The workman's brush
London, 1874. A workman turns a brush over a sieve of horsehair.1
The brush was a strong, round furniture brush, and he kept it turning without a pause. Under it, a pulp of minced brain was worked through a sieve so fine that every strand in its weave was made of eight single horse hairs.1
The brains were from oxen, more than a thousand of them, and they came from the butcher soaked in blood. The usual way to kill an ox was a blow of the pole-axe to the forehead, which punched a piece of skull into the brain. Then the slaughterman pushed a cane through the hole and down the spinal canal, and stirred it about to destroy the spinal cord.1
In the laboratory the brains were washed, skinned with fine forceps and dropped into strong alcohol to harden. If the alcohol was too weak, they stayed soft and rotted with "a fetid odour". The hardened brains went through a rotary mincing machine, and then to the brush.1
The man in charge was Johann Ludwig Wilhelm Thudichum, a German-born London doctor who did research for John Simon, the British government's medical officer.2 From 1870 to 1872 Thudichum had studied the chemistry of typhus, and his results could be no more than provisional. Nobody knew the chemistry of a healthy brain, so there was nothing to measure a sick one against.3 So he started again, with the healthy brain.2, 3
He could not get enough human brains that were perfectly fresh and free of disease. Oxen it had to be.1
He was taking the brain's fats apart, one by one. One of them he called kephalin. Inside it hid phosphatidylserine, and nobody would see it for another 67 years.1, 4
The chemical soul
In 1884 Thudichum put twelve years of work into one book, A Treatise on the Chemical Constitution of the Brain. He signed the preface that February from Pembroke Gardens, in Kensington in west London.5, 6
He had pulled a whole family of fats, the phosphatides, out of the brain. To him they were "the centre, life, and chemical soul of all bioplasm whatsoever, that of plants as well as animals".5
He hoped his chemistry would explain madness. Many forms of insanity, he wrote, came from "poisons fermented within the body". Once the brain's normal chemistry was known "to its uttermost detail", he had no doubt the poisons would be found, and then their antidotes.5
He made powerful enemies. The German pharmacologist Oscar Liebreich had drawn from the brain a substance called protagon, and held that it was one large molecule. Thudichum showed it was a mixture.2 In 1879 the journal he edited declared that the doctrine of protagon "has been properly rejected by all physiological chemists who know their business".6
The fight cost him. The criticism told against him, and after Simon retired he was pushed to end his government research. With no university post and no students to carry it on, his work was neglected and then forgotten.2
In 1901 the University of Giessen, where he had trained, honoured him fifty years on by renewing his diploma. It called him "a most celebrated exponent of the art of Medicine and Chemistry". A fortnight later he died of a stroke. At his own request, his papers were burned.2
Six years on, a King's College London chemist called Otto Rosenheim began to dig into the history of protagon. He was struck by Thudichum's work on it and set out to learn who this forgotten writer had been. In the end he won the dead man his credit.2
Three fats in one
Jordi Folch came to New York from Barcelona in 1936, a young doctor who wanted to learn the chemistry of medicine at the Rockefeller Institute.4
He meant to go home and fight in the Spanish Civil War for the Loyalists, the side that defended the Republic's government against an army rebellion. His family told him to stay.4
The whole family were Loyalists. Both his older brothers fought, and both had to flee to Toulouse. One day his father, a lawyer, businessman and prize-winning poet, heard that his name was on a list of people to be arrested the next day. He escaped to France by boat at once. Soon after, Folch's mother walked north through the Pyrenees, at night, in winter. Folch stayed on at the Rockefeller for nine years.4
His new ways of measuring fats needed pure brain fats as yardsticks, and he made them from the brains of cattle. Kephalin was supposed to be a single fat, as Thudichum had said. Folch measured what was in it, and the numbers did not fit.4
So he took it apart. In 1941 he and Howard Schneider reported an amino acid in ox-brain kephalin. It was serine, first found in silk and named after it.7, 8 By June he had pulled out the fat that carried it, phosphatidyl serine. In the papers that followed he showed that kephalin was not one fat but a mixture of at least three.4, 7
In 1944 McLean, a psychiatric hospital in Massachusetts, made him its director of research, and Harvard made him an assistant professor. His new laboratories there opened in 1946. The brains still came from cattle. At busy times his staff went to the local slaughterhouse almost every day. Then everyone, students, technicians and scientists alike, spent the day scraping grey matter off the brains with wooden tongue depressors. "For this I had to go to college?" one technician said.4
Cow brains at Abano Terme
In the 1980s the fat Folch had found was tested as a medicine, taken from cow brains, on people whose memory was failing.9
At Abano Terme, near Padua, the Italian drug company Fidia had its research laboratories, and its scientists published paper after paper on phosphatidylserine.10
In Bethesda, Maryland, Thomas Crook worked at a company called Memory Assessment Clinics. In 1991 he and his colleagues reported a trial of cow-brain phosphatidylserine in 149 people with what doctors call age-associated memory impairment. After twelve weeks the treated group did better than the placebo group on tests of learning and memory drawn from daily life. Those who had scored lowest at the start gained most.11
Two years later a scientist from Fidia's laboratories reported a trial in 494 older people with moderate to severe mental decline. They were treated for six months in 23 hospital units across north-east Italy. Those on the cow-brain fat did better than those on a placebo, in behaviour and in memory.12
Mad cows
By then a new disease had turned up in British cattle. Bovine spongiform encephalopathy was first described in the mid-1980s, and like the other diseases of its kind it left the brain looking like a sponge. It was carried by prions, unusual proteins that survive the usual ways of killing germs. In 1996 doctors in Britain described a new form of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, the human illness of the same kind, and the likely cause was beef from infected cattle.9
By then phosphatidylserine was also sold as a supplement, and until the mid-1990s it came only from cow brains. That suddenly looked risky.13
In 1996 Parris Kidd, a scientist who championed phosphatidylserine, wrote about it in the journal of the supplement company Thorne Research. With "the 'mad cow' disease epidemic in Great Britain", eating bovine brain "might be deemed a questionable practice". Soy phosphatidylserine was already on sale.13, 14
Soy phosphatidylserine is not pressed out of beans. It is made from soy lecithin, which holds the soybean's own membrane fats, by treating it with serine and an enzyme that turns those fats into phosphatidylserine.9
The new molecule was not quite the old one, so results from cow brains might not hold for soy. Its fatty acids were mostly polyunsaturated, while cow-brain phosphatidylserine carried mainly saturated ones and long-chain ones such as DHA.9
In Maastricht, a team gave soy phosphatidylserine or a placebo to 120 older people with memory complaints for twelve weeks. In 2001 they reported "no significant differences" between the groups "in any of the outcome variables".15
Little scientific evidence
In 2002 lawyers for a petitioner who made phosphatidylserine from soy wrote to the US Food and Drug Administration. They asked for supplement labels to be allowed to say that phosphatidylserine "may reduce the risk of dementia in the elderly".9
The agency read the trials. Most had used cow-brain phosphatidylserine and only two used soy, and all ten it weighed were "seriously flawed or limited in their reliability in one or more ways".9
On 13 May 2003 it said it would not act against labels that carried the claim. The agency's own words had to sit directly beneath it, in the same size of type.9
"Very limited and preliminary scientific research suggests that phosphatidylserine may reduce the risk of dementia in the elderly. FDA concludes that there is little scientific evidence supporting this claim."9
A year and a half later the agency admitted two errors in how it had judged the trials. It looked at them again and kept every word of the warning.16
Twelve years younger
Crook's team had asked one more question of their 1991 trial. What did the gains mean for people's lives?13
They chose one test, learning to put names to faces, and a subgroup of 57 of the more impaired people, whose average age was 64. They calculated that on that test, cow-brain phosphatidylserine had brought them to the level of an average 52-year-old.13
In Kidd's 1996 retelling, phosphatidylserine had "rolled back the clock" by roughly 12 years. Two sentences later he added that this "can scarcely be called a reversal of age-associated memory impairment", though Crook's team thought the effect might matter to many patients and doctors. Eight pages on, in his conclusions, he put it more boldly. On names and faces, "PS reversed more than a decade of decline".13
By 2007 Kidd had written a short book on it. The book's blurb promises "a natural substance that can turn back the clock on aging". It says Crook's team "found that PS could restore up to 12 years worth of lost mental function".17
The twelve years outlived the cow brains. An article on the website of Natural Grocers, an American grocery chain, has a section headed "PS rejuvenates the aging brain, improves memory". Citing Crook's trial, it says "the researchers calculated that this subgroup's memory improved by 12 'functional' years". It does not say the trial used phosphatidylserine from cow brains. The chain's own guide says most of the supplements are now made from soy.18
Crook's figure was one calculation, on one test, for one subgroup taking a fat from cow brains. The soy trial in Maastricht found no real difference on any measure.13, 15
Soybean pods
Today phosphatidylserine is made from soya, sunflower or fish, and the trials of it, cow brain and soybean alike, are sorted on the Research tab.19
The fat Folch found has a job of its own. In a living cell it keeps to the inner face of the membrane. A team in Denver showed in 1992 that when a cell starts to die, the phosphatidylserine turns up on the outside. The body's clean-up cells, the macrophages, know it on sight and eat the dying cell.20
Thudichum had a thousand ox brains pushed through horsehair to find the fats of the mind. He had already said where else they lived. The chemical soul, he wrote in 1884, belonged to "plants as well as animals". You will find it in the soybean pods in the photograph at the top of this page.5