NR-018Ingredient Atlas entry · Mineral

Iron

Fe, a mineral

A doctor's letter about a pale girl called Anna, a courtier's borrowed bowl of spring water, a professor's magnet over burnt blood and a town doctor's pills for a girl turning green. For centuries doctors gave iron to pale young women and watched the colour come back to their faces, long before anyone could say why. The best-known iron story, about spinach and a slipped decimal point, has a slip of its own.

  • Given by mouth or by drip
  • Given as salts, fortified foods or a drip
  • Mostly people with low iron or anaemia
Dark metallic iron ore crystals

A girl called Anna

Basel, 1554. A doctor's book of letters goes to press.1

One letter answers a worried father. He had written to Johannes Lange, physician to the princes of the Rhine Palatinate, about his eldest daughter, Anna. She was old enough to marry. Suitors of good family and fortune were asking for her, and he was turning every one of them away, because she was too weak.1

Nobody could tell him why. One doctor said heartburn, another palpitations, another a choking womb, and some blamed her liver. The father no longer knew what to do.1

So Lange went over the signs her father had sent. Last year Anna's cheeks and lips had bloomed rose-red. Now her face was pale, as if drained of blood. Her heart shook at the slightest movement, the arteries at her temples throbbed, and dancing or climbing the stairs left her fighting for breath. She turned from food, meat above all, and by night her legs swelled around the ankles.1

Lange was amazed that the family's doctors had missed it. That they could not name it mattered nothing, for many illnesses lack a name but not a cure. Since this one struck virgins, it could be called the virgins' disease. The matrons of Brabant called it the white fever, for the pallor, and the love fever, because, as Ovid said, every lover is pale.1

He blamed menstrual blood that could not get out and flowed back towards the heart and liver. The cure came from Hippocrates. Open a vein, and have girls with the disease live with men and lie with them as soon as possible, because if they conceived they would get well. "So take heart," Lange told the father. "Give your daughter in marriage. I will gladly come to the wedding myself."1

The virgins' disease would trouble doctors for nearly four hundred years. In English it was the green sickness, and to doctors chlorosis.2, 3, 4 When Shakespeare's Juliet refuses the husband her father has chosen, Capulet roars at her, "Out, you green-sickness carrion! out, you baggage! You tallow-face!"5

The spring in the wood

Fifty years after Lange, a young English lord tasted iron in a wood. Thomas Benge Burr told the story in 1766, in his history of Tunbridge Wells, the spa that grew up around that spring.6

Dudley, Lord North, was a courtier in the circle of Prince Henry, the king's son, and had wrecked his fortune and his health with pleasure. At twenty-four he fell into a lingering, wasting illness that his doctors could not touch. In the spring of 1606 they sent him for the air to Eridge, a hunting lodge in one of the wildest parts of Sussex.6

He grew weary of the place. His friends talked him into six more weeks, and he only got worse. He set off for London more desperate than ever, with nothing ahead but a grave in the first bloom of manhood.6

His road ran through a wood near Tunbridge. There he passed a spring with a shining scum on its surface and an ochre crust marking its course to a brook. He climbed down from his carriage, sent a servant to borrow a wooden bowl from a cottage close by, and drank. The water tasted of iron. He had it bottled for his doctors.6

The next spring he came back to drink it. Burr says that after about three months he returned to London cured for good. He threw himself straight back into every pleasure of the age.6 He lived sixty more years.6, 7

Water like his was called chalybeate, from the Greek word for steel. That word came from the Chalybes of northern Anatolia, whom Greek writers counted among the first ironsmiths.8

Steel in Rhenish wine

In 1682 the London physician Thomas Sydenham set out how he treated the green sickness. He counted it a form of hysteria.3

First he bled the patient. Then he purged her for three or four mornings running, and she got worse, so he warned her not to lose heart. Only after that came the iron, which he called steel, for thirty days.3

"To the worn-out and languid blood it gives a spur or fillip," he wrote. The pulse grew strong, the skin warm, and the face, "no longer pale and deathlike", took on "a fresh ruddy colour".3

He liked his steel taken plain, and blamed the chemists' fussing, their "officious sedulity", for making it weaker. Next best was a syrup of iron or steel filings steeped in cold Rhenish wine, then strained, sugared and boiled down. And when iron failed, there were the strong chalybeate waters "like those of Tunbridge".3

A magnet over burnt blood

Bologna, the 1740s. Vincenzo Menghini taught medicine there, and he wanted to settle an argument. Doctors gave iron for many diseases, but they could not agree whether it worked on the body's solid parts or its fluids, or ever got past the gut at all.9

His plan was to bring in dogs from all over, feed them for forty days on food stuffed with iron, and compare their blood before and after.9

He never got that far. Before the feeding began, he had five ounces of blood drawn from the thigh vein of the strongest dog and burned it in a clay pot over a fierce open fire. A little ash weighing twenty-four grains was left. When he brought a magnetised knife near, bright specks leapt up to meet the blade. Held closer, it drew the rust-red grains too, and in the end all of it but a single grain followed the magnet.9

He could hardly believe it. As far as he knew, nobody had ever found so much iron in an animal's blood, or even imagined it there. Perhaps the pot or some iron tool had shed it. So he set the dogs' iron diet aside and started again.9

He burned the blood of four of the dogs, then of oxen, calves and pigs. He had four pounds let from a fine strong horse, "not for any illness of the horse, but for the sake of the experiments". He burned the blood of six men and six women. "Who would believe," he wrote, "that I slaughtered nearly a hundred eels" to collect one ounce of their blood? He burned the bones of a man killed by a terrible wound.9

Iron was richest in the blood, and scarcer in flesh, bone and fat. He had hunted it through every other part of the body "with long and wearisome labour" before he found its seat at last, in the red globules themselves, the red cells of the blood. He showed the academy in Bologna, holding the magnet over burnt blood, flesh and bone, and the work was printed in 1746.9, 10 The red of blood is the red of the iron-rich haemoglobin packed into those cells.11

Joséphine's pills

Beaucaire, in the south of France, 12 April 1828. Sixteen-year-old Joséphine Julien is put in the care of Pierre Blaud, chief physician of the town's hospital.12

For two years her complexion, once glowing and fresh, had been fading to a yellowish green. Her periods had stopped, and a dark gloom had taken the place of her high spirits. She had cramps, a pounding head and a racing heart, and climbing left her short of breath. Travel, country air, calming drugs, drugs to bring on her periods and iron in several forms had all been tried.12

At first sight Blaud thought she had some deep disease beyond the reach of medicine. Then he recognised chlorosis.12

Iron had always been counted its specific remedy. Blaud thought it failed so often because doctors gave too little of it, and in a form the gut would not take up. His pills mixed sulphate of iron with potash. Inside the pill the two reacted and made carbonate of iron, a form he trusted the body to absorb.12

Within a week Joséphine was hungry again and her heart had calmed. He called her cured on 14 May, the thirty-second day. Her periods soon came back, and her health held.12

In his patients a light rosy tint came into the skin first, above all in the face. The eyes got back their shine. Then everything else came right, "as if by miracle". And it was not only girls at puberty, he warned. Chlorosis struck every age, and men too.12

The disease that vanished

Early in the twentieth century, the green sickness disappeared.2

In 1984 the family doctor and medical historian Irvine Loudon argued that it had never been one disease. The girls diagnosed in the late 1800s mostly had a form of anaemia, the kind with pale, iron-poor blood, perhaps from stomach ulcers and poor diet. In earlier centuries many had a disorder of the mind much like anorexia, and it was this one that went by the old names, the virgins' disease and the love fever. He even thought the green may first have meant innocence, not the colour of the skin.13, 14

Nobody can now say which one Anna had.1, 13

The decimal point that never slipped

In the Christmas issue of the British Medical Journal in 1981, the haematologist Terence Hamblin told a story about spinach. As he told it, spinach was found in the 1890s to be as good a source of iron as red meat. Then German chemists in the 1930s showed that "the original workers had put the decimal point in the wrong place and made a tenfold overestimate of its value." He added, "For a source of iron Popeye would have been better off chewing the cans."15, 17

It was the perfect tale of careless science. It spread through academic papers, newspapers, magazines, television and myth-busting websites. One spice seller's website still tells it today, with a German chemist slipping his decimal point in 1870.15, 16

In 2010 Mike Sutton, a British criminologist, went back through the old papers and found no slip anywhere. He asked Hamblin, who could not remember where he had read it but was sure he had not made it up.15

A reader of Sutton's article, Bonnie Taylor-Blake, pointed him to the nutritionist Arnold Bender. In a lecture in 1972 Bender had said the fame of spinach "may well have grown from a misplaced decimal point". In a 1977 letter to The Spectator, he wrote that it "appears to have been based on" one. Four years later Hamblin turned the guess into a fact.15, 17

For the old, too-high figures, Sutton pointed instead to iron from laboratory equipment getting into the samples, and to figures for dried spinach read as if they were fresh. The right value was known well before Popeye.15, 18

And Popeye never ate spinach for its iron. In a 1932 strip by his creator, Elzie Segar, the sailor munches it and declares that "spinach is full of vitamin A an' tha's what makes hoomans strong and hefty."15, 18

Hamblin took it well. "Thanks for pointing out my mistake of 29 years ago," he wrote on Sutton's web page. "I thought it was in Reader's Digest." A Reader's Digest book did print the story in 1988, seven years after he did.15

Iron in the bread

In Great Britain the iron now goes into the flour. By law the miller must top it up wherever the grain falls short of the legal minimum.19 Lange's cure for Anna was a wedding. Sydenham's was steel and waters like Lord North's, and Blaud's was a pill. What studies in people have found since is in the Research tab.

Every white loaf baked from that flour carries a little iron, four and a half centuries after a doctor told a worried father to find his pale daughter a husband.

See what modern trials found

Myths and facts

In the record, or legend?

Every story you will read about this mineral, checked against the oldest source we could find.

  • Lange told Anna's father that marriage would cure her

    In the record

    His own letter, printed in Basel in 1554, quoting Hippocrates1

  • Lord North found the Tunbridge Wells spring in 1606, and its water cured him

    Told, not shown

    Told by Burr in 1766, 160 years later, "chiefly gathered from verbal information", with, he admits, "no corroborating circumstances" from history. North's own account was not found6, 7

  • Green-sick girls really turned green

    Partly

    Blaud recorded a yellow-green complexion in Joséphine in 1828. Loudon suggested the "green" first meant innocence12, 13

  • Menghini found the iron in blood with a magnet

    In the record

    His own paper of 1746, with his animals and his weights of ash9

  • The green sickness was a lack of iron

    Partly

    Loudon argued for two conditions under one name, a form of anaemia and a disorder much like anorexia13

  • Spinach got its name for iron from a misplaced decimal point

    Legend

    No slip has been found. The story grew from Bender's guess in 1972 into Hamblin's fact in 198115, 17

  • Popeye ate spinach for its iron

    Legend

    In Segar's 1932 strip it is "full of vitamin A"15, 18

In the record means a source from the time, or a scholar quoting one, says it. Likely means a named expert's reasoned identification. Told, not shown means one interested party says it and nothing checks it. Partly means a real event sits under a bigger story. Legend means the earliest source is far too late or missing. Wrong date means the event is real but the popular date doesn't match the record.

Notes

Every fact in the story points to one of these. Where a translation is ours, the note says so.

Show all 19 notes Hide the notes
  1. Johannes Lange of Löwenberg ("Ioanne Langio Lembergio"), physician to the Electors Palatine ("Illustriss. Principum Palatinorum Rheni, &c. Medico"), Medicinalium epistolarum miscellanea (Basel: Johannes Oporinus, 1554), letter XXI, "De morbo virgineo", pp. 74-77, John Carter Brown Library copy at https://archive.org/details/medicinaliumepis00lang . Page numbers read from the page images. Translations ours; the Latin is in the source log. p. 74: "Conquereris mihi, ut tuo fido Achati, filiam tuam Annam primogenitam, & iam nubilem, a multis procis, virtutum integritate ac stemmatis claritate, opumque facultatibus, avito tuorum maiorum generi non imparibus, in coniugem desiderari: quos tu, ob filiae imbecillitatem, abdicare cogaris" (you complain to me, as to your faithful Achates, that your firstborn daughter Anna, now of an age to marry, is sought as a wife by many suitors, not unequal to your ancestral line in virtue, lineage and wealth, whom you are forced to refuse because of your daughter's weakness); "nullus Medicorum internam morbi causam & essentiam explicare ... potuerit. Nam unus esse cardialgiam ait, alius cordis palmum" (no doctor could explain the inner cause and nature of the disease; one says heartburn, another palpitation of the heart). p. 75: "hic vero dyspnoeam, ille matricis suffocationem: nec defuisse, qui ex vitio epatis esse ventriculi fastidium suspicarentur" (this one breathlessness, that one suffocation of the womb, and there were some who suspected the loathing of the stomach came from a fault of the liver); so that "totus animi pendeas, nec quid facto opus sit discernere possis" (you are wholly at a loss and cannot tell what must be done). The father had asked "de morbo filiae ... ac de nuptiis consilium fidele" (for faithful advice about his daughter's disease and about marriage). p. 75, the doctors: from these signs, which show the disease's cause and mark its cure, "miror vestrates Medicos morbi causas & naturam non agnovisse" (I wonder that your local doctors did not recognise the causes and nature of the disease); "Quod vero nomen illius non dixerint, id quum ad morbi curam nihil conferat, nihil quoque refert. Multae sunt in morborum catalogo aegritudines, nomine & non cura carentes" (that they did not name it matters nothing, since a name adds nothing to the cure; there are many illnesses in the list of diseases that lack a name and not a cure). The signs: her face, "quum anno praeterito roseo genarum labiorumque rubore floruisset, ea modo velut exanguia, pallescere triste" (which last year had bloomed with the rosy red of cheeks and lips, now grows sadly pale, as if bloodless), all from the father's own account ("quibus morbi symptomatis affligitur, recte primum declaras", you rightly set out first the symptoms she suffers from); "cor ad quaevis corporis motu contremiscere, arteriasque temporum sensibiliter pulsare, & in choreis ascensuve scalarum dispnoea corripi, stomachum cibum, ac praecipue carnem fastidire: & crura, praecipue iuxta talos, ad noctem oedemate intumescere" (her heart trembles at any movement of the body, the arteries of the temples beat perceptibly, she is seized with breathlessness in dancing or climbing stairs, her stomach loathes food and above all meat, and her legs, above all near the ankles, swell with oedema towards night). The name: the disease has no name of its own, "quam cum sit virginibus peculiaris, virgineus quoque indigitari poterit: quem Brabantinorum matronae, febrem albam, ob faciei pallorem, & amatoriam appellare solent: quum palleat omnis amans, & color hic sit aptus amanti" (since it is peculiar to virgins it may also be called virgineus; the matrons of Brabant are used to calling it the white fever, for the pallor of the face, and the love fever, since every lover is pale and this colour suits a lover), with the margin "Amantes pallent, teste Ouidio" (lovers are pale, as Ovid bears witness). pp. 75-76, the cause: menstrual blood, unable to break out of the narrow mouths of the veins of the womb, "rursum per venae cavae maiorisque arteriae propagines, ad cor, epar, diaphragma, & praecordiorum venas regurgitat" (flows back through the branches of the vena cava and the great artery to the heart, liver, diaphragm and the veins of the chest). p. 77, the cure, quoting Hippocrates' little book on the diseases of virgins: "Huius morbi liberatio est, venae sectio, si nihil obstiterit. Ego vero, inquit, praecipio, virgines hoc morbo afflictas, ut quamprimum viris cohabitent, & copulentur. si conceperint, convalescent" (the release from this disease is opening a vein, if nothing stands against it; I for my part, he says, instruct virgins with this disease to live with men and couple with them as soon as possible; if they conceive, they will recover); with medicines that bring on the menses he has "nunquam falsus, aut spe frustratus" (never been deceived or disappointed in hope); "Quare bono sis animo, filiam tuam elocato: nuptiis quoque ego libens interero. Vale" (so be of good heart, give your daughter in marriage; I too will gladly attend the wedding. Farewell). The letter names neither the father nor a date or place of writing. That Anna's disease cannot now be identified is our reading of note 13. ↩
  2. Eugenia Tognotti, "La clorosi. Storia di una malattia" (in Italian, English abstract), Medicina nei Secoli 22 (2010), pp. 721-742, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21563494/ : chlorosis, "for centuries ... considered as typical of young unmarried women", is one of the few diseases for which the medical literature allows us "to assign the exact date of beginning in the sixteenth century--and its disappearance in early twentieth century." Abstract only. ↩
  3. Thomas Sydenham, Dissertatio epistolaris to William Cole (1682), in The Works of Thomas Sydenham, M.D., translated by R. G. Latham, vol. 2 (London: Sydenham Society, 1850), https://archive.org/details/worksofthomassyd02sydeiala . Page numbers read from the page images. p. 96 (§92): "the chlorosis (a truly hysterical complaint) of hysteria". p. 97 (§95): "With this view I bleed. I then purge for three or four mornings running. Meanwhile, the patient is so far from improving that she gets worse ... Hence I warn her against being dispirited". pp. 97-98 (§96): "After these evacuations, I comfort the blood and the spirits belonging to it by giving a chalybeate thirty days running. This is sure to do good. To the worn-out and languid blood it gives a spur or fillip, whereby the animal spirits, which before lay prostrate and sunken under their own weight, are raised and excited. Clear proof of this is found in the effects of steel upon chlorosis. The pulse gains strength and frequency, the surface warmth, the face (no longer pale and deathlike) a fresh ruddy colour"; with weak patients "the bleeding and purging may be omitted". p. 98 (§97): steel "is best given in substance"; "With steel, as with other more famous medicines, the officious sedulity of the chemists has not only failed in adding to its activity, but has succeeded in diminishing it"; "I have heard a statement, which, if true, strongly sustains this assertion—namely, that the crude ore itself, as dug out of the bowels of the earth, operates more effectually in our victories over disease than steel which has been exposed to the fire and suffered fusion. For this, however, my informant is answerable"; "Next to steel in substance, I prefer a syrup. This is made by steeping iron or steel filings in cold Rhenish wine. When the wine is sufficiently impregnated, strain the liquor; add sugar; and boil to the consistency of a syrup." pp. 103-104 (§108): "the so-called female obstructions; especially chlorosis, or green-sickness"; "if the blood be so effete, and the spirits so atactic that iron will not avail to cure them, strong chalybeate waters must be resorted to, like those of Tunbridge". The year and the name: Wikipedia, "Thomas Sydenham", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Sydenham : "In 1682 he published another Dissertatio epistolaris", on smallpox and hysteria; he "became known as 'The English Hippocrates'". Cole's letter that it answers is dated "Worcester; Nov. 17, 1681" (vol. 2, p. 35 of the same edition). ↩
  4. Irvine Loudon, "The diseases called chlorosis", Psychological Medicine 14 (1984), pp. 27-36, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6369367/ : "chlorosis, or the 'green-sickness'"; "The latter form ... was also known as 'the virgin's disease' or 'febris amatoria'." For the disappearance, see note 2. Abstract only; the publisher's page blocks bots. ↩
  5. William Shakespeare, Romeo and Juliet, act 3, scene 5, Capulet to Juliet after she refuses to marry Paris, MIT Shakespeare text, http://shakespeare.mit.edu/romeo_juliet/romeo_juliet.3.5.html : "Out, you green-sickness carrion! out, you baggage! You tallow-face!" ↩
  6. Thomas Benge Burr, The History of Tunbridge Wells (London, 1766), chapter 1, "The first discovery of the medicinal water at Tunbridge-Wells", pp. 4-15, Wellcome Collection copy at https://archive.org/details/b3052345x . Page numbers and years read from the page images (the years are printed in the margin). pp. 4-5: "Dudley Lord North was a distinguished nobleman in king James's court, or rather in the court of Prince Henry, his son, where he entered into all the gallantries of the times", which proved "not only destructive to his fortune, but ruinous to his constitution also"; p. 5 (margin 1605): "This young nobleman had reached his twenty-fourth year, when he fell into a lingering, consumptive disorder, that baffled the utmost efforts of medicine". p. 6: his friends and physicians advised "change of air", and "in the spring of the year one thousand six hundred and six, made Eridge-house the place of his retreat"; Eridge was "a hunting-seat belonging to Lord Abergavenny". p. 8: it lay "in one of the most savage parts of the county of Sussex". pp. 8-10: he "soon grew weary of his retreat"; "at the repeated instances of his friends ... was prevailed upon to continue yet another six weeks at Eridge; when, finding his disorder rather increased than diminished" he "abruptly quitted" and began his journey to London "in a more desperate and melancholy condition than ever ... with no other prospect in view but that dismal one of a grave in the first bloom of manhood". pp. 10-11 (margin 1606): "his road lay directly through the wood in which these useful springs were concealed"; he took notice of "a water, which seemed to claim his attention, on account of the shining mineral scum that every where swam on its surface, as well as on account of the ochreous substance which subsided at the bottom, and marked its course to a neighbouring brook"; it "induced him to alight from his carriage", and "he ordered one of his attendants to borrow a little vessel from the neighbouring hovel, that he might taste it: and the peculiar ferruginous taste of the water" (p. 12) convinced him it ran through "some undiscovered mine"; he "commanded his servants to bottle off some of the water, in order to consult his physicians". p. 13: the one cottage near the spring, "in which lived the woman from whom his servants borrowed the wooden bowl, that his lordship drank out of when he tasted the water". pp. 14-15 (margin 1607): he returned to Eridge in spring, and "after about three months continuance in this now delightful country, he returned to town so perfectly freed from all his complaints, that we cannot find he ever afterwards experienced the least return of his disorder, though we are assured he again gave himself up to all the gallantries of the age". Burr's footnote, p. 15: "Vide North's Lives—and Collins's Peerage." p. 16: he "died on the sixteenth day of January in the year one thousand six hundred and sixty-six, at the advanced age of eighty-five". Burr's warning, pp. 3-4: the story is "better attested than any other on the same subject" and "the only one unattended with miraculous, or, at least, very improbable incidents", but "there are no corroborating circumstances to be produced from history, or antique monuments" and the narrative "is chiefly gathered from verbal information". Lodowick Rowzee's The Queenes Welles (1632), an earlier book on the same waters, was not read. ↩
  7. Wikipedia, "Dudley North, 3rd Baron North", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dudley_North,_3rd_Baron_North : "(1581 – 16 January 1666)"; "In 1606, while returning from Eridge to London, he discovered the springs at The Pantiles, Tunbridge Wells, which cured North himself of a complaint and quickly became famous", citing the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica. Those dates make him 84 or 85 at his death; Burr (note 6, p. 16) says eighty-five. Either way he lived about sixty years after 1606. ↩
  8. Wikipedia, "Chalybeate", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chalybeate : "mineral spring waters containing salts of iron"; "The word chalybeate is derived from the Latin word for steel, chalybs, which follows from the Greek word χάλυψ khálups", the singular of the name of the Chalybes. Wikipedia, "Chalybes", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chalybes : peoples "living in Pontus and Cappadocia in northern Anatolia"; they "are counted among the first ironsmith nations by classical authors" (citing Strabo 11.14.5); Χάλυψ "means 'tempered iron, steel'". ↩
  9. Vincenzo Menghini, letter to Francesco Maria Zanotti, "De ferrearum particularum sede in sanguine", in De Bononiensi Scientiarum et Artium Instituto atque Academia Commentarii, vol. 2, part 2 (Bologna, 1746), Opuscula, pp. 244-261, https://archive.org/details/commentariidebon22unse . Page numbers and figures read from the page images. Translations ours; the Latin is in the source log. p. 244: he had read the paper "in academia" a few months before, and brought "calcinatas carnes, atque ossa, & sanguinem" (calcined flesh, bones and blood) so as to show "cultro magnetico, quantum ferri in unaquaque re inesset, academicis omnibus palam, & publice" (with a magnetic knife, how much iron was in each thing, openly and publicly to all the academicians). p. 245: "Haerebat animo martialium medicamentorum in plurium morborum curatione vis, & efficacitas, cumque inter auctores non levis dissensio existat, an eadem in partes humani corporis solidas, an in fluidas vim suam exerceant, an contra ne ultra primas vias quidem ... progrediantur" (the power and efficacy of iron medicines in curing many diseases stuck in my mind, and since there is no small dispute among authors whether they act on the solid parts of the human body or the fluid ones, or on the contrary do not even get beyond the first passages); "decreveram plures canes e diversis locis adductos, cibis multo ferro infarctis per quadraginta dies alere" (I had decided to feed several dogs, brought from different places, for forty days on food stuffed with much iron) and to compare their blood before and after; before starting, "e vena crurali robustioris unius ex dictis canibus sanguinem educi iussissem ad uncias quinque, hunc in vase fictili inclusum vehementi, apertoque igni commisi" (I had five ounces of blood drawn from the thigh vein of the strongest of the dogs and put it, shut in a clay pot, on a fierce open fire); the ash "ponderis erat granorum viginti quatuor" (weighed twenty-four grains); at the magnetic knife "protinus visae sunt ferreae quaedam particulae celeritate summa sese attollere" (at once some iron particles were seen to lift themselves with the greatest speed), and others, more of them, "colore ad crocum martis vergentes" (of a colour close to crocus martis, the red-brown iron rust of the chemists), followed when the knife was brought closer ("propius admotum"). pp. 245-246: in the end "illa viginti quatuor calcis grana dempto uno, omnia magnetis actioni paruerint" (all those twenty-four grains of ash, save one, obeyed the magnet). p. 246: his doubts, "quia neminem tantam in animalium sanguine ferri copiam non modo reperisse, sed de illa ne cogitasse quidem intelligebam" (because I understood that nobody had found so great a quantity of iron in the blood of animals, or even thought of it), the clay pot "ferro scatens" (teeming with iron) or an iron tool, and the very humid weather; so he set aside the plan "de ferri ingressu in sanguinem inquirendo" (of enquiring into iron's entry into the blood) to ask whether iron is in animals' bodies by nature. p. 247: four dogs "ex illorum numero, qui iamdudum in custodia detinebantur" (from among those long kept in custody), five ounces of blood each. p. 248: oxen, calves, horses and pigs ("bovillo ... vitulino, equino, & suillo"); "cum generoso, ac forti equo, non ob adversam equi valetudinem, sed institutorum experimentorum causa libras quatuor sanguinis mittendas curassem" (when I had four pounds of blood let from a fine strong horse, not because of any ill health of the horse but for the sake of the experiments), giving 219 grains of ash, of which about 200 showed iron; "ex sex viris, totidemque mulieribus pares sanguinis portiones" (equal portions of blood from six men and as many women). p. 250: "ut unam sanguinis unciam colligerem, quis credat me centum fere anguillas iugulasse; ex totidem vero ranis, quasi triplum?" (to collect one ounce of blood, who would believe that I slaughtered nearly a hundred eels, and from as many frogs nearly three times as much?); dog bones and flesh burned. p. 251: "ossium hominis gravissimo vulnere interfecti" (the bones of a man killed by a very grave wound). p. 252: more iron "in sanguine, quam in carnibus, & in his paulo maior, quam in ossibus, & pinguedine" (in the blood than in the flesh, and in the flesh a little more than in the bones and fat); so "sanguinem esse proprium ac verum ferri receptaculum" (blood is the proper and true receptacle of iron). p. 257: "Sedem ergo ferri, quam diu in ceteris animalium partibus prolixo, improboque labore frustra quaesiveram, inveni tandem in ipsis globulis" (the seat of iron, which I had long sought in vain in the other parts of animals with long and wearisome labour, I found at last in the globules themselves). ↩
  10. Wikipedia, "Vincenzo Menghini", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vincenzo_Menghini : "(15 February 1704-27 January 1759)"; from 1737 "professor of Theoretic Medicine, later of Practical Medicine" at the University of Bologna; "Menghini's experiments were published in 1746"; earlier, Giuseppe Badia "had suggested the presence of iron". ↩
  11. Alex D. Sheftel, Anne B. Mason and Prem Ponka, "The long history of iron in the Universe and in health and disease", Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 1820 (2012), pp. 161-187, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21856378/ (free on PMC, PMC3258305, which shows a bot check): the blood is "vibrant red from a massive abundance of hemoglobin iron". ↩
  12. P. Blaud, chief physician of the hospital of Beaucaire ("médecin en chef de l'hôpital de Beaucaire"), "Sur les maladies chlorotiques, et sur un mode de traitement spécifique dans ces affections", presented to the Académie royale de médecine on 23 August 1831, Revue médicale française et étrangère, March 1832, vol. 1, pp. 337-367, https://archive.org/details/s3id13657250 . Page numbers and dates read from the page images. Translations ours. p. 344: "Et que l'on ne croie pas que ces affections soient seulement le triste apanage des jeunes filles qui arrivent à la puberté! elles atteignent tous les âges; elles n'épargnent pas non plus notre sexe" (and let no one think these diseases are only the sad lot of girls reaching puberty! they strike every age, and they do not spare our sex either). p. 345: "Le fer a été employé de tout temps dans les affections chlorotiques, dont il a été considéré comme le spécifique; mais tous les praticiens savent combien son succès est incertain" (iron has always been used in chlorotic diseases and considered their specific, but every practitioner knows how uncertain its success is), which comes "de la faible dose à laquelle on l'administre, et surtout de ce qu'on ne l'introduit point dans l'organisation convenablement modifié" (from the small amount given, and above all from its not being introduced into the body in a suitably modified form), so that "les voies absorbantes le repoussent" (the absorbing passages reject it); the patients had languished for years on "l'eau ferrée ou du safran de mars apéritif" (iron water or saffron of Mars); his pills are made of "Sulfate de fer" and "Sous-carbonate de potasse" with gum tragacanth. p. 346: mixing them causes "une décomposition réciproque des deux sels" (a reciprocal decomposition of the two salts), forming carbonate of iron. pp. 347-348: "D'abord une légère teinte rosée se répand sur le système cutané, principalement à la face, et les yeux reprennent l'éclat qu'ils avaient perdu" (first a light rosy tint spreads over the skin, mainly in the face, and the eyes regain the brightness they had lost); the functions return to normal "comme par miracle" (as if by miracle). p. 348: "Joséphine Julien, âgée de seize ans, réglée à quatorze, vit, sans cause connue, son teint, auparavant brillant de fraîcheur, se faner et prendre peu à peu une couleur jaune-verdâtre" (Joséphine Julien, aged sixteen, whose periods began at fourteen, saw her complexion, until then glowing with freshness, fade for no known cause and little by little take on a yellow-green colour); her periods stopped, and "une morosité sombre, une sorte de torpeur morale dont on ne pouvait la tirer, remplacèrent sa gaieté et sa vivacité naturelles" (a dark gloom, a kind of torpor of the spirit nobody could draw her out of, replaced her natural gaiety and liveliness). p. 349: cramps of the stomach, "des battemens douloureux dans la tête" (painful throbbing in the head), sleeplessness, palpitations and oppression "sous l'influence de la marche ascendante" (when walking uphill); "Deux ans s'écoulèrent dans cet état de souffrance" (two years passed in this suffering); travel, "le séjour à la campagne", antispasmodics, emmenagogues and "les substances ferrugineuses sous diverses formes" had been tried; "elle fut confiée à nos soins le 12 avril 1828" (she was put in our care on 12 April 1828); "Au premier aspect nous la jugeâmes atteinte de quelque lésion organique profonde, au dessus de toutes les ressources de l'art" (at first sight we judged her to have some deep organic lesion beyond all the resources of the art), until a careful examination showed "une affection chlorotique"; on the 19th the appetite was back and "la cardialgie avait disparu", the palpitations rarer, "le teint commençait à se ranimer" (her complexion was beginning to revive). p. 350: cure "complète le 14 mai, trente-deuxième jour de l'emploi de la méthode curative" (complete on 14 May, the thirty-second day of the treatment); her periods soon returned "et la santé ne fut point troublée depuis" (and her health was not disturbed since). The pill schedule (p. 347) is left out here. The article gives only the initial ("Par P. Blaud"). The first name is from Rodolfo Delfini Cançado and Manuel Muñoz, "Intravenous iron therapy: how far have we come?", Revista Brasileira de Hematologia e Hemoterapia 33 (2011), p. 461, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23049364/ (free on PMC, PMC3459360): "it was not until the 19th century when Pierre Blaud introduced ferrous sulfate". ↩
  13. Loudon 1984 (note 4), abstract: "chlorosis, or the 'green-sickness', was not a single disease entity, but a name applied to at least two distinct conditions affecting young females in the past. The first ('chloro-anaemia') was a form of hypochromic anaemia possibly associated with gastric ulceration and poor diet. This form predominated in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. The second ('chloro-anorexia') was a disorder of psychogenic origin resembling, but not identical to, anorexia nervosa. The latter form predominated in earlier periods but also occurred throughout the nineteenth century; it was also known as 'the virgin's disease' or 'febris amatoria'. The 'green' of 'green-sickness' may originally have indicated innocence rather than a green colour of the skin." See also his "Chlorosis, anaemia, and anorexia nervosa", British Medical Journal 281 (1980), pp. 1669-1675, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7004564/ (scan on PMC, PMC1715689, not read). ↩
  14. Wikipedia, "Irvine Loudon", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irvine_Loudon : "(1 August 1924 – 7 January 2015) was a British doctor and a medical historian"; after qualifying "He settled down as general practitioner". ↩
  15. Ole Bjørn Rekdal, "Academic urban legends", Social Studies of Science 44 (2014), pp. 638-654, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25272616/ (free full text on PMC, PMC4232290, which shows a bot check). Rekdal quotes Terence J. Hamblin, "Fake!", British Medical Journal 283 (1981), pp. 1671-1674, p. 1671: "The discovery that spinach was as valuable a source of iron as red meat was made in the 1890s … German chemists reinvestigating the iron content of spinach had shown in the 1930s that the original workers had put the decimal point in the wrong place and made a tenfold overestimate of its value. … For a source of iron Popeye would have been better off chewing the cans"; Hamblin "does not provide a reference"; "the 1981 Christmas issue of British Medical Journal". The spread: "His story about the decimal point error extends far beyond academia, to newspapers, magazines, TV-programs, and web pages, including some that specialize in debunking myths and urban legends." Mike Sutton, "a British criminologist", found no trace of the error in Hamblin's references, "contacted Hamblin directly and asked him from where he had learned of the decimal point error. Hamblin replied that he could not remember, but that he was sure he had not made it up"; Sutton "argues convincingly that there were entirely other reasons, such as contamination during the analysis or the confusion between fresh and dried spinach, that caused the exaggerated figures in the 19th century", and that "Elzie Crisler Segar had an entirely different nutrient, vitamin A, in mind". After Sutton's 2010 article, "a reader by the name Bonnie Taylor-Blake made Sutton aware that a certain Arnold E. Bender could be the source"; in Bender's inaugural lecture at Queen Elizabeth College, London, in 1972: "the fame of spinach may well have grown from a misplaced decimal point"; in a letter to The Spectator (Bender, "Iron in spinach", 9 July 1977, p. 18): "The fame of spinach appears to have been based on a misplaced decimal point"; "Hamblin ... accidentally turned Bender's suggestion into a piece of fact". Hamblin's comment on Sutton's web page "almost 30 years later": "Thanks for pointing out my mistake of 29 years ago. I never could remember where I had first seen the decimal point story – I thought it was in Reader's Digest." a Reader's Digest book, Facts and Fallacies (1988), p. 264, "published in 1988, 7 years after Hamblin": "Nutrition researchers in the 1890's put a decimal point in the wrong place". Sutton's own paper, M. Sutton, "Spinach, iron and Popeye", Internet Journal of Criminology (2010), could not be reached: its old address now serves an unrelated site. ↩
  16. A spice seller's page: Sarah Johnson, "Popeye Sailor Spinach: The Decimal Point Error That Changed Food History", Alibaba.com spice pages, https://spice.alibaba.com/spice-basics/popeye-sailor-spinach (read 14 November 2026): "The story begins with German chemist Erich von Wolf's 1870 nutritional analysis. While studying vegetable iron content, von Wolf accidentally misplaced a decimal point". The page carries no date. ↩
  17. Mike Sutton, "The Spinach, Popeye, Iron, Decimal Error Myth is Finally Busted", reproduced from his blog (Dysology) at https://gwern.net/doc/www/dysology.blogspot.com/35c207b4df4f38698342d7aafd1d6fc277a5766e.html : "the original published source of this story was in fact the famous nutritionist, and self-styled myth-buster - Arnold E. Bender. Bender first mentioned it in his inaugural lecture in 1972 (Bender 1972) and later in an article in the Spectator (Bender 1977)"; Hamblin "had forgotten the original source of the story, after so many years, but thought he may have read it in an unknown copy of the Reader's Digest." ↩
  18. Joe Schwarcz, "Setting the facts straight about iron in spinach", McGill Office for Science and Society, 20 March 2017, https://www.mcgill.ca/oss/article/food-health-news-quirky-science/setting-facts-straight-about-iron-spinach : on Sutton's findings, "There may have been contamination of samples with iron from laboratory equipment, and there was also confusion about whether the iron they found referred to iron in fresh spinach, or in the dried variety"; "the correct value was already well-known before Popeye was ever conceived"; Segar "never made any mention of iron in connection with spinach. His first reference to spinach was in a 1932 strip that shows Popeye munching away and declaring that 'spinach is full of vitamin A an' tha's what makes hoomans strong and hefty.'" (Schwarcz spells the name "Sagar"; it is Segar.) The strip itself was not seen. ↩
  19. The Bread and Flour Regulations 1998 (SI 1998/141), regulation 4 and schedule 1, as amended, in force in England and Scotland, https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1998/141/regulation/4 : flour from wheat "shall contain the substances specified in column 1 of Schedule 1", which lists iron; in flour other than wholemeal they "shall be added" (England) or "must be added" (Scotland) "where such addition is necessary"; "no manufacturer of flour shall sell any flour which does not comply". Since 13 December 2024 England exempts small mills producing under 500 tonnes a year (regulation 4(1A), inserted by SI 2024/1162). In Wales the 1998 regulations were revoked on 19 February 2025 by the Bread and Flour (Wales) Regulations 2025 (SI 2025/88), whose schedule 1, https://www.legislation.gov.uk/wsi/2025/88/schedule/1/made , still requires iron in flour. The 1998 regulations themselves "revoke and replace the Bread and Flour Regulations 1995" (explanatory note, https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1998/141/note/made ), so the rule is older than 1998. The amounts are left out here. ↩