Every fourth or fifth day
Thule, 1915. Hardly a nose in the tribe goes a week without bleeding.1
That was the report of Peter Freuchen, a Dane who had quit medical school to stoke the boilers on an expedition to Greenland, then a Danish colony. In 1910 he and the explorer Knud Rasmussen set up a trading station at Thule, in the far north of the island, and he married there. Five years later a Danish medical weekly printed his notes on the health of the Inuit around him.2, 1
One complaint was so common that the people themselves mostly ignored it. Almost everyone's nose bled on its own at least every fourth or fifth day, as a rule for about half an hour.1
It was nothing new. In 1745 a book by Hans Egede, a missionary in Greenland, told English readers that its people were "very full of Blood, which is observed by their frequent Bleeding at the Nose." Few of them lived past fifty or sixty.3
Doctors kept noting the bleeding for the next two centuries. In 1940 Alfred Bertelsen, a Danish doctor who had come to Greenland in 1902, gathered their reports into a history of the island's diseases that ran to hundreds of pages. He had seen patients die of nosebleeds that would not stop. His English summary called the bleeding "remarkably frequent among the Greenlanders; a fact for which no absolutely satisfactory explanation has yet been found."4
Thirty years later two doctors from Aalborg went looking for something else and explained it. The explanation came with a story about the heart, and that story became an axiom.5
Blood in ice water
In 1969 Hans Olaf Bang and Jørn Dyerberg, at the hospital in Aalborg in northern Denmark, decided to find out why Greenlanders so rarely seemed to suffer blood clots. Above all they meant the clot in a heart artery that causes most heart attacks.6
Bang ran the hospital's clinical chemistry department. Dyerberg was a young doctor, and the chance to drive a dog sledge over the ice was part of the pull.7, 8
In August 1970 they went to the Umanak district on Greenland's west coast, 500 kilometres north of the Arctic Circle, with a laboratory technician, Aase Brøndum Nielsen. Its 2,600 people lived largely by seal hunting and fishing, and they ate their meat boiled or raw, never fried.6
They took blood from 130 Greenlanders before breakfast, the oldest of them 83. Each sample travelled for up to ten hours in ice water to the hospital in Umanak town, then went into a freezer and finally home to Aalborg.9
Reading the fats took two years on what Dyerberg remembered as "a very old gas chromatogram". He said in 2007 that it would now take a fortnight.8
The blood was low in cholesterol, and one omega-3 fat stood out. Eicosapentaenoic acid, EPA for short, was known to be plentiful in the body fat of Arctic sea animals, yet Danish blood held very little of it. In the Greenlanders it made up 16 per cent of the fats bound to cholesterol, against 1 per cent in the Danes. They also carried more of a second omega-3 fat from fish, DHA.10
Thirty-two Greenlanders living in Denmark had blood like any Dane's. So it was not in the genes. It had to come from what they ate.10
Sugar five times a day
In 1972 they went back, to Igdlorssuit, a settlement of about 140 people a hundred kilometres north of Umanak, where everyone lived at least partly on seal, whale and fish. Seven of them handed over an exact copy of every meal for a week, and each portion was weighed, ground up and frozen for the laboratory.11
Whale or seal was eaten every day, and sugar went into tea or coffee about five times a day. The meals held slightly less fat than average Danish food, which the doctors called remarkable. Now and then a person ate more than 600 grams of fat in a day. That gave "9000 Kcal!", the report said, exclamation mark and all.11
In April 1976 they came back in winter with a bigger team, among them a dietician, the Oxford nutritionist Hugh Sinclair and the Arctic traveller Ivars Silis, who handled the practical problems. Every journey went by dog sledge over the ice. At night it fell to 20 or 25 below zero, and at noon it often rose to about zero.12
Seals came in almost every day, and 50 Greenlanders gave the team copies of 178 days of meals.12
The shop told another story. Igdlorssuit had had one since 1918, and in 1975 it sold more than five tonnes of sugar, nearly 100 grams a day for every person in the settlement. These Greenlanders, the doctors wrote, were "not eating the traditional high fat and protein diet". It was not the amount of fat that set them apart. It was the kind.12
The clot that would not form
Next the doctors tested EPA in the laboratory. Platelets, the specks in the blood that clump at a wound to start a clot, normally make their clumping signal from another fat, arachidonic acid. From EPA they could make none, while the wall of a blood vessel could turn EPA into a substance that keeps platelets apart.13
In 1978 the Lancet printed the idea, written with John Vane and Salvador Moncada of the Wellcome Foundation, whose laboratory had found the vessel wall's own anti-clotting substance. The title ended with a question mark. Four years later Vane shared a Nobel Prize for work on that family of substances.14, 15
In the summer of 1978 the two Danes went back to test it in living people. Twenty-one Greenlanders volunteered, with no medicines and no alcohol for three days before. The doctors made a small standard cut on each and timed the bleeding.16
It lasted 8.1 minutes on average, against 4.8 minutes in 21 Danes of the same ages and sexes. In half the Greenlanders the platelets would not clump at all, even when the doctors added collagen, a powerful trigger.16
Their report put it in four words. "Our theory comes true." They had found, they wrote, the first well supported explanation of "the bleeding tendency in Greenlanders known for centuries".16
Ten years before, they had asked why heart disease was so rare in Greenland. Now they had their answer.16
A seal in the fridge
Hugh Sinclair, back from the 1976 trip, wanted to see what the Greenland diet did to clotting in Britain.17
His interest in the Inuit went back to the Second World War, when he studied snow blindness in Canada for the air force. In 1956 he blamed the rising deaths from hardened arteries on a lack of essential fats, in a letter to the Lancet that drew the longest correspondence the journal had seen.17, 18 Two years later he lost his readership at Oxford. His views and his manner with authority both counted against him, though Magdalen College kept him as a fellow.18
Colleagues remembered an eccentric and "an odd ball".18, 19
The research councils would not pay for a study of an Inuit diet. They called it "unethical" and "based on limited evidence". So in 1979, at 69, Sinclair put himself on it. For 100 days he ate only seal, fish and water, and every so often he cut his arm and timed the bleeding.17, 18
His bleeding time went from three minutes to 57. His boots filled with blood when he pruned his roses, and other diners at Magdalen complained venomously about the smell of seal meat.17
The Edinburgh cardiologist Michael Oliver once stayed at his house, along with the Aberdeen scientist Elspeth Smith. At breakfast Sinclair drank something he called tea. It was seal oil. The fridge was locked, with an ice pick hanging beside it, and when Smith asked what was inside, Sinclair very reluctantly found the key. Inside was a frozen seal he had been picking away at.19
One day Sinclair rang Oliver at home. He wanted a liver biopsy for fatty acid analysis the next day, and a doctor in Oxford had doubts. "He said my bleeding time is 60 minutes," Sinclair said. "Is that high?" Oliver told him it would be the last time he spoke to anyone. He didn't have the biopsy.19
His results were never properly written up.18
Not even mentioned
"The Greenlandic Inuit eat this really high fat diet, and they don't have heart disease." The founder of a supplement consulting firm told a trade magazine that in 2024, and the trade press was telling it the same way in 2007.20, 8
Bang and Dyerberg never counted a heart attack themselves. They took the rarity from other doctors, from official reports that listed not a single heart attack in the Umanak district in ten years, and from Bertelsen's history. It gave "some information about atherosclerosis", they wrote, but "does not even mention ischaemic heart disease", the disease of narrowed heart arteries.21, 22
Bertelsen's book says more than that. When he arrived in 1902 he found "not a few" older Greenlanders with degenerating heart muscle, and in his judgement hardened arteries were a fairly common complaint there. His English summary is blunter still. "Arteriosclerosis and myocardiac degeneration are common, and heart disease a not uncommon cause of death, specially among the oldest age groups." He never used the words "ischaemic heart disease" at all.23
And few Greenlanders grew old enough to die of it. From 1901 to 1930 only 0.4 per cent of deaths in West Greenland came after the age of 80, against 16 per cent in Denmark.23
In 2003 Peter Bjerregaard, of Denmark's National Institute of Public Health, and two colleagues went back over the death records for Greenland, Canada and Alaska. They found the evidence for few heart deaths "fragile", resting "on unreliable mortality statistics". Deaths from stroke were higher among the Inuit than in other Western populations, and all heart and blood vessel deaths together were no lower.24
In 2014 George Fodor of the University of Ottawa Heart Institute and three colleagues reviewed forty years of studies. Most found that Greenlanders and the Inuit of Canada and Alaska had coronary artery disease as often as other people. Yet Bang and Dyerberg's papers were "still routinely cited" as proof that the "Eskimo diet" protects the heart.25
Only us
By 2007 Dyerberg counted some 14,000 papers on omega-3 fats since their first in 1971. "It was easy to calculate for 1971," he said. "There was only us!"8
In 2020 a Cochrane review pooled 86 trials, with more than 160,000 people, mostly taking capsules, and found that more EPA and DHA made little or no difference to deaths overall.26 A 2019 trial took high-risk patients whose blood triglycerides stayed high despite statins. Against a placebo of mineral oil, a drug made of purified EPA cut heart deaths, heart attacks, strokes and other heart events by a quarter, though more patients went to hospital with an irregular heartbeat. A later look found that markers of heart risk had risen in the mineral oil group itself, which left what the result meant uncertain.27
Sinclair's friend David Horrobin tried EPA on the mind. In 2002 he and Malcolm Peet of Swallownest Court Hospital in Sheffield tested it on patients whose depression had not lifted on standard drugs. What they and later trials found is in the Research tab. DHA, found beside EPA in those Greenland samples, has a story of its own about the brain.28, 18, 8
Freuchen's neighbours at Thule bled from the nose and paid it little mind. Bang and Dyerberg traced that bleeding to a fat in the seal and whale they ate. The healthy hearts were the legend.1, 16, 25