NR-024Ingredient Atlas entry · Fatty acid

Omega-3 EPA

Eicosapentaenoic acid, a long-chain omega-3 fat

A trader's notes on nosebleeds at Thule, two Danish doctors with blood samples in ice water, and an Oxford nutritionist who lived on seal and fish for a hundred days. Out of them grew the story that the Inuit hardly knew heart disease. The doctors never counted the heart attacks.

  • Found in: oily fish and fish oil
  • Most tested: 1,000 mg a day
  • Often taken for 12 weeks
Close-up of an anchovy's head
Close-up of an anchovy's head. Photo by Горбунова М.С., CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Every fourth or fifth day

Thule, 1915. Hardly a nose in the tribe goes a week without bleeding.1

That was the report of Peter Freuchen, a Dane who had quit medical school to stoke the boilers on an expedition to Greenland, then a Danish colony. In 1910 he and the explorer Knud Rasmussen set up a trading station at Thule, in the far north of the island, and he married there. Five years later a Danish medical weekly printed his notes on the health of the Inuit around him.2, 1

One complaint was so common that the people themselves mostly ignored it. Almost everyone's nose bled on its own at least every fourth or fifth day, as a rule for about half an hour.1

It was nothing new. In 1745 a book by Hans Egede, a missionary in Greenland, told English readers that its people were "very full of Blood, which is observed by their frequent Bleeding at the Nose." Few of them lived past fifty or sixty.3

Doctors kept noting the bleeding for the next two centuries. In 1940 Alfred Bertelsen, a Danish doctor who had come to Greenland in 1902, gathered their reports into a history of the island's diseases that ran to hundreds of pages. He had seen patients die of nosebleeds that would not stop. His English summary called the bleeding "remarkably frequent among the Greenlanders; a fact for which no absolutely satisfactory explanation has yet been found."4

Thirty years later two doctors from Aalborg went looking for something else and explained it. The explanation came with a story about the heart, and that story became an axiom.5

Blood in ice water

In 1969 Hans Olaf Bang and Jørn Dyerberg, at the hospital in Aalborg in northern Denmark, decided to find out why Greenlanders so rarely seemed to suffer blood clots. Above all they meant the clot in a heart artery that causes most heart attacks.6

Bang ran the hospital's clinical chemistry department. Dyerberg was a young doctor, and the chance to drive a dog sledge over the ice was part of the pull.7, 8

In August 1970 they went to the Umanak district on Greenland's west coast, 500 kilometres north of the Arctic Circle, with a laboratory technician, Aase Brøndum Nielsen. Its 2,600 people lived largely by seal hunting and fishing, and they ate their meat boiled or raw, never fried.6

They took blood from 130 Greenlanders before breakfast, the oldest of them 83. Each sample travelled for up to ten hours in ice water to the hospital in Umanak town, then went into a freezer and finally home to Aalborg.9

Reading the fats took two years on what Dyerberg remembered as "a very old gas chromatogram". He said in 2007 that it would now take a fortnight.8

The blood was low in cholesterol, and one omega-3 fat stood out. Eicosapentaenoic acid, EPA for short, was known to be plentiful in the body fat of Arctic sea animals, yet Danish blood held very little of it. In the Greenlanders it made up 16 per cent of the fats bound to cholesterol, against 1 per cent in the Danes. They also carried more of a second omega-3 fat from fish, DHA.10

Thirty-two Greenlanders living in Denmark had blood like any Dane's. So it was not in the genes. It had to come from what they ate.10

Sugar five times a day

In 1972 they went back, to Igdlorssuit, a settlement of about 140 people a hundred kilometres north of Umanak, where everyone lived at least partly on seal, whale and fish. Seven of them handed over an exact copy of every meal for a week, and each portion was weighed, ground up and frozen for the laboratory.11

Whale or seal was eaten every day, and sugar went into tea or coffee about five times a day. The meals held slightly less fat than average Danish food, which the doctors called remarkable. Now and then a person ate more than 600 grams of fat in a day. That gave "9000 Kcal!", the report said, exclamation mark and all.11

In April 1976 they came back in winter with a bigger team, among them a dietician, the Oxford nutritionist Hugh Sinclair and the Arctic traveller Ivars Silis, who handled the practical problems. Every journey went by dog sledge over the ice. At night it fell to 20 or 25 below zero, and at noon it often rose to about zero.12

Seals came in almost every day, and 50 Greenlanders gave the team copies of 178 days of meals.12

The shop told another story. Igdlorssuit had had one since 1918, and in 1975 it sold more than five tonnes of sugar, nearly 100 grams a day for every person in the settlement. These Greenlanders, the doctors wrote, were "not eating the traditional high fat and protein diet". It was not the amount of fat that set them apart. It was the kind.12

The clot that would not form

Next the doctors tested EPA in the laboratory. Platelets, the specks in the blood that clump at a wound to start a clot, normally make their clumping signal from another fat, arachidonic acid. From EPA they could make none, while the wall of a blood vessel could turn EPA into a substance that keeps platelets apart.13

In 1978 the Lancet printed the idea, written with John Vane and Salvador Moncada of the Wellcome Foundation, whose laboratory had found the vessel wall's own anti-clotting substance. The title ended with a question mark. Four years later Vane shared a Nobel Prize for work on that family of substances.14, 15

In the summer of 1978 the two Danes went back to test it in living people. Twenty-one Greenlanders volunteered, with no medicines and no alcohol for three days before. The doctors made a small standard cut on each and timed the bleeding.16

It lasted 8.1 minutes on average, against 4.8 minutes in 21 Danes of the same ages and sexes. In half the Greenlanders the platelets would not clump at all, even when the doctors added collagen, a powerful trigger.16

Their report put it in four words. "Our theory comes true." They had found, they wrote, the first well supported explanation of "the bleeding tendency in Greenlanders known for centuries".16

Ten years before, they had asked why heart disease was so rare in Greenland. Now they had their answer.16

A seal in the fridge

Hugh Sinclair, back from the 1976 trip, wanted to see what the Greenland diet did to clotting in Britain.17

His interest in the Inuit went back to the Second World War, when he studied snow blindness in Canada for the air force. In 1956 he blamed the rising deaths from hardened arteries on a lack of essential fats, in a letter to the Lancet that drew the longest correspondence the journal had seen.17, 18 Two years later he lost his readership at Oxford. His views and his manner with authority both counted against him, though Magdalen College kept him as a fellow.18

Colleagues remembered an eccentric and "an odd ball".18, 19

The research councils would not pay for a study of an Inuit diet. They called it "unethical" and "based on limited evidence". So in 1979, at 69, Sinclair put himself on it. For 100 days he ate only seal, fish and water, and every so often he cut his arm and timed the bleeding.17, 18

His bleeding time went from three minutes to 57. His boots filled with blood when he pruned his roses, and other diners at Magdalen complained venomously about the smell of seal meat.17

The Edinburgh cardiologist Michael Oliver once stayed at his house, along with the Aberdeen scientist Elspeth Smith. At breakfast Sinclair drank something he called tea. It was seal oil. The fridge was locked, with an ice pick hanging beside it, and when Smith asked what was inside, Sinclair very reluctantly found the key. Inside was a frozen seal he had been picking away at.19

One day Sinclair rang Oliver at home. He wanted a liver biopsy for fatty acid analysis the next day, and a doctor in Oxford had doubts. "He said my bleeding time is 60 minutes," Sinclair said. "Is that high?" Oliver told him it would be the last time he spoke to anyone. He didn't have the biopsy.19

His results were never properly written up.18

Not even mentioned

"The Greenlandic Inuit eat this really high fat diet, and they don't have heart disease." The founder of a supplement consulting firm told a trade magazine that in 2024, and the trade press was telling it the same way in 2007.20, 8

Bang and Dyerberg never counted a heart attack themselves. They took the rarity from other doctors, from official reports that listed not a single heart attack in the Umanak district in ten years, and from Bertelsen's history. It gave "some information about atherosclerosis", they wrote, but "does not even mention ischaemic heart disease", the disease of narrowed heart arteries.21, 22

Bertelsen's book says more than that. When he arrived in 1902 he found "not a few" older Greenlanders with degenerating heart muscle, and in his judgement hardened arteries were a fairly common complaint there. His English summary is blunter still. "Arteriosclerosis and myocardiac degeneration are common, and heart disease a not uncommon cause of death, specially among the oldest age groups." He never used the words "ischaemic heart disease" at all.23

And few Greenlanders grew old enough to die of it. From 1901 to 1930 only 0.4 per cent of deaths in West Greenland came after the age of 80, against 16 per cent in Denmark.23

In 2003 Peter Bjerregaard, of Denmark's National Institute of Public Health, and two colleagues went back over the death records for Greenland, Canada and Alaska. They found the evidence for few heart deaths "fragile", resting "on unreliable mortality statistics". Deaths from stroke were higher among the Inuit than in other Western populations, and all heart and blood vessel deaths together were no lower.24

In 2014 George Fodor of the University of Ottawa Heart Institute and three colleagues reviewed forty years of studies. Most found that Greenlanders and the Inuit of Canada and Alaska had coronary artery disease as often as other people. Yet Bang and Dyerberg's papers were "still routinely cited" as proof that the "Eskimo diet" protects the heart.25

Only us

By 2007 Dyerberg counted some 14,000 papers on omega-3 fats since their first in 1971. "It was easy to calculate for 1971," he said. "There was only us!"8

In 2020 a Cochrane review pooled 86 trials, with more than 160,000 people, mostly taking capsules, and found that more EPA and DHA made little or no difference to deaths overall.26 A 2019 trial took high-risk patients whose blood triglycerides stayed high despite statins. Against a placebo of mineral oil, a drug made of purified EPA cut heart deaths, heart attacks, strokes and other heart events by a quarter, though more patients went to hospital with an irregular heartbeat. A later look found that markers of heart risk had risen in the mineral oil group itself, which left what the result meant uncertain.27

Sinclair's friend David Horrobin tried EPA on the mind. In 2002 he and Malcolm Peet of Swallownest Court Hospital in Sheffield tested it on patients whose depression had not lifted on standard drugs. What they and later trials found is in the Research tab. DHA, found beside EPA in those Greenland samples, has a story of its own about the brain.28, 18, 8

Freuchen's neighbours at Thule bled from the nose and paid it little mind. Bang and Dyerberg traced that bleeding to a fat in the seal and whale they ate. The healthy hearts were the legend.1, 16, 25

See what modern trials found

Myths and facts

In the record, or legend?

Every story you will read about this fatty acid, checked against the oldest source we could find.

  • Greenlanders' noses bled often

    In the record

    Egede's book said it in Danish in 1741 and in English in 1745, Freuchen wrote it at Thule in 1915 and Bertelsen in 1940, and Bang and Dyerberg measured longer bleeding times in 19781, 3, 4, 16

  • Bang and Dyerberg discovered EPA

    Legend

    Their own report calls it a fat already known to be plentiful in Arctic sea animals. What they found was how much of it the Greenlanders carried, and what it did to their platelets8, 10, 16

  • The Inuit lived on a diet that was almost all fat

    Partly

    The old diet was high in fat and protein with little carbohydrate, and an early survey put fat at 47 per cent of the energy. But the meals weighed at Igdlorssuit in 1972 held slightly less fat than average Danish food, and in 1976 fat gave 39 per cent of the energy against 42 per cent for Danes. By then the shop sold sugar and flour11, 12

  • Sinclair lived on seal and fish for 100 days and bled for nearly an hour

    In the record

    Told by the nutrition unit named after him and by a cardiologist who stayed in his house. The accounts give 57 minutes, "60 minutes" and "over 50", and his results were never properly written up. The boots full of blood are told second-hand, from a 2002 book review17, 18, 19, 29

  • The Inuit had almost no heart disease

    Legend

    Bang and Dyerberg never counted it. Bertelsen's 1940 history called heart disease "a not uncommon cause of death", above all among the old, though his heart deaths per head were below Denmark's in a people who seldom grew old. The 2003 review found heart and stroke deaths together no lower than elsewhere, with more from stroke, and the 2014 review found heart-artery disease as common in most studies. Fewer heart attacks may have been real, but the records behind that are fragile21, 23, 24, 25

In the record means a source from the time, or a scholar quoting one, says it. Likely means a named expert's reasoned identification. Told, not shown means one interested party says it and nothing checks it. Partly means a real event sits under a bigger story. Legend means the earliest source is far too late or missing. Wrong date means the event is real but the popular date doesn't match the record.

Notes

Every fact in the story points to one of these. Where a translation is ours, the note says so.

Show all 29 notes Hide the notes
  1. A. Bertelsen, Grønlandsk medicinsk Statistik og Nosografi III, Meddelelser om Grønland 117, no. 3 (Copenhagen, 1940), p. 98, https://tidsskrift.dk/meddrgroenland/article/view/168643 , quoting P. Freuchen, "Om Sundhedstilstanden blandt Polareskimoerne", Ugeskrift for Læger 1915, p. 1089 (Bertelsen's bibliography no. 6; the quoted passage at p. 1104). Freuchen "fra Thule 1915": "En overordentlig almindelig Lidelse - om man kan betegne med dette Udtryk, hvad Befolkningen selv for det meste lader ganske uænset - er de hyppige Næseblødninger. Der findes næppe et Individ i Stammen, uden at hans Næse af sig selv bløder mindst hver 4de eller 5te Dag. I Reglen varer det ved i ca. 1/2 Time". Our translation: "An extraordinarily common complaint, if one may use that word for something the people themselves mostly leave quite unheeded, is the frequent nosebleeds. There is hardly an individual in the tribe whose nose does not bleed of its own accord at least every fourth or fifth day. As a rule it lasts about half an hour." The story's "goes a week" rounds "at least every fourth or fifth day". Ugeskrift for Læger is the Danish medical weekly. Freuchen's 1915 paper itself was not consulted; the words are Bertelsen's quotation of it. ↩
  2. B. Nielsen and O. Ventegodt, "Peter Freuchen", Lex, https://lex.dk/Peter_Freuchen : "Han blev student i 1904 og begyndte at studere medicin, men i 1906 afbrød han studierne for at deltage som fyrbøder og meteorologisk assistent i Danmark-Ekspeditionen til Nordøstgrønland" (he began to study medicine, but in 1906 broke off his studies to take part as stoker and meteorological assistant in the Danmark Expedition to north-east Greenland); "I 1910 grundlagde Freuchen sammen med Knud Rasmussen en handelsstation i Thule, som han bestyrede indtil 1919. I Thule blev han gift med Navarana". On Greenland as a colony, I. Seiding, "Grønlands historie - kort overblik", Lex, https://lex.dk/Gr%C3%B8nlands_historie_-_kort_overblik : Danish colonisation began with Hans Egede's mission of 1721, and "kolonitiden formelt sluttede med nyordningen i 1953" (the colonial period formally ended with the new order of 1953). On the place, H. Schultz-Lorentzen and R. O. Rasmussen, "Thule", Lex, https://lex.dk/Thule : Rasmussen and Freuchen set up "Kap York Stationen Thule, i Nordgrønland ved bopladsen Uummannaq" (in North Greenland, at the settlement of Uummannaq). That Uummannaq is not the Umanak district of the later sections, which lies far to the south on the west coast. ↩
  3. H. Egede, A Description of Greenland (London: C. Hitch, S. Austen and J. Jackson, 1745), "Translated from the Danish", ch. IX, p. 120, https://archive.org/details/descriptionofgre00eged . The title page calls him "Missionary in that Country". After the smallpox of 1734, which "swept away in and about the Colony above 2000 Persons": "They are very full of Blood, which is observed by their frequent Bleeding at the Nose. Few of them exceed the Age of 50 or 60 Years; many die in the Prime of their Years, and most part in their tender Infancy". The Danish original was printed in 1741 (Bertelsen, note 4, p. 97: "De ere meget Blodrige, derfore bløde de oftist Næsebloed"). ↩
  4. Bertelsen (note 1). P. 97: "Næseblod (Epistaxis) forekommer med stor Hyppighed blandt den indfødte Befolkning i Grønland" (nosebleed occurs with great frequency among the native population), with reports from Egede (1741), Prosch (1855), Trebitsch (1907), Freuchen (1915), Bichel (1920) and Høygaard (1936/37) on pp. 97-98. P. 98, his own experience: "jeg har set Patienter dø af ustandselig Epistaxis, en enkelt Gang i de første Aar af mit Grønlandsophold under Skørbug, i de senere Aar et Par Gange under Tyfus" (I have seen patients die of unstoppable nosebleed, once in my first years in Greenland during scurvy, a couple of times in later years during typhus). P. 102: "Da jeg i 1902 kom til Grønland" (when I came to Greenland in 1902). The journal's page for the volume gives his name as Alfred Bertelsen and the length of Part III as 234 pages. The work's full title adds "Undersøgelser og Erfaringer fra 30 Aars grønlandsk Lægevirksomhed" (studies and experience from 30 years of medical practice in Greenland). English summary, p. 215: "Nosebleed is remarkably frequent among the Greenlanders; a fact for which no absolutely satisfactory explanation has yet been found." ↩
  5. P. Bjerregaard, T. K. Young and R. A. Hegele, "Low incidence of cardiovascular disease among the Inuit: what is the evidence?", Atherosclerosis 166 (2003), pp. 351-357, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535749/ : "The notion that the incidence of ischemic heart disease (IHD) is low among the Inuit subsisting on a traditional marine diet has attained axiomatic status." Full text not read. ↩
  6. H. O. Bang and J. Dyerberg, "The Lipid Metabolism in Greenlanders", Meddelelser om Grønland, Man & Society 2 (1981), pp. 3-4, https://tidsskrift.dk/meddrgroenland_man_soc/article/view/145404 (Department of Clinical Chemistry, Aalborg Hospital). P. 4: "In 1969 we decided to start examinations in Greenland with the purpose of attempting to find the cause of the nearly non-existence of thrombotic diseases in Greenlanders"; later (p. 16) "why thrombotic diseases and especially ischaemic heart disease are so rare in Greenland Eskimos". The report ties the two together, writing of "the almost non-existence of coronary thrombosis" (p. 14), a clot in a heart artery, the usual cause of a heart attack. First Umanak expedition, "12 August - 17 September 1970", with "three members, namely the authors and Aase Brøndum Nielsen who served as laboratory technician"; the district is "on the west coast of Greenland at latitude 70°40' north, about 500 km north of the Arctic circle", with "about 2600 inhabitants". "In the settlements a great deal of the adult males are occupied by seal hunting, occasionally whale hunting, and fishing. In the city of UmanaK part of the population is working in offices, service institutions and trade, and the hunting and fishing is of less importance." "All meat is eaten boiled if not raw. Frying is not used." Umanak is today spelled Uummannaq. ↩
  7. "Hans Olaf Bang", Lex, https://lex.dk/Hans_Olaf_Bang : "1913-1994, dansk læge, overlæge ved klinisk-kemisk afdeling, Aalborg Sygehus 1952-78" (chief physician of the clinical chemistry department, Aalborg Hospital, 1952-78). "Jørn Dyerberg", Lex, https://lex.dk/J%C3%B8rn_Dyerberg : "f. 1937, dansk læge", chief physician of the same department 1979-89. ↩
  8. S. Daniells, "The inventor of omega-3" (interview with Jørn Dyerberg), FoodNavigator, 27 November 2007, https://www.foodnavigator.com/Article/2007/11/27/the-inventor-of-omega-3/ . "As a young doctor, curious about the Inuit's high fat diet and low incidence of heart disease - and attracted by the opportunity to dog sled over the ice and snow - he set off with fellow countrymen Hans Olaf Bang and Aase Brondum Nielsen". "After presenting the lipid data in The Lancet, we had a very old gas chromatogram that enabled us to do sample analysis on 130 blood samples. After two years of analysis (today it would take about a fortnight) we reported that we'd found two fatty acids, eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid". "I have done some computing ... and since we published the first paper in 1971 there are now some 14,000 published papers [on omega-3], including close to 8,000 human studies." "It was easy to calculate for 1971 - there was only us!" The same article gives the Inuit "one of the lowest death rates from cardiovascular disease on the planet". The motives the article mentions are the journalist's paraphrase of the interview; the quoted words are Dyerberg's. The 1971 paper: H. O. Bang, J. Dyerberg and A. B. Nielsen, "Plasma lipid and lipoprotein pattern in Greenlandic West-coast Eskimos", Lancet 1 (1971), pp. 1143-1145, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4102857/ . ↩
  9. Bang and Dyerberg (note 6), pp. 4-5: blood "taken in the fasting state in the morning in 130 Greenlanders, 61 males and 69 females, aged 30-83 years"; "Serum or plasma was separated from the blood samples shortly after the venipuncture and was kept in ice-water during transportation in up to ten hours to the hospital in UmanaK. Here the samples were frozen to about -20°C and kept deep frozen until they were analysed in the Department of Clinical Chemistry in the Aalborg Hospital". The fatty acids were measured "gas-liquid-chromatographically". ↩
  10. Bang and Dyerberg (note 6), pp. 7-8. "Remarkable is the high level of the long-chained polyunsaturated fatty acid 5, 8, 11, 14, 17-eicosapentaenoic acid (C 20:5ω-3) which is known to be abundant in the body fats of arctic marine animals. Eicosapentaenoic acid of which only very small amounts are normally found in the blood of western populations was one of the major components of the esterified fatty acids in plasma of Greenlanders, constituting up to 16 per cent of the total fatty acids in ester-bound with cholesterol." Table 6 (p. 7) gives the averages in plasma cholesterol esters as 15.8 per cent in Greenlanders and 0.9 per cent in Danes. Docosahexaenoic acid (C 22:6ω-3, DHA) was higher in the Greenlanders too, 1.0 against 0.4 per cent in the cholesterol esters (table 6) and 3.9 against 2.2 per cent in the phospholipids (table 8, from the 1975 paper). On the 32 Greenlanders living in Denmark (p. 5): "There was found no differences between the concentrations of the blood lipids in these Greenlanders and Danes", and (p. 8) the differences "are not due to racial peculiarities in the Eskimos' lipid metabolism, but must be of exogenous, presumably nutritional origin." The blood lipids, "especially that of cholesterol", were low (p. 8). Their 1975 paper said that "the Eskimos living in Denmark did not differ substantially from other persons living in Denmark", and still called EPA by an older name, timnodonic acid: J. Dyerberg, H. O. Bang and N. Hjørne, "Fatty acid composition of the plasma lipids in Greenland Eskimos", American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 28 (1975), pp. 958-966, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1163480/ . ↩
  11. Bang and Dyerberg (note 6), pp. 8-10. Second expedition, "7 August - 4 September 1972": "The settlement of Igdlorssuit about 100 km north of UmanaK was chosen as particularly suitable for a food examination as the population of this settlement are active hunters and/or fishermen. The inhabitants of the settlement, about 140 persons, all live to a greater or lesser degree on catch from hunting and fishing, predominantly seal, whale and fish." "The study comprised seven persons ... During a period of seven days all meals of these seven persons were collected and weighed ... (the 'double-portion-technique'). The subjects were asked ... to collect and deliver quantitative dublicates of all their meals"; the portions were "weighed, homogenized, and aliquots were taken out and kept frozen until they could be analysed in Denmark". P. 10: "whale and/or seal meat was eaten every day. Sugar was used abundantly about five times a day, mostly in tea or coffee." "The fat intake may occasionally exceed 600 g a day giving an energy intake of 9000 Kcal!" The 49 portions showed "the Greenlanders' diets containing less fat than average Danish food"; p. 11: "The slightly lower fat content as compared with Danish food is remarkable." Table 11 (p. 9) gives the highest daily intakes as 603.3 g of fat and 9,407 Kcal. Table 10 (p. 9) gives an older survey by Krogh and Krogh in north-west Greenland (dated 1914 in the table, 1913 in the reference list), with 44 per cent of the energy from protein, 47 from fat and 8 from carbohydrate. Igdlorssuit is today spelled Illorsuit. ↩
  12. Bang and Dyerberg (note 6), pp. 11-13. Third expedition, "19 April - 12 May 1976", with "Professor Hugh M. Sinclair, Oxford", "Anna Rosenquist, dietician, Aarhus Universitet", "Ivars Silis, author and arctic traveller, responsible for the practical problems of the expedition", two technicians, an engineer and "two interpreters". "Winter climate was still prevailing. For all transportations dog sledging on the frozen ice was used. The temperature went down to about 20-25°C below zero during night and often rose to about zero at noon." "50 Greenlanders ... A total of 178 samples of day rations were collected". P. 12: "The seal hunting was during our stay in Igdlorssuit very profitable, several seals being delivered almost every day." "The settlement of Igdlorssuit was established in 1859. The first shop was opened in 1918 and in 1966 a new and bigger shop was built ... sugar and white flour were in great demand. In 1975 the shop sold 3147 kg of soft sugar and 1920 kg of lump sugar. This gives a daily consumption of nearly 100 g sugar/person." The 1976 food "was found in all essentials similar to those collected in 1972" (p. 12); table 15 (p. 11) gives 39 per cent of its energy from fat, against 42 per cent for Danes. P. 13: "the Igdlorssuit Eskimos we have examined are not eating the traditional high fat and protein diet, but their dietary fat is rich in long-chained fatty acids of the linolenic (ω-3) class with very little of the linoleic (ω-6) class". The food results: H. O. Bang, J. Dyerberg and H. M. Sinclair, "The composition of the Eskimo food in north western Greenland", American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 33 (1980), pp. 2657-2661, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7435433/ ("In the winter of 1976 ... 50 adults"). ↩
  13. Bang and Dyerberg (note 6), p. 14: "Eicosapentaenoic acid cannot be converted by the platelets to a potent pro-aggregatory substance, but actually inhibits platelet aggregation (Dyerberg and Bang 1978). Vascular tissue, however, can convert it to a potent antiaggregatory substance". The clumping signal made from arachidonic acid is thromboxane A2, "pro-aggregatory"; "the very first stage of a thrombus formation is an aggregation of the thrombocytes" (pp. 14-15). The vessel wall's substance from arachidonic acid is prostacyclin, "a powerful anti-aggregatory agent formed by the vessel wall (Moncada et al. 1976)". ↩
  14. J. Dyerberg, H. O. Bang, E. Stoffersen, S. Moncada and J. R. Vane, "Eicosapentaenoic acid and prevention of thrombosis and atherosclerosis?", Lancet 2 (1978), pp. 117-119 (15 July 1978), abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/78322/ : "Eskimos have high levels of E.P.A. and low levels of A.A. and they also have a low incidence of myocardial infarction and a tendency to bleed. It is possible that dietary enrichment with E.P.A. will protect against thrombosis." J. R. Vane, Nobel biography, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1982/vane/biographical/ : "In 1973, I was offered the position of Group Research and Development Director for The Wellcome Foundation ... a Prostaglandin Research department under the leadership of Dr. Salvador Moncada. It was in this department that prostacyclin was discovered". ↩
  15. The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1982, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1982/summary/ : awarded jointly to Sune K. Bergström, Bengt I. Samuelsson and John R. Vane "for their discoveries concerning prostaglandins and related biologically active substances". Prostacyclin and thromboxane belong to this family. ↩
  16. Bang and Dyerberg (note 6), pp. 14-16. Fourth expedition, "28 July - 18 August 1978": "21 Greenlanders, 14 males and 7 females, aged between 21 and 77 years, took part in the study as volunteers. All were free of any medication and none had consumed alcohol for three days prior to the examination", compared with "21 healthy Danes ... chosen as to match each Greenlander according to age and sex". Bleeding time was measured "after Ivy's method with the Simplate device", which makes a small standard cut. P. 15: "The bleeding time was found significantly longer in the Greenlanders, averagely 8.1 as compared with 4.8 min in the Danish controls". In ten of the 21 Greenlanders the strongest ADP test gave no aggregation or a doubtful result, and collagen, "a potent stimulator of platelet aggregation", was tried: "In none of the cases it induced any aggregation." In those Greenlanders, arachidonic acid "induced a normal aggregation response", so the platelets themselves worked. P. 16: "The complete absence of ADP- and collagen-induced secondary phase platelet aggregation in half of the Greenlanders examined by us"; "Our theory of eicosapentaenoic acid ... was consistently confirmed"; "further shows that our theory comes true. Our findings give for the first time a well supported explanation of the bleeding tendency in Greenlanders known for centuries (Bang and Dyerberg 1980)." "The question we asked 10 years ago why thrombotic diseases and especially ischaemic heart disease are so rare in Greenland Eskimos can be answered". Earlier reports of the bleeding, they note, came from Bertelsen (1940). Also J. Dyerberg and H. O. Bang, "Haemostatic function and platelet polyunsaturated fatty acids in Eskimos", Lancet 2 (1979), pp. 433-435, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/89498/ . ↩
  17. J. A. Lovegrove and others, "The Hugh Sinclair Unit of Human Nutrition: 20 years of research 1995-2015", Nutrition Bulletin 40 (2015), pp. 303-314, accepted version at https://centaur.reading.ac.uk/55079/ , section "Hugh Sinclair's contribution to nutritional sciences". He conducted "his renowned 'Eskimo experiment' after developing an interest in the Inuit diet whilst studying snow blindness in Canada during World War II"; "Following a trip to Greenland to study the Inuit's diet, he made plans to test this hypothesis in the UK by investigating the effect of an Inuit diet ... on blood clotting time. He struggled to obtain funding for the study, which research councils felt was 'unethical' and 'based on limited evidence', and in 1979 (at the age of 69 years) he joined the 'n=1 club' choosing to experiment on himself ... For 100 days he consumed only seal meat, fish and water, periodically cutting his arm under controlled conditions to measure the time it took for his blood to clot (Figure 4). The result of this extreme diet was impressive, with an increase in his bleeding time from three to fifty seven minutes, which reportedly caused 'Sinclair's boots to fill with blood when he pruned his roses' (McLean 2002) and the other diners in Magdalen College to complain venomously about the smell of seal meat." The 1956 letter "resulted in the longest correspondence seen in the medical journal"; in it he wrote of "the devastating and usually increasing mortality from atherosclerosis". Figure 4A is captioned "Mincing whale meat for the 100 day Inuit diet". McLean 2002 is a review of Sinclair's biography in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, not read for this page. ↩
  18. University of Reading, Hugh Sinclair Unit of Human Nutrition, "About us", https://www.reading.ac.uk/hsuhn/about-us : "His interest in this area had first occurred during the War when he visited Canada to assist the Air Force in investigating snow-blindness." "In 1956, he wrote a long and controversial letter outlining his views to The Lancet (6 April 1956, 381)." "Sinclair lost his position at Oxford in 1958"; "Another factor was Sinclair's unfortunate manner of dealing with authority ... Although he lost his readership, he remained a fellow at Magdalen." On the 1979 diet: "His results were never properly written up but he did find that his clotting time extended greatly." "His friend and colleague David Horrobin" wrote the foreword to Jeannette Ewin's biography of Sinclair. ↩
  19. L. A. Reynolds and E. M. Tansey (eds), Cholesterol, Atherosclerosis and Coronary Disease in the UK, 1950-2000, Wellcome Witnesses to Twentieth Century Medicine 27 (London, 2006), https://iiif.wellcomecollection.org/file/b16544717_Vol.%2027.pdf . P. 66, Thomas Sanders: "An odd ball, Hugh Sinclair wrote an extremely long letter ... published in the Lancet in 1956". P. 135, biographical note: "Dr Hugh Sinclair DM DSc FRCP (1910-90), an eccentric nutritionist". P. 70, Michael Oliver: "Hugh asked me to stay in his house, Elspeth [Smith] was there too ... the next morning we were given eggs and bacon. Hugh had some filthy stuff that he was drinking, which he said was tea. Well, it wasn't tea, it was seal oil. Elspeth ... asked, 'What is that? What is in the fridge, Hugh?' And Hugh was forced, very reluctantly, to find a key. Having spotted an ice pick hanging by the side of the fridge, Elspeth and Hugh opened it and inside was a frozen seal, at which he had been picking away. So he turned himself into a seal over a period of about three months. ... one day when I was doing something unimportant at home, the telephone went and it was Hugh saying, 'I want to have a liver biopsy tomorrow for fatty acid analysis. A doctor in Oxford doesn't think it is very wise. He said my bleeding time is 60 minutes. Is that high?' I replied, 'Well, you do what you like, Hugh, but it will be the last time you will be talking to me, or anybody else for that matter.' He didn't have it." P. 132: Oliver was "the Duke of Edinburgh Professor of Cardiology at the University of Edinburgh from 1976 to 1989"; p. 135: Elspeth Smith moved "to the University of Aberdeen in 1968 as Lecturer and later Reader" (biographical notes). Oliver does not date the visit. ↩
  20. C. Adrien, "The evolution of omega-3s: From heart to brain health", NutraIngredients-USA, 9 February 2024, https://www.nutraingredients.com/Article/2024/02/09/The-evolution-of-omega-3s-From-heart-to-brain-health/ . Sam Wiley, "founder and managing partner of supplement consulting firm Skysail Solutions": "There's this fat paradox ... You should have lots of heart attacks and cancer with a high fat diet. But the Greenlandic Inuit eat this really high fat diet, and they don't have heart disease." The 2007 wording is in note 8. ↩
  21. Bang and Dyerberg (note 6), p. 3: "Ischaemic heart disease is very rare in Greenlanders (Harvald 1974). In his extensive nosography of Greenland, Berthelsen (1940) does not even mention ischaemic heart disease, although he gives some information about atherosclerosis in the Greenlanders." Official reports gave ischaemic heart disease "on an average 3.5 per cent of all causes of death" in 1973-76, and "In this and other official medical statistics no distinction is made between true Greenlanders and Danes living in Greenland". P. 4: "not a single death from ischaemic heart disease nor case of myocardial infarction is reported from the UmanaK district (population of about 2600) in the decade 1968-78". Their report gives no count of heart disease of its own. ↩
  22. J. G. Fodor, E. Helis, N. Yazdekhasti and B. Vohnout, "'Fishing' for the origins of the 'Eskimos and heart disease' story: facts or wishful thinking?", Canadian Journal of Cardiology 30 (2014), pp. 864-868, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25064579/ : "Bang and Dyerberg, on being informed that the Greenland Eskimos had a low prevalence of coronary artery disease (CAD) set out to study the diet of this population ... Notably, Bang and Dyerberg's studies from the 1970s did not investigate the prevalence of CAD in this population". The publisher's page blocks automated checks, so the abstract on PubMed is linked. Full text not consulted. ↩
  23. Bertelsen (note 1), pp. 102-105 and English summary p. 215. P. 102: "Da jeg i 1902 kom til Grønland, fandt jeg dog ikke saa faa ældre Individer med Degeneratio myocardii" (when I came to Greenland in 1902 I found not a few older individuals with myocardial degeneration); earlier doctors (Hastrup 1886, Kiær 1900) had seen no heart disease in North Greenland. P. 103: of 2,613 causes of death reported from West Greenland in 1924-1933, 92 were heart disease, which after correcting for missing reports he put at "9 Dødsfald aarlig pr. 10.000 Individer i Vest-Grønland 1924-1933 (mod f. Eks. i det egentlige Danmark 1933: 14)" (9 deaths a year per 10,000 people, against 14 in Denmark in 1933), with 35 of the 92 among people aged 65 and over; pp. 103-104: deaths over the age of 80 in West Greenland 1901-30 "kun udgjorde 0,4 °/o af samtlige Dødsfald mod tilsvarende 16 °/o i det egentlige Danmark" (made up only 0.4 per cent of all deaths against 16 per cent in Denmark). P. 104: "Ogsaa efter mit Skøn er Arteriosklerose en ret almindelig Lidelse i Grønland, særlig i Forhold til Gennemsnitslevealderen for den grønlandske Befolkning" (in my judgement too, arteriosclerosis is a fairly common complaint in Greenland, especially in relation to the average lifespan of the Greenland population), after Høygaard (Angmagssalik 1936/37): no hypertension found, "Derimod var Arteriosclerosis ingenlunde ualmindelig" (arteriosclerosis, on the other hand, was by no means uncommon). P. 215 (English summary): "Arteriosclerosis and myocardiac degeneration are common, and heart disease a not uncommon cause of death, specially among the oldest age groups." The volume does not use the terms "iskæmisk", "ischaemic", "coronary" or "infarct"; his section on the circulation (pp. 102-105) covers heart disease under "Hjertesygdomme" and arteriosclerosis. ↩
  24. Bjerregaard and others (note 5), abstract: "The scientific evidence for this is weak and rests on early clinical evidence and uncertain mortality statistics ... We reviewed the literature and performed new analyses of the mortality statistics from Greenland, Canada, and Alaska. FINDINGS: The evidence for a low mortality from IHD among the Inuit is fragile and rests on unreliable mortality statistics. Mortality from stroke, however, is higher among the Inuit than among other western populations ... INTERPRETATION: The mortality from all cardiovascular diseases combined is not lower among the Inuit than in white comparison populations." The first author's institute: "Division for Research in Greenland, National Institute of Public Health", Copenhagen. A study of hospital cases in the Upernavik district, 1950-74, found "a higher frequency of apoplexy" and "a lower frequency or absence of acute myocardial infarction": N. Kromann and A. Green, Acta Medica Scandinavica 208 (1980), pp. 401-406, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7457208/ . ↩
  25. Fodor and others (note 22), abstract: the authors were at the "University of Ottawa Heart Institute" (first author) and elsewhere; "In view of data, which accumulated on this topic during the past 40 years, we conducted a review of published literature ... Most studies found that the Greenland Eskimos and the Canadian and Alaskan Inuit have CAD as often as the non-Eskimo populations ... their reports are still routinely cited as evidence for the cardioprotective effect of the 'Eskimo diet.'" ↩
  26. A. S. Abdelhamid and others, "Omega-3 fatty acids for the primary and secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease", Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2020, CD003177, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32114706/ : "We included 86 RCTs (162,796 participants) ... Most trials assessed LCn3 supplementation with capsules ... Meta-analysis and sensitivity analyses suggested little or no effect of increasing LCn3 on all-cause mortality". LCn3 are the long-chain omega-3 fats, including EPA and DHA. The deaths result pooled 45 of the 86 trials (143,693 people, 11,297 deaths, high-certainty evidence); the trials studied adults at varying cardiovascular risk, mainly in high-income countries. The review also found that they "may slightly reduce coronary heart disease mortality" and events (low-certainty evidence) and reduce blood triglycerides. ↩
  27. D. L. Bhatt and others, "Cardiovascular Risk Reduction with Icosapent Ethyl for Hypertriglyceridemia" (REDUCE-IT), New England Journal of Medicine 380 (2019), pp. 11-22, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30415628/ : icosapent ethyl is "a highly purified eicosapentaenoic acid ethyl ester"; 8,179 patients "with established cardiovascular disease or with diabetes and other risk factors, who had been receiving statin therapy" and had raised fasting triglycerides; the conclusion is for "patients with elevated triglyceride levels despite the use of statins"; "A primary end-point event occurred in 17.2% of the patients in the icosapent ethyl group, as compared with 22.0% of the patients in the placebo group (hazard ratio, 0.75)". The primary end point combined cardiovascular death, non-fatal heart attack, non-fatal stroke, coronary revascularisation and unstable angina. "A larger percentage of patients in the icosapent ethyl group than in the placebo group were hospitalized for atrial fibrillation or flutter (3.1% vs. 2.1%, P=0.004). Serious bleeding events occurred in 2.7% of the patients in the icosapent ethyl group and in 2.1% in the placebo group (P=0.06)." "Funded by Amarin Pharma". The placebo was mineral oil (Ridker, below). P. M. Ridker and others, "Effects of Randomized Treatment With Icosapent Ethyl and a Mineral Oil Comparator on Interleukin-1β, Interleukin-6, C-Reactive Protein, Oxidized Low-Density Lipoprotein Cholesterol, Homocysteine, Lipoprotein(a), and Lipoprotein-Associated Phospholipase A2", Circulation 146 (2022), pp. 372-379, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35762321/ : the trial compared the drug "with pharmaceutical grade mineral oil"; "The levels of biomarkers associated with atherosclerosis increased over time among those allocated to mineral oil treatment ... The effect of these findings on interpretation of the overall risk reductions in clinical events observed within REDUCE-IT is uncertain." ↩
  28. M. Peet and D. F. Horrobin, "A dose-ranging study of the effects of ethyl-eicosapentaenoate in patients with ongoing depression despite apparently adequate treatment with standard drugs", Archives of General Psychiatry 59 (2002), pp. 913-919, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12365878/ : 70 patients "with persistant depression despite ongoing treatment with an adequate dose of a standard antidepressant"; first author's address "Swallownest Court Hospital, Sheffield, England". The findings, and the later trials, are summarised in the Research tab. ↩
  29. Wikipedia, "Hugh Macdonald Sinclair", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugh_Macdonald_Sinclair : "In 1976, he was able to spend some time joining the expedition of Bang and Dyerberg in northwest Greenland, which led to his most widely known experiment, in which he put himself on an Inuit diet, consisting solely of seal, fish (including molluscs and crustaceans), and water for 100 days, starting in March 1979. Many analyses were done: extreme disaggregation of platelets was observed, with bleeding times rising from 3 min to over 50 min, accompanied by spontaneous hemorrhages." ↩