separate us for ever from England, and perhaps from life." At the Paris police prefecture the clerks wrote Faraday down with a round chin, a brown beard, a large mouth and a great nose.1

The visitors were André-Marie Ampère, Nicolas Clément and Charles Desormes. Their bottle held small shining scales, a violet so deep it was almost black, with the look of pencil lead. Held in the hand, the bottle soon turned violet inside. Davy set to work on it with his travelling apparatus.1

It came from a Paris saltpetre works. Bernard Courtois made saltpetre for gunpowder, and the war had made wood ash scarce, so makers like him had turned to the ash of seaweed from Normandy and Brittany.3 Towards the end of 1811 the liquid from the seaweed ash was eating his copper vessels. Searching for the cause, he added sulphuric acid to what was left after the washing soda had been taken out, and a vapour of a beautiful violet rose and settled as crystals with the colour and lustre of graphite.3, 4

He found it made a powder that exploded when treated with ammonia. Then the busy saltpetre trade kept him out of the laboratory, and he handed the work to Clément.5 It was a new element. Its story would be told in necks.

Our English philosopher

Davy worked fast. So did the French chemist Joseph Louis Gay-Lussac, whom Clément had asked to carry the research on. On 6 December Gay-Lussac told the Institute that the substance was an element like chlorine. He proposed calling it iode, for the beautiful violet colour of its vapour.5

An English journal soon printed that the substance had been found two years before, "but such is the deplorable state of scientific men in France, that no account of it was published till the arrival of our English philosopher there."5

Gay-Lussac called it a strange assertion, and said Davy had seen his results more than a week before publishing his own.5 Davy had heard the French name as ione, and worried that it would give English compounds called "ionic" and "ionian", words English already used. He made it iodine, from the Greek for violet-coloured, to sit beside chlorine and fluorine.4

Both men named Courtois as the discoverer.3 Peace in 1815 brought cheap saltpetre from India. By 1822 he was making iodine and its salts, and struggling to make a living. The Academy of Sciences gave him 6,000 francs in 1831. He died in Paris in September 1838 with nothing to leave his widow and son, and went into a temporary grave. Nobody knows what became of his remains.3 A Paris journal's notice of his death said that if he had taken out "a certificate of invention, he would have realized a large estate."6

Burnt sponge

Geneva had long had a cure for goitre, the swollen thyroid in the front of the neck that was common in the city. It was burnt sea sponge.7, 8

Jean-François Coindet, chief physician of the city's hospital, had learned it as a student in Edinburgh.9 Then he read that the English doctor Richard Russell had given a seaweed for goitre, and seaweed ash was where iodine came from. Sponge came from the sea too, and in 1819 Andrew Fyfe had found iodine in it. Coindet guessed that iodine was the working part of both.7, 10

In the summer of 1820 Coindet reported that goitres began to soften and shrink within eight days. Iodine also, he found, stirred the appetite and acted as an aphrodisiac.9

A most virulent poison

Geneva took to it at once. In 1824 the doctor William Gairdner wrote that its reputation "flew over the city and neighbourhood," and people took it "with the utmost levity, with and without medical advice."7 By 1821 Coindet reckoned from the pharmacies' sales that about a thousand people had taken it.9

Then came the vomiting, the cramps in the legs, and a wasting "so rapid and so extreme as to strike terror into the minds both of patients and physician." A Geneva magistrate, "robust, corpulent, and of an athletic form," lost so much flesh that his oldest acquaintances did not know him.7 The Geneva physician Colladon reported that six of his nine iodine patients had fallen badly ill, and a lady of the city's high society died after two months of it.9 "Several persons paid for their temerity with their lives," Gairdner wrote.7 In January 1821 the city's doctors, surgeons and pharmacists agreed that iodine be sold only on prescription. Coindet blamed the reckless use, and said none of his own patients had come to serious harm.7, 9

Gairdner saw the poison at first hand in Paris. An English girl at boarding school there had a goitre, and her brother, a medical student, tried the new remedy on her. The swelling shrank to a small hard knot, and he pushed on to get rid of it. Gairdner was called one morning and found her in cramps, vomiting dark green streaked with blood. Within ten days her thighs were not much thicker than her wrists had been. Months later only opium eased her stomach spasms. Gairdner called her "a miserable monument of the effect of iodine."7

Mountain air on the Abendberg

In the worst Alpine valleys goitre came with cretinism, the old name for children whose bodies and minds were stunted by a thyroid that failed from birth, usually for lack of iodine.11

In 1841 a young Zurich doctor, Johann Jakob Guggenbühl, opened a home to cure cretin children on the Abendberg, an alp near Interlaken. He liked to tell how, on a walk through a village in Uri, he had met a young cretin kneeling before a holy picture and stammering a prayer, and seen that such children had souls to be woken.12

He treated them with mountain air and sunshine, gymnastics, baths and rubbing, herb teas and minerals, an iodine salt among them. Visitors came from all over Europe and wrote him up as the saviour of cretins, and the king of Bavaria gave money.12

Bern's inspectors were less sure. In 1849 they reported that two poor children the canton had placed there had never had cretinism at all. In 1858, after an Englishman complained of what he had seen, two doctors found that Guggenbühl had been away for six months without leaving anyone in charge. An anonymous attack in a Bern newspaper painted him as a swindler, and the Swiss naturalists' society voted unanimously to drop him. The home closed when he died in 1863.12

Wallets of flesh

Edward Whymper, the Englishman who made the first ascent of the Matterhorn, found the valley of Aosta fertile and charming, and knew no other so lovely with so many cretins.13, 14 He put their number at about two thousand and wrote of them, with the contempt of his day, as "more like brutes than men."13

In Britain, Whymper wrote, a goitre was thought a misfortune. In the Alps it was "a positive advantage", because it got a man out of military service. It was "worth so much hard cash."13

When Savoy became French in 1860, the new government found its acres many and its conscripts few.13, 15 It cleaned the villages, tested the water and gave schoolchildren iodine lozenges. Of five thousand children with goitre, it was said, two thousand were cured in eight years and two thousand more improved. More would have been, if parents had not fought it "in order to preserve the privilege of exemption from military service." The parents, Whymper sneered, preferred their "wallets of flesh", Shakespeare's words for the swellings at mountaineers' throats.13

The easiest disease to prevent

In 1915 the American pathologist David Marine called endemic goitre "the easiest known disease to prevent".10, 16 From 1917 he and O. P. Kimball set out to show it in Akron, Ohio, giving iodine to about five thousand schoolgirls aged eleven to eighteen. Far fewer of them developed goitres than girls who went without.10, 16, 17

Switzerland began putting iodine in its salt in 1922.18 In Michigan, doctors led by David Murray Cowie won over the salt makers, who could not afford to iodise salt for Michigan alone. Iodised salt went on sale in Michigan in May 1924, and Morton was selling it nationwide by autumn.17, 18

It killed people. A thyroid starved of iodine for years can be driven into overdrive when iodine suddenly floods in, sometimes fatally.17 Deaths from exophthalmic goitre, an overactive thyroid with bulging eyes, nearly doubled in the United States between 1921 and 1926, and in 1926 women died of it at six times the rate of men. Three economists estimated in 2013 that iodised salt caused at least ten thousand extra deaths between 1925 and 1942, mostly among older people. "The treatment designed to help goiter sufferers sometimes ended up killing them," they wrote.17

The same paper found that in the quarter of the country lowest in iodine, more of the young men born after the salt arrived went into the Army Air Forces in the Second World War, which drew men with above-average scores on the Army's tests. The authors read that as a large rise in intelligence.17

The emperor's seaweed

A 2012 review of iodine in the United States opens its history in "early Chinese medical writings in approximately 3600 B.C."19 A McGill University page says almost four thousand years ago, and a health news site 2700 BC.20, 21

The 2700 BC trail runs through a 2011 review in an Indian journal back to a 1960 history of goitre for the World Health Organization. There the Bratislava endocrinologist P. Langer wrote that one of the oldest references to goitre is "attributed to the legendary Chinese emperor Shen-Nung", whose herbal "is said to mention" seaweed for it. He added that there were "doubts about the very existence of Shen-Nung".10, 21

Today the name is written Shennong. He is the Divine Farmer of Chinese myth, said to have taught people farming and the use of herbs. The herbal that carries his name was written down in the first or second century AD, and the original no longer exists.22 In a Qing-dynasty scholar's reconstruction, its entry for seaweed says it is bitter and cold and governs goitre and lumps under the neck. A commentator of the early 300s described the plant as "like tangled hair, growing in the sea."23

The recipes come later, with names on them. Ge Hong was a Daoist alchemist who brewed elixirs of immortality on Mount Luofu in the 300s.24 His handbook of emergency remedies has one for a lump that suddenly forms under the neck and slowly grows into a goitre. It says to wash the salt out of the seaweed, put it in a silk bag, steep it in clear wine, and sip it, letting it trickle down little by little.25

The seaweed remedy for goitre is genuinely old, about two thousand years. The emperor said to have found it nearly five thousand years ago belongs to myth. Fifteen centuries after Ge Hong, a saltpetre maker in Paris poured acid on seaweed ash and saw the violet.

Salt on the table

Switzerland still iodises its salt a century on, and the iodine deficiency of its valleys is gone.18 The studies of iodine in people are in the Research tab.26

And the violet is still there. Hold a bottle of iodine crystals in a warm hand and the inside turns violet, as Faraday saw in Paris in 1813.1

See what modern trials found

Myths and facts

In the record, or legend?

Every story you will read about this mineral, checked against the oldest source we could find.

  • Courtois found iodine by accident in seaweed ash in 1811

    In the record

    Davy and Gay-Lussac, both writing in 1814, credit Courtois and say he found it about two years before the November 1813 announcement. Davy adds that he was looking into his corroded vessels3, 4, 5

  • Iodine is named for the violet colour of its vapour

    In the record

    Gay-Lussac proposed iode in December 1813 for its violet vapour, and Davy made it iodine in English4, 5

  • Iodine killed people in Geneva's craze of 1820 and 1821

    In the record

    Gairdner, writing in 1824, says several people paid with their lives. Coindet said none of his own patients came to serious harm7, 9

  • Guggenbühl cured cretin children on the Abendberg

    Legend

    Bern's experts found children who were not cretins among his boarders, his claim of 300 cures was probably an inflated sum, and in 1858 the canton concluded that true cretinism could not be cured12

  • Alpine families kept goitres to keep their sons out of the army

    Likely

    Whymper reports it in 1871, with figures for the lozenge campaign that he gives as hearsay. We found no French official source13

  • Iodised salt raised America's IQ by 15 points

    Partly

    An economics paper inferred a rise of about that size only for the quarter of the population lowest in iodine, from the Army postings of men born after 1924. The authors say the national effect was much smaller (a press report put it at about 3.5 points), and the same paper estimated at least 10,000 deaths17

  • Chinese doctors treated goitre with seaweed in 3600 BC

    Wrong date

    The oldest text we found that names seaweed for goitre is a herbal written down in the first or second century AD. The 2700 BC date traces to a legendary emperor in a 1960 WHO history. The 3600 BC date comes from a 2000 article we could not read, and is older even than that emperor's legendary reign10, 19, 22, 23

In the record means a source from the time, or a scholar quoting one, says it. Likely means a named expert's reasoned identification. Told, not shown means one interested party says it and nothing checks it. Partly means a real event sits under a bigger story. Legend means the earliest source is far too late or missing. Wrong date means the event is real but the popular date doesn't match the record.

Notes

Every fact in the story points to one of these. Where a translation is ours, the note says so.

Show all 26 notes Hide the notes
  1. H. Bence Jones, The Life and Letters of Faraday, vol. 1 (London, 1870), Faraday's journal, https://archive.org/details/lifelettersoffar01joneuoft . P. 83, 13 October 1813, leaving London: "Tis indeed a strange venture at this time, to trust ourselves in a foreign and hostile country, where also so little regard is had to protestations and honour, that the slightest suspicion would be sufficient to separate us for ever from England, and perhaps from life." Pp. 93-94, Tuesday 9 November 1813, at the Préfecture de Police for a passport: "excepting Sir H. Davy's, there was not another free Englishman's passport down in the books"; "they ... described me in their books with a round chin, a brown beard, a large mouth, a great nose, &c. &c." Pp. 95-96, Tuesday 23 November 1813: "MM. Ampere, Clement, and Desormes came this morning to show Sir H. Davy a new substance, discovered, about two years ago, by M. Courtois, saltpetre manufacturer. The process by which it is obtained is not yet publicly known"; "when heated it rises in vapour of a deep violet colour"; "Sir Humphry Davy made various experiments on it with his travelling apparatus"; "It was in small scales with a shining lustre, colour deep violet, almost black; its appearance was very like plumbago"; "for when the bottle containing it was held in the hand, the interior soon became of a violet colour." Plumbago is graphite, the "lead" of a pencil. The full names Nicolas Clément and Charles-Bernard Desormes are from Swain (note 3), pp. 104, 108. ↩
  2. Wikipedia, "Humphry Davy", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humphry_Davy : "In October 1813, he and his wife, accompanied by Michael Faraday as his scientific assistant (also treated as a valet), travelled to France to collect the second edition of the prix du Galvanisme, a medal that Napoleon Bonaparte had awarded Davy for his electro-chemical work." ↩
  3. P. A. Swain, "Bernard Courtois (1777-1838), famed for discovering iodine (1811), and his life in Paris from 1798", Bulletin for the History of Chemistry 30 (2005): 103-111, https://www.ideals.illinois.edu/items/134711 (free PDF; the repository blocks automated checks). P. 108: "with France at war until 1815 and the saltpeter trade largely government controlled, there was a shortage of wood ashes for obtaining potassium nitrate from nitre-bed mother-liquors. As an alternative source of potassium salts the manufacturers turned to cheap soda kelp made from ashes of Normandy and Brittany seaweeds"; "one day towards the end of 1811 when he was investigating corrosion of his copper vessels and noticed an unusual purple vapor given off"; Clément announced it to the Institute on 29 November 1813. P. 109: "Bernard was clearly acknowledged as the discoverer of iodine by these distinguished chemists"; "importation of cheap Indian saltpeter began in 1815", but "he was still a salpêtrier when his son Louis was" born in 1816, and "He first appeared as a manufacturer of high quality iodine and its salts in 1822"; "Bernard found it difficult to make a living as a manufacturer and salesman"; in 1831 the Académie royale des sciences "awarded him 6,000 francs as part of its Montyon prize"; "when he died at his lodgings on September 27, 1838 at the age of 62, he left no assets for his widow and son. He was buried in a temporary grave for five years at the cemetery of the North, but what finally happened to his remains is not known." Swain's account of the saltpetre trade (p. 103) is of saltpetre made for gunpowder. ↩
  4. H. Davy, "Some experiments and observations on a new substance which becomes a violet coloured gas by heat", Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 104 (1814): 74-93, read 20 January 1814, https://archive.org/details/philosophicaltra1041roya (publisher's page https://doi.org/10.1098/rstl.1814.0007 blocks automated checks). P. 74: "This substance was accidentally discovered about two years ago by M. Courtois, a manufacturer of saltpetre at Paris. In his processes for procuring soda from the ashes of sea weeds, (cendres de vareck) he found the metallic vessels much corroded; and in searching for the cause of this effect, he made the discovery. The substance is procured from the ashes, after the extraction of the carbonate of soda, with great facility, and merely by the action of sulphuric acid:—when the acid is concentrated, so as to produce much heat, the substance appears as a vapour of a beautiful violet colour, which condenses in crystals having the colour and the lustre of plumbago." P. 75: "M. Ampere had the goodness to give me some of this substance." P. 91: "The name ione has been proposed in France for this new substance from its colour in the gaseous state ... The name ione, in English, would lead to confusion, for its compounds would be called ionic and ionian. By terming it iodine, from ἰώδης, violaceous, this confusion will be avoided, and the name will be more analogous to chlorine and fluorine." The archive.org text layer garbles the Greek and "ione"; read from the page image. ↩
  5. J. L. Gay-Lussac, "Mémoire sur l'iode", Annales de chimie 91 (1814): 5-160, read 1 August 1814, https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_Efms0Fri1CQC . Translation ours. P. 5: his notes of 6 and 20 December 1813 on "la substance découverte par M. Courtois, et à laquelle j'ai proposé de donner le nom d'iode, à cause de la belle couleur violette de sa vapeur" (the substance discovered by M. Courtois, to which I proposed giving the name iode, because of the beautiful violet colour of its vapour). Pp. 118-121, "Note historique sur la découverte de l'iode": Courtois had made the discovery nearly two years before Clément announced it to the Institute on 29 November 1813; he observed "particulièrement celle qu'il a de former une poudre très-fulminante, lorsqu'on le traite par l'ammoniaque" (in particular its forming a highly explosive powder when treated with ammonia); "détourné des travaux de laboratoire par les soins qu'exigeait une fabrication très-active de salpêtre ... il engagea M. Clément à continuer ses recherches" (kept from laboratory work by the demands of a very busy saltpetre business, he asked Clément to carry on the research); Clément showed it to Chaptal and Ampère, then to Davy; p. 120, Clément read his note to the Institute "et la termina en annonçant que j'allais les continuer" (and ended it by announcing that I would continue them); Gay-Lussac quotes, as "l'étrange assertion" (the strange assertion), the journal of Nicholson and Tilloch, no. 189, p. 69, in English: "It appears that this gaz (l'iode) was discovered above two years ago; but such is the deplorable state of scientific men in France, that no account of it was published till the arrival of our english philosopher there"; on 6 December he read a note establishing "que cette substance est un corps simple analogue au chlore" (that this substance is an element analogous to chlorine); "il est certain que M. Davy n'a publié ses résultats que plus de huit jours après avoir connu les miens" (it is certain that M. Davy published his results only more than eight days after learning mine). The scan's text layer prints 1813 as "181 5"; read the years from the page image. The quotation's own words ("our english philosopher") show the journal was English; we did not see the journal itself. ↩
  6. Journal de chimie médicale, de pharmacie et de toxicologie, vol. 2 (1838), p. 6 (as Wikipedia cites it), as translated in The American Journal of Pharmacy 11 (1839): 168, quoted in Wikipedia, "Bernard Courtois", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernard_Courtois : "Bernard Courtois, the discoverer of iodine, died at Paris the 27th of September, 1838, leaving his widow without fortune. If, on making this discovery, Courtois had taken out a certificate of invention, he would have realized a large estate." We did not see either journal page. ↩
  7. W. Gairdner, Essay on the Effects of Iodine on the Human Constitution (London: Thomas and George Underwood, 1824), Project Gutenberg #68406, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/68406 , pp. 1-15 of the essay. Coindet "found that the fucus vesiculosus had been recommended by Russel in the cure of goitre. From this plant ... the soda, with which iodine is generally found combined, is extracted. As the sponge, whose virtues have long been established by certain experience at Geneva, is also a maritime plant, Dr. Coindet suspected that iodine might be the active principle of them both"; "a place where that disease is extremely common"; "Its reputation flew over the city and neighbourhood of Geneva, and it was taken with the utmost levity, with and without medical advice. Dr. Coindet justly deplores this abuse"; "several persons paid for their temerity with their lives, and many were irreparably injured in their health. Every day brought to light some new catastrophe, the effect of iodine; and in the course of a short time its name was associated with the idea of a most intractable and virulent poison"; "violent and incessant vomiting", "strong spasms of the back and legs"; "The emaciation ... is so rapid and so extreme as to strike terror into the minds both of patients and physician. A magistrate of Geneva, high in office, robust, corpulent, and of an athletic form, was so much reduced in flesh, that he was not known by his oldest acquaintances." The English girl at a Paris boarding school, whose brother "was prosecuting the study of medicine there": "A small hard knot only remained ... and the desire to get rid of this little tumour was the cause of the remedy having been pushed too far"; "I was sent for early in the morning"; "The matter vomited was of a dark green colour, streaked with blood"; "During ten days she remained in a very doubtful state"; "her thighs were not much thicker than her wrists, when in health"; "By the steady and very liberal use of opium, she recovered to a certain degree; but when I last saw her, many months after her illness, she remained subject to frequent violent spasms of the stomach, during which opium alone gave her relief"; "She was indeed a miserable monument of the effect of iodine"; months later "The few moments of ease she knew were purchased by large doses of laudanum"; he heard later that she was much better. Footnote: "the chemists are much in the habit of substituting charcoal for burnt sponge, of which an undeniable proof is the fact, that burnt sponge is sold at an inferior rate to the same article before it has undergone the process of combustion"; he sent prescriptions for hydriodate of potass to several London chemists, which "were said to have been made up", and found "they were not even aware of the existence of such a drug". Gairdner gives the explanation of the charcoal as told to him "from a quarter in which I can place implicit reliance". The Gutenberg text has no page numbers; locate the passages by these quotations. ↩
  8. Wikipedia, "Goitre", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goitre : "a swelling in the neck resulting from an enlarged thyroid gland". ↩
  9. "Jean-Francois Coindet (1774-1834)", Milestones in European Thyroidology, European Thyroid Association, https://www.eurothyroid.com/about/met/coindet.html : the Edinburgh "course in Materia Medica ... included the use of burnt sponge as an effective treatment for struma or bronchocoele (as goiters were then called)"; Coindet studied medicine in Edinburgh from 1792 and was "Medecin-Chef in the Geneva Hospital, a position he held from 1809 to 1831"; he "first communicated the results of his iodine treatment for goitre to the Société Helvétique des Sciences Naturelles in Geneva on July 21, 1820"; his solutions "were prepared by Jean Baptiste Dumas, a poor 18 year-old boy who arrived barefoot from Alès in the south of France, but who later became Professor of Chemistry in Collège de France and a member of the French Academy"; "softening and shrinking of goitres occurred after 8 days"; "iodine had a general stimulating effect on the appetite, the uterus (?), acted as an aphrodisiac"; "Based on the sales of iodine in the pharmacies of Geneva, Coindet estimated that in 1821, 1000 people had taken iodine"; J.-P. Colladon "reported that among 9 patients he had treated with iodine, 6 had developed severe ill-effects"; "a lady from the high ranks of Geneva's society had died of a respiratory problem ascribed to 2 month's treatment with iodine"; Coindet "had treated 150 patients ... and had not observed serious complications in any of them"; "In January of 1821, the local authorities of Geneva called upon an assembly of physicians, surgeons and pharmacists to interdict the sale of iodine preparations in the absence of a medical prescription, a decision which they endorsed." Langer (note 10, p. 21) dates the lecture to 25 July 1820. ↩
  10. P. Langer, "History of goitre", in Endemic Goitre, WHO Monograph Series no. 44 (Geneva: World Health Organization, 1960), pp. 9-25, https://iris.who.int/handle/10665/38822 (free PDF). P. 9: "One of the oldest references to goitre is attributed to the legendary Chinese emperor Shen-Nung (2838-2698 B.C.), who, in his book Pen-Ts'ao Tsing (A treatise on herbs and roots) is said to mention the seaweed Sargassum as an efficacious remedy against goitre. However, there are doubts about the very existence of Shen-Nung as an historical personality"; Langer's sources for it are M. Jantsch, Der Kropf und seine Behandlung (1948), and P. P. Popovitsh (1959), which we could not read. Pp. 9-10: "The famous Chinese medical writer Ge-Khun ... described a mode of treatment for goitre consisting of Sargassum weeds and the weed Laminaria japonica". P. 21: Coindet "was prompted to make this suggestion through his discovery that Fucus vesiculosus had been used by Richard Russell (1700-1771) in England for the treatment of goitre and that in 1819 iodine had also been found by Andrew Fyfe (1795-1891) in sea sponges, long famed as a goitre remedy. He suspected that iodine was the active substance in both cases." P. 23: "David Marine, who in 1915 declared that 'endemic goitre is the easiest known disease to prevent'"; "The first large-scale trials with iodine were carried out in 1916-1920 by Marine and Kimball in Akron, Ohio, USA, when they gave to about 5000 schoolgirls, aged between 11 and 18" iodine "for 10 days each spring and autumn"; "The results of these trials demonstrated conclusively the prophylactic value of iodine". Langer dates the Akron trials 1916-1920; notes 16 and 17 give 1917 for the start. On p. 9 Langer also dates a second book, the Huang Ti Nei Ching, to 2697-2597 B.C., so a "2700 BC" date could come from either attribution. He dates Ge-Khun to between A.D. 317 and 419, later than the dates in note 24. Langer worked at the Endocrinological Institute of the Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava (p. 9). ↩
  11. Wikipedia, "Congenital hypothyroidism", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congenital_hypothyroidism : untreated, it "can lead to growth failure and permanent intellectual disability"; "The word 'cretinism' is an old term for the state of mental and physical retardation resulting from untreated congenital hypothyroidism, usually due to iodine deficiency from birth because of low iodine levels in the soil and local food sources ... It is now deprecated." The source says "from birth". Whymper (note 13) writes that "crétins are very generally goitrous". The story uses the old word because the people in it did. ↩
  12. S. Tappy, "L'Abendberg, établissement pour la guérison des enfants crétins: vie et mort d'une controverse (1841-1863)", Revue suisse d'histoire 72 (2022): 5-21, https://doi.org/10.24894/2296-6013.00094 (free PDF at https://www.sgg-ssh.ch/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/001_tappy_artikel_szg_1_2022.pdf ). Translation ours. P. 7: Guggenbühl, born in 1816 at Meilen in the canton of Zurich, finished medicine in Bern in 1836; that year, on a walk in a village in Uri, "il aurait été bouleversé par sa rencontre avec un jeune crétin, agenouillé devant une image pieuse et bafouillant une prière" (he is said to have been overwhelmed by meeting a young cretin kneeling before a holy picture and stammering a prayer); cretins had a soul, and his mission would be to wake those souls; Tappy calls the anecdote a founding myth, first told in his 1840 publication. He bought the Abendberg, "un alpage au sud-ouest d'Interlaken" (an alp south-west of Interlaken), in 1840 and opened the home the next year. P. 8: visitors "de toute l'Europe" published accounts "érigeant Guggenbühl en sauveur des crétins" (making Guggenbühl the saviour of cretins). P. 9, note 17: the 1849 report on two poor children placed there at the canton's cost, "es ist thatsächlich nachgewiesen, dass sie nie von Cretinismus behaftet waren" (it is actually proven that they were never affected by cretinism). P. 9: the last inspection, by Drs Vogt and Verdat in 1858, followed "les plaintes d'un Anglais effrayé par ce qu'il a vu" (the complaints of an Englishman frightened by what he saw) and found that "Guggenbühl s'est absenté durant six mois sans nommer de remplaçant" (had been absent for six months without appointing a replacement); note 23, the king of Bavaria was one of the donors. Pp. 9-10: an anonymous serial in the Bern newspaper Der Bund (17-20 June 1858) treated him as a swindler ("escroc") running "persönliche Geld- und Ehrenspekulation"; in August 1858 the Swiss Society of Natural Sciences voted "à l'unanimité" to withdraw all support; the home closed on his death in 1863 (note 29). Pp. 13-14: the treatment rested on "l'air pur de la montagne, l'exposition au soleil, des exercices de gymnastique, des bains et des frictions, mais aussi des tisanes de plantes médicinales et des extraits de minéraux dont l'iodure de potassium" (pure mountain air, sunshine, gymnastics, baths and rubbing, but also herb teas and mineral extracts including potassium iodide). P. 15: from 1844 Bern's experts found "non-crétins" among the boarders. Pp. 14-15: in 1858 Bern's interior department concluded that "eigentlicher Cretinismus nicht heilbar sei" (true cretinism is not curable). P. 16: in 1850 he claimed that 300 children had left the Abendberg cured, but "il a probablement additionné le nombre de pensionnaires année par année" (he probably added up the number of boarders year by year). Note 46: his medical methods were soon criticised, but "son approche pédagogique est aujourd'hui reconnue comme pionnière" (his teaching approach is recognised today as pioneering). ↩
  13. E. Whymper, Scrambles Amongst the Alps in the Years 1860-'69 (1871), chapter on the valley of Aosta, Project Gutenberg #41234, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/41234 : "there are places where the proportion of crétins to population is ... even greater than in the valley of Aosta; but I have never seen or heard of a valley so fertile and so charming—of one which, apart from crétinism, leaves so agreeable an impression upon the wayfarer—where equal numbers are reduced to a condition which any respectable ape might despise"; "these distorted, mindless beings, more like brutes than men"; note: "the valley of Aosta contained about 2000 crétins", and one in twenty-five in the Valais; "In this country the possession of a goître is considered a misfortune rather than otherwise ... In France, Italy and Switzerland it is a positive advantage to be goîtred, as it secures exemption from military service. A goître is a thing to be prized, exhibited, preserved—it is worth so much hard cash"; "When Savoy was annexed to France the administration took stock of the resources of its new territory, and soon discovered that although the acres were many the conscripts would be few"; it took measures "to cleanse the villages, to analyze the waters ... and to give to children who came to school lozenges containing small doses of iodine. It is said that out of five thousand goitrous children who were so treated in the course of eight years, two thousand were cured, and the condition of two thousand others was improved; and that the number of cures would have been greater if the parents 'had not opposed the care of the government, in order to preserve the privilege of exemption from military service.' These benighted creatures refused the marshal's bâton and preferred their 'wallets of flesh!'" Whymper believed goitre came from "chemically impure water, and especially hard water". "Wallets of flesh" is from Shakespeare, The Tempest, Act 3, scene 3, where Gonzalo recalls tales of "mountaineers / Dew-lapp'd like bulls, whose throats had hanging at 'em / Wallets of flesh" (Project Gutenberg #23042, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/23042 ). The figure of about 2,000 is one Whymper gives, not a count of his own. ↩
  14. Wikipedia, "Edward Whymper", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Whymper : "an English mountaineer ... best known for his 1865 first ascent of the Matterhorn." ↩
  15. Wikipedia, "Treaty of Turin (1860)", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Turin_(1860) : concluded "on 24 March 1860", the treaty by which "the Duchy of Savoy and the County of Nice were annexed to France". ↩
  16. Wikipedia, "David Marine", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Marine : "an American pathologist ... remembered for his trial, with O. P. Kimball as his assistant, of the effect of giving iodide to a large group of schoolgirls in Akron, Ohio from 1917 to 1922, which greatly reduced their development of goiter, and resulted in the iodization of table salt." ↩
  17. J. Feyrer, D. Politi and D. N. Weil, "The Cognitive Effects of Micronutrient Deficiency: Evidence from Salt Iodization in the United States", NBER Working Paper 19233 (July 2013), https://www.nber.org/papers/w19233 (published in the Journal of the European Economic Association 15 (2017): 355-387, free at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6919660/ ). Pp. 11-12 (working paper): a committee chaired by Cowie ran Michigan's campaign; the salt producers found "it would be financially impossible to separate the salt intended for the Michigan market and then add iodine to it. Instead, the Salt Producers Association decided to launch iodized salt nationwide"; "in May 1924, Michigan was the first state to introduce iodized salt"; "Morton Salt Company, the largest producer in the country at the time, began selling iodized salt on a nationwide basis in the fall of 1924"; footnote: "The first such experiment took place in Akron, Ohio in 1917, under the direction of David Marine and O.P. Kimball." Pp. 5-6: "Chronic iodine deficiency, followed by a sudden large intake of iodine, can cause iodine-induced hyperthyroidism, which can be fatal"; "We estimate that at least 10,000 deaths over the period 1925-1942 were the result of iodization. These deaths affected mostly older age groups, which had been deficient for a longer period of time." P. 32: "the treatment designed to help goiter sufferers sometimes ended up killing them"; deaths from exophthalmic goitre ("an enlargement of the thyroid accompanied by bulging of the eyes, which is sign of hyperthyroidism"): "Between 1921 and 1926 the death rate nearly doubled from 2.1 to 4 per 100,000"; "In 1926 death rates were over 6 times as high for women as for men." Abstract and p. 5: "for the one quarter of the population most deficient in iodine this intervention raised IQ by approximately one standard deviation", inferred from the higher share of men born after iodization in low-iodine counties who were assigned to the Army Air Forces, which drew recruits with above-average Army General Classification Test scores; "The average level of iodine deficiency in the US was significantly lower than in the highest regions, so the overall effect in the US was much more modest." A standard deviation on an IQ scale is 15 points; a 2013 press report put the national gain at 3.5 points: M. Nisen, "How Adding Iodine To Salt Resulted In A Decade's Worth Of IQ Gains For The United States", Business Insider, 22 July 2013, https://www.businessinsider.com/iodization-effect-on-iq-2013-7 . ↩
  18. Wikipedia, "Iodised salt", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iodised_salt : Switzerland "was the first country to introduce iodized salt"; successful village trials led, "starting in 1922, to the adoption of iodized salt throughout the Swiss cantons"; "Today, iodized salt continues to be used in Switzerland, where historically endemic iodine deficiency has been eradicated"; David Murray Cowie, a professor of paediatrics at the University of Michigan, "led the United States to adopt the Swiss practice"; "On May 1, 1924, iodized salt was sold commercially in Michigan. By the fall of 1924, Morton Salt Company began distributing iodized salt nationally." ↩
  19. A. M. Leung, L. E. Braverman and E. N. Pearce, "History of U.S. iodine fortification and supplementation", Nutrients 4 (2012): 1740-1746, section 2, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3509517/ : "Early Chinese medical writings in approximately 3600 B.C. were the first to record the decreases in goiter size upon ingestion of seaweed and burnt sea sponge." Its source is L. Rosenfeld, "Discovery and early uses of iodine", Journal of Chemical Education 77 (2000): 984-987, which we could not read. ↩
  20. J. Schwarcz, "What Is The Role of Iodine in Thyroid Function?", McGill Office for Science and Society, 20 March 2017, https://www.mcgill.ca/oss/article/health-history-you-asked/what-role-iodine-thyroid-function : "Almost four thousand years ago Chinese medical writings described the troublesome swelling of the neck we know as goiter and noted the remedy which had somehow been arrived at through trial and error." The page opens with an unsourced prescription in quotation marks: "Take a dose of seaweed or burnt sea sponge twice a year!" ↩
  21. News-Medical, "Goiter History", https://www.news-medical.net/health/Goiter-History.aspx : "There have been references to goiter in historical Chinese texts as far back as 2700 BC ... Burnt sponges and seaweeds were used to treat the condition as far back as 1600 BC." A. K. Niazi, S. Kalra, A. Irfan and A. Islam, "Thyroidology over the ages", Indian Journal of Endocrinology and Metabolism 15, suppl. 2 (2011): S121-S126, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3169859/ : "References to goiter it have been seen in texts dating back to 2700 BC", citing Langer (note 10), p. 9; "It is said that the Chinese were aware of the enlarged thyroids from around 2700 BC." A 2021 Taiwanese review repeats "as early as 2700 BC": C.-H. Lee and J.-H. Chiu, "Goiter disease in traditional Chinese medicine", Journal of the Chinese Medical Association 84 (2021): 577-579, https://doi.org/10.1097/JCMA.0000000000000547 (the publisher's page blocks automated checks). ↩
  22. Wikipedia, "Shennong", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shennong : "variously translated as 'Divine Farmer' ... a mythological Chinese ruler", thought "to have taught the ancient Chinese not only their practices of agriculture, but also the use of herbal medicine". Wikipedia, "Shennong Bencaojing", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shennong_Bencaojing : "Researchers believe the text is a compilation of oral traditions, written between the first and second centuries AD ... The original text no longer exists." ↩
  23. Shennong bencao jing (神農本草經), as reconstructed by the Qing scholar Sun Xingyan, Chinese Wikisource, https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/神農本草經_(孫星衍) , entry 海藻 (haizao, seaweed). Translation ours. "味苦,寒。主癭瘤氣,頸下核" (bitter and cold; governs goitre swellings and lumps under the neck). Sun's commentary quotes Guo Pu (276-324) on the plant: "如亂發,生海中" (like tangled hair, it grows in the sea). ↩
  24. Wikipedia, "Ge Hong", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ge_Hong : born 283, died 343 or 364; author of the Emergency Formulae at an Elbow's Length (Zhouhou beiji fang); "he went to Mount Luofu to live in seclusion. There, he gathered herbal medicine, refined elixirs, and documented numerous cases of illness", and later returned "in seclusion in Mount Luofu to refine elixirs". The elixirs were for long life and immortality (the page links "Pill of Immortality"). ↩
  25. Wang Tao, Waitai miyao (外臺秘要, 752), juan 23, quoting Ge Hong's Zhouhou handbook, Chinese Wikisource (Siku quanshu text), https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/外臺秘要方_(四庫全書本)/卷23 . Translation ours. "肘後療頸下卒結囊漸大欲成癭海藻酒方" (from the Zhouhou: for a lump that suddenly forms under the neck and gradually grows into a goitre, seaweed wine); "海藻去鹹 ... 清酒 ... 以絹袋盛海藻酒漬 ... 稍稍含咽之" (seaweed with the salt removed ... clear wine ... put the seaweed in a silk bag and steep it in the wine ... hold it in the mouth and swallow it little by little). The amounts and timings in the recipe are left out here. ↩
  26. Nooroots Ingredient Atlas, iodine, Research tab, /pages/iodine-research : "This page covers only studies in people that measured thinking, memory, mood, stress, sleep, energy or quality of life, where iodine is studied mostly for thinking and development in children and in pregnancy." ↩