A girl called Anna
Basel, 1554. A doctor's book of letters goes to press.1
One letter answers a worried father. He had written to Johannes Lange, physician to the princes of the Rhine Palatinate, about his eldest daughter, Anna. She was old enough to marry. Suitors of good family and fortune were asking for her, and he was turning every one of them away, because she was too weak.1
Nobody could tell him why. One doctor said heartburn, another palpitations, another a choking womb, and some blamed her liver. The father no longer knew what to do.1
So Lange went over the signs her father had sent. Last year Anna's cheeks and lips had bloomed rose-red. Now her face was pale, as if drained of blood. Her heart shook at the slightest movement, the arteries at her temples throbbed, and dancing or climbing the stairs left her fighting for breath. She turned from food, meat above all, and by night her legs swelled around the ankles.1
Lange was amazed that the family's doctors had missed it. That they could not name it mattered nothing, for many illnesses lack a name but not a cure. Since this one struck virgins, it could be called the virgins' disease. The matrons of Brabant called it the white fever, for the pallor, and the love fever, because, as Ovid said, every lover is pale.1
He blamed menstrual blood that could not get out and flowed back towards the heart and liver. The cure came from Hippocrates. Open a vein, and have girls with the disease live with men and lie with them as soon as possible, because if they conceived they would get well. "So take heart," Lange told the father. "Give your daughter in marriage. I will gladly come to the wedding myself."1
The virgins' disease would trouble doctors for nearly four hundred years. In English it was the green sickness, and to doctors chlorosis.2, 3, 4 When Shakespeare's Juliet refuses the husband her father has chosen, Capulet roars at her, "Out, you green-sickness carrion! out, you baggage! You tallow-face!"5
The spring in the wood
Fifty years after Lange, a young English lord tasted iron in a wood. Thomas Benge Burr told the story in 1766, in his history of Tunbridge Wells, the spa that grew up around that spring.6
Dudley, Lord North, was a courtier in the circle of Prince Henry, the king's son, and had wrecked his fortune and his health with pleasure. At twenty-four he fell into a lingering, wasting illness that his doctors could not touch. In the spring of 1606 they sent him for the air to Eridge, a hunting lodge in one of the wildest parts of Sussex.6
He grew weary of the place. His friends talked him into six more weeks, and he only got worse. He set off for London more desperate than ever, with nothing ahead but a grave in the first bloom of manhood.6
His road ran through a wood near Tunbridge. There he passed a spring with a shining scum on its surface and an ochre crust marking its course to a brook. He climbed down from his carriage, sent a servant to borrow a wooden bowl from a cottage close by, and drank. The water tasted of iron. He had it bottled for his doctors.6
The next spring he came back to drink it. Burr says that after about three months he returned to London cured for good. He threw himself straight back into every pleasure of the age.6 He lived sixty more years.6, 7
Water like his was called chalybeate, from the Greek word for steel. That word came from the Chalybes of northern Anatolia, whom Greek writers counted among the first ironsmiths.8
Steel in Rhenish wine
In 1682 the London physician Thomas Sydenham set out how he treated the green sickness. He counted it a form of hysteria.3
First he bled the patient. Then he purged her for three or four mornings running, and she got worse, so he warned her not to lose heart. Only after that came the iron, which he called steel, for thirty days.3
"To the worn-out and languid blood it gives a spur or fillip," he wrote. The pulse grew strong, the skin warm, and the face, "no longer pale and deathlike", took on "a fresh ruddy colour".3
He liked his steel taken plain, and blamed the chemists' fussing, their "officious sedulity", for making it weaker. Next best was a syrup of iron or steel filings steeped in cold Rhenish wine, then strained, sugared and boiled down. And when iron failed, there were the strong chalybeate waters "like those of Tunbridge".3
A magnet over burnt blood
Bologna, the 1740s. Vincenzo Menghini taught medicine there, and he wanted to settle an argument. Doctors gave iron for many diseases, but they could not agree whether it worked on the body's solid parts or its fluids, or ever got past the gut at all.9
His plan was to bring in dogs from all over, feed them for forty days on food stuffed with iron, and compare their blood before and after.9
He never got that far. Before the feeding began, he had five ounces of blood drawn from the thigh vein of the strongest dog and burned it in a clay pot over a fierce open fire. A little ash weighing twenty-four grains was left. When he brought a magnetised knife near, bright specks leapt up to meet the blade. Held closer, it drew the rust-red grains too, and in the end all of it but a single grain followed the magnet.9
He could hardly believe it. As far as he knew, nobody had ever found so much iron in an animal's blood, or even imagined it there. Perhaps the pot or some iron tool had shed it. So he set the dogs' iron diet aside and started again.9
He burned the blood of four of the dogs, then of oxen, calves and pigs. He had four pounds let from a fine strong horse, "not for any illness of the horse, but for the sake of the experiments". He burned the blood of six men and six women. "Who would believe," he wrote, "that I slaughtered nearly a hundred eels" to collect one ounce of their blood? He burned the bones of a man killed by a terrible wound.9
Iron was richest in the blood, and scarcer in flesh, bone and fat. He had hunted it through every other part of the body "with long and wearisome labour" before he found its seat at last, in the red globules themselves, the red cells of the blood. He showed the academy in Bologna, holding the magnet over burnt blood, flesh and bone, and the work was printed in 1746.9, 10 The red of blood is the red of the iron-rich haemoglobin packed into those cells.11
Joséphine's pills
Beaucaire, in the south of France, 12 April 1828. Sixteen-year-old Joséphine Julien is put in the care of Pierre Blaud, chief physician of the town's hospital.12
For two years her complexion, once glowing and fresh, had been fading to a yellowish green. Her periods had stopped, and a dark gloom had taken the place of her high spirits. She had cramps, a pounding head and a racing heart, and climbing left her short of breath. Travel, country air, calming drugs, drugs to bring on her periods and iron in several forms had all been tried.12
At first sight Blaud thought she had some deep disease beyond the reach of medicine. Then he recognised chlorosis.12
Iron had always been counted its specific remedy. Blaud thought it failed so often because doctors gave too little of it, and in a form the gut would not take up. His pills mixed sulphate of iron with potash. Inside the pill the two reacted and made carbonate of iron, a form he trusted the body to absorb.12
Within a week Joséphine was hungry again and her heart had calmed. He called her cured on 14 May, the thirty-second day. Her periods soon came back, and her health held.12
In his patients a light rosy tint came into the skin first, above all in the face. The eyes got back their shine. Then everything else came right, "as if by miracle". And it was not only girls at puberty, he warned. Chlorosis struck every age, and men too.12
The disease that vanished
Early in the twentieth century, the green sickness disappeared.2
In 1984 the family doctor and medical historian Irvine Loudon argued that it had never been one disease. The girls diagnosed in the late 1800s mostly had a form of anaemia, the kind with pale, iron-poor blood, perhaps from stomach ulcers and poor diet. In earlier centuries many had a disorder of the mind much like anorexia, and it was this one that went by the old names, the virgins' disease and the love fever. He even thought the green may first have meant innocence, not the colour of the skin.13, 14
The decimal point that never slipped
In the Christmas issue of the British Medical Journal in 1981, the haematologist Terence Hamblin told a story about spinach. As he told it, spinach was found in the 1890s to be as good a source of iron as red meat. Then German chemists in the 1930s showed that "the original workers had put the decimal point in the wrong place and made a tenfold overestimate of its value." He added, "For a source of iron Popeye would have been better off chewing the cans."15, 17
It was the perfect tale of careless science. It spread through academic papers, newspapers, magazines, television and myth-busting websites. One spice seller's website still tells it today, with a German chemist slipping his decimal point in 1870.15, 16
In 2010 Mike Sutton, a British criminologist, went back through the old papers and found no slip anywhere. He asked Hamblin, who could not remember where he had read it but was sure he had not made it up.15
A reader of Sutton's article, Bonnie Taylor-Blake, pointed him to the nutritionist Arnold Bender. In a lecture in 1972 Bender had said the fame of spinach "may well have grown from a misplaced decimal point". In a 1977 letter to The Spectator, he wrote that it "appears to have been based on" one. Four years later Hamblin turned the guess into a fact.15, 17
For the old, too-high figures, Sutton pointed instead to iron from laboratory equipment getting into the samples, and to figures for dried spinach read as if they were fresh. The right value was known well before Popeye.15, 18
And Popeye never ate spinach for its iron. In a 1932 strip by his creator, Elzie Segar, the sailor munches it and declares that "spinach is full of vitamin A an' tha's what makes hoomans strong and hefty."15, 18
Hamblin took it well. "Thanks for pointing out my mistake of 29 years ago," he wrote on Sutton's web page. "I thought it was in Reader's Digest." A Reader's Digest book did print the story in 1988, seven years after he did.15
Iron in the bread
In Great Britain the iron now goes into the flour. By law the miller must top it up wherever the grain falls short of the legal minimum.19 Lange's cure for Anna was a wedding. Sydenham's was steel and waters like Lord North's, and Blaud's was a pill. What studies in people have found since is in the Research tab.
Every white loaf baked from that flour carries a little iron, four and a half centuries after a doctor told a worried father to find his pale daughter a husband.