NR-029Ingredient Atlas entry · Trace mineral

Selenium

Se, a trace mineral

Dragoon horses losing their hoofs and manes on the Missouri, a Swedish chemist who lost his sense of smell to a bubble of gas the size of a pea, rats whose livers broke down on the wrong yeast, and children dying in a Chinese county that gave its name to a heart disease. For more than a century selenium was known only as a poison. Then it turned out to be one the body cannot do without. The hope that it keeps cancer away rose with one small trial in 1996 and fell with a far bigger one.

  • Found in: Brazil nuts, fish, meat and eggs
  • Most tested: 200 µg a day
  • Mostly taken daily for weeks or months
A sack of Brazil nuts in their shells at a market stall
A sack of Brazil nuts in their shells at a market stall. Photo by Raíssa Lisboa on Pexels

The horses at Fort Randall

Fort Randall, August 1856. The horses of the Second Dragoons are going lame.1

Four companies of the regiment had ridden in to the army post on the Missouri River about the 10th, some leading new horses, and camped on the lower side of a creek bed that stood empty most of the year, known at the post as the Dry Ravine. About ten days later the sickness broke out in all four companies at once.1

The horses' throats and jaws swelled. Their feet grew inflamed and tender, then festered where the hoof meets the skin, until the hoof began to come away and a new one formed in its place. They lost the hair of their manes and tails.1

They still wanted to eat, but they were too lame to go looking for grass, and the post had no hay or grain to give them.1

Every case began on that lower side of the ravine, and once forage reached the post no new ones followed. The surgeon, T. C. Madison, could not say whether a poisonous plant or some contagion was to blame. Even the Indians of the country had never seen anything like it.1

Madison ended his report with a complaint. "We have no veterinary surgeons in our service, and, consequently, when these noble animals become seriously sick, they almost invariably die."1

Nobody would name the cause for almost eighty years. It was selenium, drawn up from the soil by the plants the horses grazed. The element had been found in a Swedish acid works nearly forty years before the dragoons rode in.2, 8

Red sludge at Gripsholm

In 1817 the chemist Jöns Jacob Berzelius was part owner, with two partners, of a sulphuric acid works at Gripsholm. It burned sulphur roasted out of ore from the copper mine at Falun.2, 3

A reddish powder kept settling at the bottom of the lead-walled chamber where the acid formed. A former owner, Bjuggren, had noticed it long before. A chemist told him it must contain arsenic, so he stopped using Falun sulphur. Berzelius and his partners went on burning it, and the red layer kept building up.3

They burned a little of the red powder, and in a hot flame what was left gave off a strong smell of radish, or rotten cabbage. Chemists knew that smell from tellurium, a rare element named after the earth, and Berzelius and his partner Gahn took it for tellurium.3, 4, 5

Berzelius had the whole sediment scraped out of the chamber, about four pounds of it, and worked on it in Stockholm. It was not tellurium. It was a new element. It burned with an azure-blue flame. Softened by heat, it could be kneaded like sealing wax and drawn out into fine threads, and held up to the light they were a clear ruby red.3, 4

Tellurium was named for Tellus, the earth. So Berzelius named tellurium's look-alike for Selene, the moon.3, 5

He also found out what it could do to a chemist. He breathed in a bubble of its gas, hydrogen selenide, no larger than a small pea. He tasted something like bad eggs at the back of his throat, then something sharper, and a wave of giddiness. After that the strongest ammonia barely registered in his nose. He was still suffering days later, when he wrote to a friend in London.4

The plant the cattle knew

Marco Polo's book, in the Italian version printed at Venice in 1559, carries a warning about the rhubarb mountains of Suhchau, at the north-western end of the Great Wall. Travellers dared not take any beasts there but local ones, because a plant grew there "so poisonous that cattle which eat it lose their hoofs. The cattle of the country know it and eschew it."6

In 1920 O. A. Beath, at the University of Wyoming, wrote much the same of a wild vetch called astragalus. Cattle penned in with it "would not touch the plant at all and after a few days could not be kept inside the fence."7

On the northern plains the sickness Madison had seen came to be called alkali disease, and the name was wrong.2, 8 In the early 1930s K. W. Franke suspected a rare poisonous element in grain grown in the sick districts, and W. O. Robinson found selenium in it.2 Beath's team showed that some wild vetches drew so much selenium out of the soil that they could kill. By 1937 A. L. Moxon could title a South Dakota report Alkali Disease, or Selenium Poisoning.8 In Wyoming it was blamed for a faster killer too, which stockmen called blind staggers.2, 7

Selenium was now the poison of the plains. In an exposed herd, as many as six animals in ten showed the signs, and some died.8 In 1943 rats fed selenium grew tumours in their livers, and it became a suspected cause of cancer as well.8

Factor 3

Klaus Schwarz had a different problem with his rats.8

He was a German biochemist working at the National Institutes of Health in Bethesda. When his rats ate a diet made with torula yeast, their livers broke down. When baker's yeast took its place, the trouble disappeared. Something in the good yeast protected them. He called the unknown protector factor 3.8, 9

In 1957 he and Calvin Foltz, working with extracts of pig kidney, found that factor 3 held selenium.9 The poison of the plains was a nutrient. Within a year, researchers had tied a lack of it to white muscle disease in lambs and calves.8 In the early 1970s it turned up built into the body's enzymes, the proteins that drive its chemistry.9

Regulators took longer to allow it in animal feed. The 1943 rat study still stood against selenium, and only in 1973 did scientists at the Food and Drug Administration and the National Cancer Institute declare that "judicious administration of selenium derivatives to domestic animals would not constitute a carcinogenic risk."8

The Keshan sickness

Keshan County, winter 1935. In China's far north-east, an unknown disease is killing people.10

It came on suddenly, with pressure and pain in the chest and vomiting, and it often ended in death. A year later doctors found that it was a disease of the heart muscle. It struck young children and women of child-bearing age, and in the 1940s more than eight in ten of those who caught it died.10

It turned up along a broad belt of hill country, from the north-east of China to the south-west. In the same districts it struck farming families and left the families of factory workers alone.10

In the 1960s and 1970s teams led by the Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences measured the grain, the blood and the hair of people in the sick districts. All of it held far less selenium than in places without the disease. Farming families lived on grain and vegetables grown in that ground. The factory workers' families ate more varied food, with more of it from animals.10

In 1974 they put it to the test. In Mianning County, in Sichuan, village health workers went round once a week with tablets for children aged one to nine. Some children got selenium and the rest got dummy tablets, and neither the families nor the health workers knew which. In the first year, 54 of the 3,985 children on dummy tablets caught Keshan disease, and half of them died. Of the 4,510 children given selenium, 10 fell ill and none died. More children took part the second year, and the result was much the same.10

Bigger trials followed across whole communes and counties, and selenium tablets and salt with selenium added became the health ministry's weapons against the disease. Since 1990 it has almost vanished.10

Selenium was not the whole story. Keshan disease came and went with the seasons, which pointed to an infection as well. In the 1990s researchers at the University of North Carolina gave a harmless strain of a virus known for inflaming the heart to mice short of selenium. Inside them, it mutated into a strain that damaged the heart.10, 11

Hair and nails in Enshi

Enshi County, Hubei, 1961. In a handful of villages in central China, people's hair and nails are falling out.12

In the five worst villages almost half of the 248 people who lived there fell ill between 1961 and 1964. The scientists who studied it traced it to the ground. The source was a stony coal packed with selenium. Weathering carried the selenium into the soil, and the lime that farmers there had always spread on their fields let the crops take it up.12

What tipped it over was a drought. The rice crop failed, so the villagers ate more of their maize and vegetables, which were loaded with selenium. Their vegetables and grain, their hair and their blood held up to a thousand times more selenium than samples from the Keshan districts. The same country had the shortage and the excess.12

Certain cancers

Christmas Day, 1996. The Journal of the American Medical Association publishes a trial led by L. C. Clark at the Arizona Cancer Center.13

It had set out to test whether selenium would cut new skin cancers in 1,312 people who had already had one. It did not. But in 1990, seven years in, the team had added other targets. On those the selenium group had half as many deaths from cancer as the dummy-pill group, and fewer cancers of the lung, bowel and prostate. The team said these needed confirming in a new trial.13

A history of selenium research published in 2002 was subtitled "from poison to prevention", and its summing-up pointed to Clark's "promise" of cutting prostate cancer by more than six in ten.8 In 2003 America's Food and Drug Administration let selenium supplements carry the line "Selenium may reduce the risk of certain cancers." Directly beneath it, in the same size type, had to go a disclaimer that ended, "However, FDA has determined that this evidence is limited and not conclusive."14

By then a far bigger test was under way. From 2001, 35,533 men took selenium, vitamin E, both, or dummy pills. In September 2008 the trial's monitors stopped it. Neither selenium nor vitamin E had prevented prostate cancer, and the men taking selenium had a little more diabetes, though not enough to rule out chance.15

In 2018 a Cochrane review pooled the trials and found "no beneficial effect of selenium supplements in reducing cancer risk", and rated that finding high certainty.16 The old line lives on. A popular health site's guide to selenium's benefits, first posted in 2019, still says it "may help lower the risk of certain cancers."17

Back to the hoof

Selenium poisoning still turns up on the plains, though far more rarely than the early researchers claimed. From the late 1980s a University of Wyoming team spent six years looking for it in the state's livestock. They found it, and it looked as it had at Fort Randall. Manes and tails thinned, and hoofs cracked until the toe came away.7

They never confirmed a single case of blind staggers. Of 23 cases that matched it, ten were lead poisoning, eight were a brain disease that too much sulphur can cause, and the rest were infections. They decided selenium should never have been blamed.7

What trials in people found about selenium and mood, memory and thinking is in the Research tab.

Madison never learned why the dragoons' horses lost their hoofs. The answer had been waiting since 1817 in a Swedish acid works, in an element named for the moon.

See what modern trials found

Myths and facts

In the record, or legend?

Every story you will read about this mineral, checked against the oldest source we could find.

  • Berzelius named selenium after the moon

    In the record

    His own memoir of 1818: "dérivé de sélénê (la lune)", to recall its likeness to tellurium3

  • The dragoons' horses at Fort Randall in 1856 had selenium poisoning

    Likely

    The surgeon's description matches alkali disease, and later selenium scientists called it the first report of that disease. No tissue from the horses was ever tested for selenium, and Madison's one post-mortem found nothing telling1, 2

  • Marco Polo described selenium poisoning

    Told, not shown

    The hoof passage is found only in Ramusio's Italian version, printed in 1559. Its editors suggested a poisonous plant and quoted others who blamed a grass or stony ground. Selenium writers claimed it in the 20th century on the symptom alone6, 7

  • Blind staggers in cattle was selenium poisoning

    Legend

    Taught from the 1930s. A six-year Wyoming study from 1988 never confirmed a case. The cases that matched were lead poisoning, a sulphur-linked brain disease or infections, and its authors judged it misdiagnosed7

  • A lack of selenium caused Keshan disease

    Partly

    Chinese studies found it the major cause, and selenium tablets cut cases in the 1970s trials. Other causes were not ruled out, and mouse studies point to a virus acting with the deficiency10, 11

  • Taking selenium keeps cancer away

    Legend

    The 1996 trial missed its own target, skin cancer, and its hopeful figures came from targets it added later. A trial of 35,533 men found no effect on prostate cancer, and a 2018 Cochrane review found no benefit in well-run trials13, 15, 16

In the record means a source from the time, or a scholar quoting one, says it. Likely means a named expert's reasoned identification. Told, not shown means one interested party says it and nothing checks it. Partly means a real event sits under a bigger story. Legend means the earliest source is far too late or missing. Wrong date means the event is real but the popular date doesn't match the record.

Notes

Every fact in the story points to one of these. Where a translation is ours, the note says so.

Show all 17 notes Hide the notes
  1. T. C. Madison, "Sanitary report—Fort Randall", written September 1857, in Richard H. Coolidge (comp.), Statistical Report on the Sickness and Mortality in the Army of the United States ... from January, 1855, to January, 1860 (Washington, 1860), pp. 37-41, National Library of Medicine scan at https://archive.org/details/101523698.nlm.nih.gov . p. 37: "Fort Randall is situated on the right bank of the Missouri river, and in the Territory of Nebraska". p. 38: a creek "which, from the fact that it is dry three fourths of the year, has been denominated the Dry Ravine." p. 41, "Veterinary": "A very fatal disease manifested itself among the dragoon horses, which is supposed not to have been described in works on veterinary surgery. Four companies of the second dragoons arrived at this post about the 10th of August, 1856, one squadron from Fort Lookout and one from Big Sioux river, the latter accompanied by a number of new or remount horses. The four companies encamped on the east or lower side of the dry ravine ... About the 20th of August the disease commenced simultaneously in all four companies, and many horses died, not, however, until after the lapse of weeks and months. The following symptoms were observed: first, that, among the remount horses from below, there was a sort of catarrh, or distemper, with running at the nose, and among all the horses a swelling of the skin of the throat and jaw; also, inflammation, swelling, and suppuration of the sheath, tenderness and inflammation of the feet, followed by suppuration at the point where the hoof joins the skin, the hoof, in a measure, detaching itself, and a new one forming in its place. These were also accompanied by loss of the manes and tails. The appetite was uniformly good; but, from extreme tenderness of the feet, they were unable to move about in search of food, and it appears that at that time they were entirely dependent upon grazing, there being no forage at the post for issue. Sorrel horses appeared to suffer most, but no color escaped. The private horses of officers shared the fate of the public animals. A few mules and Indian ponies were similarly affected. ... No treatment was effectual, or afforded permanent relief. Bleeding in the feet was tried, but its effect was merely temporary. Every case of disease originated on the lower side of the dry ravine, above alluded to. After forage was provided for the horses no new cases occurred ... Whether the disease was caused by eating any poisonous herbs, or propagated in any manner by contagion, could not be satisfactorily determined, the origin and progress of the malady being something entirely new even to the Indians and half-breeds of the country. One post mortem was made of a horse that died late in the winter, but developed nothing important ... It is well to remark, that we have no veterinary surgeons in our service, and, consequently, when these noble animals become seriously sick, they almost invariably die." The fort stood in what is now South Dakota (Wikipedia, "Fort Randall", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fort_Randall ). ↩
  2. S. G. Knott, C. W. R. McCray and W. T. K. Hall, "Selenium poisoning in horses in North Queensland", Queensland Journal of Agricultural Science 15, no. 2 (June 1958), pp. 43-58, https://era.daf.qld.gov.au/id/eprint/13629/ . p. 43: "Selenium, discovered by Berzelius in 1817, was shown to be toxic to animals in 1842 (Japha 1842)." "A disease of dragoon horses at Fort Randall, Nebraska, in 1856, characterised by lameness and loss of hair from the mane and tail (Madison 1860), was the first report of the disease later known as 'alkali disease'. Subsequently this disease was shown to occur over large areas of semi-arid plains of North America and to affect all grazing stock. A similar disorder resulted in animals fed grains grown in these areas. A much more rapidly fatal disease, 'blind staggers', caused stock losses, particularly in Wyoming." pp. 43-44: "The connection between these apparently unrelated enzootic diseases and selenium was not suspected till Franke (1934) postulated a rare toxic element in grain from affected areas. The presence of selenium in this grain was demonstrated by Robinson (1933). Independent investigation in Wyoming showed that 'blind staggers' was also due to the ingestion of herbage containing selenium (Beath, Eppson and Gilbert 1935)." The authors quote Madison from Trelease and Beath's 1949 book on selenium. The link rests on Madison's description alone, since no horse was tested; hence "Likely" in the panel. ↩
  3. J. J. Berzelius, "Recherches sur un nouveau corps minéral trouvé dans le soufre fabriqué à Fahlun", Annales de chimie et de physique 9 (1818), beginning p. 160, scan of the volume at https://archive.org/details/s3id13207770 (our translation). pp. 160-161: the Falun sulphur is made from "des pyrites qui abondent, en plusieurs endroits, dans la mine de cuivre" (pyrites found in many places in the copper mine), roasted in kilns; "il se dépose au fond de la chambre de plomb une masse pulvérulente rougeâtre. Cette circonstance a été observée, il y a long-temps, par M. Bjuggren, qui était alors possesseur de la fabrique d'acide sulfurique à Gripsholm. Il trouva qu'elle n'a point lieu lorsqu'on se sert d'une autre espèce de soufre; et comme il avait appris par un chimiste que la matière rouge devait contenir de l'arsenic, il n'employa plus le soufre de Fahlun. Depuis que cette fabrique a été achetée par MM. Gahn, Eggertz et moi, on y a constamment brûlé le soufre de Fahlun. Le sédiment rouge ... avait par conséquent augmenté en quantité" (a reddish powdery mass settles at the bottom of the lead chamber; Bjuggren, then owner of the Gripsholm works, saw it long ago, was told by a chemist it must contain arsenic, and stopped using Falun sulphur; since Gahn, Eggertz and Berzelius bought the works, Falun sulphur has always been burned there and the red sediment has grown). p. 162: the first sample was a red powder from the bottom of the glass dishes of nitric acid in the same chamber, no more than 3 grams from 260 kilograms of sulphur; burned, it left an ash that under the blowpipe gave "une forte odeur de radis ou de chou pourri, analogue à celle que Klaproth dit se produire lorsqu'on traite de la même manière le tellure" (a strong smell of radish or rotten cabbage, like the one Klaproth says tellurium gives). p. 163: "Je laissai donc ôter toute la masse qui se trouvait au fond de la chambre de plomb ... Elle pesait environ quatre livres" (I had the whole mass at the bottom of the lead chamber removed; it weighed about four pounds). p. 164: lit at a candle flame, the red precipitate coloured the flame's edges "en bleu d'azur". p. 173: heated, selenium softens and melts, and while cooling "comme la cire d'Espagne, on peut le pétrir entre les doigts et en tirer de longs fils" (like sealing wax, it can be kneaded between the fingers and drawn into long threads); in very thin layers it is translucent, "rouge de rubis" (ruby red), and the threads seen against the light are red. p. 166: "un corps élémentaire combustible jusqu'ici inconnu, auquel j'ai donné le nom de sélénium, dérivé de sélénê (la lune), pour rappeler son analogie avec le tellure" (a combustible element unknown until now, which I have named selenium, from selene, the moon, to recall its likeness to tellurium). ↩
  4. J. J. Berzelius to Alexander Marcet, abstract of a letter, "On the discovery of a new alkali and a new metal", Annals of Philosophy 11 (April 1818), pp. 291-293, with Marcet's covering letter dated London, 25 March 1818, scan at https://archive.org/details/annalsofphilosop11lond . p. 292: "the information which I gave you in my last letter, respecting the discovery of tellurium in sulphur procured from the mine of Fahlun, which is employed in the manufacture of sulphuric acid at Gripsholm, appears to be incorrect. I have just been making a more accurate examination of it at Stockholm, and I have found that what M. Gahn and I took for tellurium is a new substance possessed of very interesting properties." "The threads, when drawn out to a great degree of fineness, if held between the eye and the light, are transparent, and of a ruby colour". "When this new substance is heated by a candle, it burns with an azure-blue flame, and exhales a strong odour of horseradish, which led us to suppose that it was tellurium." "The analogy of tellurium has induced me to give it the name of selenium." Of selenuretted hydrogen (hydrogen selenide): "if it is breathed less diluted, it produces a painful sensation in the nose and a violent inflammation, ending in a catarrh, which continues for a considerable length of time." pp. 292-293: "I am still suffering from having breathed, some days ago, a bubble of selenuretted hydrogenous gas, no larger than a small pea. Scarcely had I perceived the hepatic taste in the fauces, when I experienced another acute sensation: I was seized with a giddiness, which, however, soon left me, and the sensibility of the schneiderian membrane was so far destroyed that the strongest ammonia produced scarcely any effect upon the nose." "Hepatic" was the chemists' word for the smell and taste of hydrogen sulphide, the gas of bad eggs. ↩
  5. Wikipedia, "Tellurium", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tellurium , lead section: Martin Heinrich Klaproth "named the new element in 1798 after the Latin tellus 'earth'." ↩
  6. Henry Yule (trans. and ed.), The Book of Ser Marco Polo, 3rd edition revised by Henri Cordier (London: John Murray, 1903), vol. 1, Book 1, chapter 43, "Of the Province of Sukchur", Project Gutenberg #10636, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/10636 . The text: "Over all the mountains of this province rhubarb is found in great abundance ... [Travellers, however, dare not visit those mountains with any cattle but those of the country, for a certain plant grows there which is so poisonous that cattle which eat it lose their hoofs. The cattle of the country know it and eschew it.]" Yule's introduction (section 90) says he put "between brackets everything peculiar to Ramusio's version that seemed to me to have a just claim to be reckoned authentic", and (section 60) that Ramusio's Italian was "published at Venice two years after his death, in the second volume of the Navigationi e Viaggi"; his introduction gives Ramusio's death as July 1557. Note 2 to the chapter: the city is Suhchau, which "lies just within the extreme north-west angle of the Great Wall." Note 4: Yule thought the plant "not unlikely ... akin to the Andromeda ovalifolia", a poisonous shrub of the Himalaya; Cordier adds Bretschneider's suggestion of a grass, Stipa inebrians, and Palladius's view that the hoofs were lost "not on account of some poisonous grass, but in consequence of the stony ground." ↩
  7. M. F. Raisbeck, D. O'Toole and colleagues, "Re-evaluation of selenium toxicity in grazing mammals", Proceedings, American Society for Surface Mining and Reclamation (1995), pp. 372-383, https://doi.org/10.21000/JASMR95010372 , PDF at https://www.asrs.us/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/0372-Raisbeck.pdf . p. 372: "It has become fashionable to begin any paper on the toxic effects of Se by citing historical documents such as Marco Polo's journal as early reports of selenosis (Trelease and Beath, 1949a; Harris, 1991; James et al., 1990). In point of fact, however, the first conclusive evidence of naturally-occurring Se toxicity (selenosis) in mammals was contained in reports from the Wyoming and South Dakota Agricultural Experiment Stations during the 1930's". pp. 372-373: "As noted by Beath (1920), 'when cattle were placed in enclosures on astragalus they would not touch the plant at all and after a few days could not be kept inside the fence'" (O. A. Beath, Chemical examination of Astragalus bisulcatus, University of Wyoming, 1920). p. 373: a survey of selenosis in livestock "conducted by the University of Wyoming from 1988 through 1991" found only isolated instances. pp. 373-374, on confirmed field cases: "Typically, 1-2 months after exposure to the suspect feedstuffs, owners report noting alopecia of the mane and tail. Soft tissue swelling in the region of the coronet and/or a very fine, horizontal crack in the surface of the hoof just distal to the coronet are also noted ... The hoof lesion and attendant lameness progressively worsen over a period of several months until, finally, the toe separates from the hoof and is lost." p. 374: "Twenty-three accessions met the clinical criteria of the condition described as 'blind staggers' ... Of these, 10 were diagnosed as lead poisoning on the basis of tissue lead concentrations, eight were histopathologically diagnosed as polioencephalomalacia and the remainder attributed to various pathogenic infections." An accession is "a single incident of a disease occurrence reported to our laboratory. It might represent a single pet horse, or an outbreak in a herd of cattle." p. 378 (Discussion): "The results of a 6-year, prospective study of naturally-occurring selenosis in Wyoming indicate that, while chronic selenosis does occur in domestic animals in the state, the incidence is much less than that alluded to by early investigators and the popular press. The clinical presentation of this condition is similar to that originally referred to as 'alkali disease', which is characterized by damage to epithelial structures such as skin and hoof." "To date, we have not verified a single case of the condition referred to as 'blind staggers'", and "the term 'blind staggers' has been historically applied by stockmen to any disease condition of ruminants in which animals exhibit neurologic signs"; its signs as described by Beath's group "are virtually identical to those of polioencephalomalacia, a condition now known to sometimes result from excess dietary sulfur", and with a review of the Beath group's archived material this led them "to conclude that the condition was mis-diagnosed and probably should have never been attributed to Se." The authors were at the University of Wyoming, Laramie. ↩
  8. J. E. Oldfield, "A brief history of selenium research: from alkali disease to prostate cancer (from poison to prevention)", American Society of Animal Science (2002), https://asas.org/docs/publications/oldfieldhist.pdf . p. 1: "When Berzelius discovered selenium in the sludge of sulfuric acid vats in 1817 ..."; "In 1937, A. L. Moxon published a report at the South Dakota Agricultural Experiment Station, in which he identified selenium as the toxic principle in some livestock-poisoning plants on the Western ranges (Moxon, 1937). The livestock problem, mistakenly called 'alkali disease,' occurred in acute form following the consumption by range animals of some wild vetches of the genus Astragalus, which accumulated toxic amounts of selenium from the soil (Beath et al., 1935)." Raisbeck and colleagues (note 7, pp. 372-373) later doubted the plants' part: such accumulator plants are "extremely unpalatable", and many "contain other, more significant toxins such as swainsonine, which render the theoretical toxicity of any Se present moot." Reference list: "Moxon, A. L. 1937. Alkali Disease, or Selenium Poisoning. Bull. 331. South Dakota Agric. Exp. Sta., Brookings." "In 1957, a German émigré biochemist, Klaus Schwarz, working at the National Institutes of Health in Bethesda, published a paper that changed forever the public conception of selenium (Schwarz and Foltz, 1957). Schwarz was concerned about problems of liver necrosis in laboratory rats he was feeding on a diet containing torula yeast as the source of protein. When he substituted baker's yeast (Saccharomyces) for the torula yeast, the problem disappeared, and after considerable study he was able to show that torula was deficient in selenium whereas Saccharomyces was not. He had thus identified the first 'selenium-responsive' disease, and this led shortly to selenium being recognized as an essential trace mineral nutrient". pp. 1-2: diseases "found to relate to selenium deficiency, including 'white muscle disease' in calves and lambs (Muth et al., 1958)". p. 2: "The U.S. Food and Drug Administration had to be convinced that selenium was safe at the recommended supplementary levels, and it cited studies suggesting that selenium was carcinogenic (Nelson et al., 1943). These studies involved rats that were fed diets inadequate in protein, to which selenium was added at levels much higher than needed to correct a selenium deficiency. The hypothesis was thus unsupported, and in 1973 scientists at the National Cancer Institute and the Food and Drug Administration issued a joint statement declaring that 'judicious administration of selenium derivatives to domestic animals would not constitute a carcinogenic risk' (USFDA, 1973)." Reference: "Nelson, A. A., O. G. Fitzhugh, and H. O. Calvery. 1943. Liver tumors following cirrhosis caused by selenium in rats. Cancer Res. 3:230–236." pp. 3-4: "It is interesting to reflect on this remarkable change in public awareness of the trace element selenium. Reviled in the early 20th century as a poisoner of livestock—where as many as 60% of an exposed animal population would show symptoms of alkali disease and some would die—selenium closed the millennium with the demonstration by Clark and colleagues at the Arizona Cancer Center of the promise of protecting a similar percentage of humans (>60%) from the ravages of prostate cancer (Clark et al., 1996)." Oldfield's paper also says Berzelius "was looking for, and found, a toxic element that was contributing to worker illness in the acid plant"; Berzelius's own accounts (notes 3 and 4) say nothing of sick workers. ↩
  9. August Böck, Leopold Flohé, Josef Köhrle and colleagues, "Selenoproteins – biochemistry and clinical relevance", guest editorial, Biological Chemistry 388 (October 2007), pp. 985-986, https://doi.org/10.1515/BC.2007.148 , free copy at https://epub.ub.uni-muenchen.de/17770/1/bc.2007.148.pdf . p. 985: "selenium had been recognized as an essential trace element ... for higher vertebrates by Klaus Schwarz (see photo) and Calvin M. Foltz, who isolated a selenium-containing compound from hog kidney, the 'factor 3' that protected rats against dietary liver necrosis." "Fifteen years later, the first selenoproteins were detected in mammals as well as in bacteria indicating that the trace element might fulfil its biological function as an integral constituent of enzymes." Photo caption: "Klaus Schwarz (1914–1978)". Their paper is K. Schwarz and C. M. Foltz, "Selenium as an integral part of factor 3 against dietary necrotic liver degeneration", Journal of the American Chemical Society 79 (1957), pp. 3292-3293 (not read; paywalled). ↩
  10. Junshi Chen, "An original discovery: selenium deficiency and Keshan disease (an endemic heart disease)", Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 21, no. 3 (2012), pp. 320-326, https://apjcn.nhri.org.tw/server/APJCN/21/3/320.pdf ; PubMed https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22705420/ . p. 320: "Keshan disease was discovered in the winter of 1935 in northeast China when an outbreak of an unknown disease occurred with sudden onset of precardial oppression and pain, nausea and vomiting and fatal termination. The disease was named Keshan disease (KD), because the outbreak first occurred in the Keshan county of Heilongjiang province and its cause was unknown. Later on, KD was discovered in other areas of northeast and also southwest China, including Sichuan and Yunnan provinces. It had a very high case fatality, which was greater than 80% in the 1940s and around 30% since. It was at first suspected to be an acute infectious disease, and in 1936 was shown to be a myocardial disease with necrotic lesions of unknown nature. The vulnerable sub-populations were 2-7 year-old children and women of child-bearing age. The disease almost disappeared since 1990." "with obvious seasonal variations (peak season: winter in northeast China and spring in southwest China) ... in the same endemic area, farmer families were affected, but the factory workers and other professional families were not affected." The author writes of research "conducted in 1960-70 in China ... based on my personal experience." p. 321: "Extensive observational epidemiological studies and population-based intervention trials were conducted in northeast and southwest endemic areas in China from 1960-80s with the Keshan Disease Research Group of the Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences as the leading research force." "Keshan disease occurred essentially in hilly and mountainous areas with specific focal distribution in a wide belt-like region throughout mainland China, from northeast to southwest". The selenium in maize and rice, and in the blood and hair of residents, was significantly lower at endemic sites (Figures 6-9, Table 1; children's hair 0.058 against 0.237 mg/kg). p. 323 (the paper says only "double-blind" and does not list who was blinded): "a double-blind placebo controlled oral administration trial was conducted in children (1-9 year-old) in Mianning county, Sichuan province in 1974 and 1975 using oral administration of sodium selenite tablets ... Se tablets and placebo were delivered to the study subjects once a week by village health workers." Table 3: control group, 1974, 3,985 children, 54 new cases, 27 deaths; 1975, 5,445 children, 52 new cases, 26 deaths. Selenium group, 1974, 4,510 children, 10 new cases, 0 deaths; 1975, 6,767 children, 7 new cases, 1 death. p. 323, on why farming families were hit: "The possible interpretation was that non-farming families had access to more sources and varieties of food, in particular animal foods." pp. 323-324: "The success of the 2-year trials established the foundation for expanded non-blind large scale intervention trials using nearby villages, communes or counties in the area as natural controls." p. 324: "The study results were used as the basis for the formation of preventive and control strategies for KD by the Ministry of Health of China, including the oral administration of sodium selenite tablets and selenized salt (sodium selenite fortified salt) in KD endemic area. No significant outbreaks of KD occurred since these preventive and control measures were implemented in the late 1970s." "the diet of rural residents in China in the 1960-1970s was monotonous and mainly comprised of cereal grains and vegetables (very little animal food) produced locally." The abstract concludes "that selenium deficiency is the major cause of Keshan disease, although other etiological factors could not be ruled out." ↩
  11. Melinda A. Beck, "Rapid genomic evolution of a non-virulent coxsackievirus B3 in selenium-deficient mice", Biomedical and Environmental Sciences 10, nos. 2-3 (1997), pp. 307-315, PubMed abstract https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9315324/ (University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill). "the seasonal and annual nature of the disease suggests that an infectious co-factor is required along with a deficiency in Se. Using a murine model of coxsackievirus B3 (CVB3)-induced myocarditis, Se-deficient mice were shown to be more susceptible to the cardiopathologic effects of the virus. In addition, a normal benign strain of CVB3 becomes virulent in Se-deficient mice. This change in virulence was shown to be due to point mutations in the viral genome." ↩
  12. G. Q. Yang, S. Z. Wang, R. H. Zhou and S. Z. Sun, "Endemic selenium intoxication of humans in China", American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 37, no. 5 (1983), pp. 872-881, https://doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/37.5.872 , PubMed abstract https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6846228/ . "An endemic disease was discovered in 1961 in parts of the population of Enshi County, Hubei Province of the People's Republic of China. During the years of the highest prevalence, from 1961 to 1964, the morbidity was almost 50% in the 248 inhabitants of the five most heavily affected villages; its cause was determined to be selenium intoxication. The most common sign of the poisoning was loss of hair and nails." "Up to 1000x differences occurred when selenium contents of vegetables, cereals, scalp hair, blood, and urine from the selenosis areas were compared with those from Keshan disease (selenium deficiency) areas. The ultimate environmental source of selenium was a stony coal of very high selenium content ... Selenium from the coal entered the soil by weathering and was available for uptake by crops because of the traditional use of lime as fertilizer in that region. This particular outbreak of human selenosis was due to a drought that caused failure of the rice crop, forcing the villagers to eat more high-selenium vegetables and maize and fewer protein foods." Abstract only read. ↩
  13. L. C. Clark and colleagues for the Nutritional Prevention of Cancer Study Group, "Effects of selenium supplementation for cancer prevention in patients with carcinoma of the skin: a randomized controlled trial", JAMA 276, no. 24 (25 December 1996), pp. 1957-1963, PubMed abstract https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8971064/ (Arizona Cancer Center, University of Arizona). "A total of 1312 patients ... with a history of basal cell or squamous cell carcinomas of the skin were randomized from 1983 through 1991", at seven dermatology clinics in the eastern United States. "The primary end points for the trial were the incidences of basal and squamous cell carcinomas of the skin. The secondary end points, established in 1990, were all-cause mortality and total cancer mortality, total cancer incidence, and the incidences of lung, prostate, and colorectal cancers." "selenium treatment did not significantly affect the incidence of basal cell or squamous cell skin cancer" (377 new basal cell cancers on selenium against 350 on placebo; 218 squamous against 190). Secondary end points: "significant reductions in total cancer mortality (29 deaths in the selenium treatment group and 57 deaths in controls ...), total cancer incidence ... and incidences of lung, colorectal, and prostate cancers"; "Primarily because of the apparent reductions in total cancer mortality and total cancer incidence in the selenium group, the blinded phase of the trial was stopped early." Conclusion: "Selenium treatment did not protect against development of basal or squamous cell carcinomas of the skin. However, results from secondary end-point analyses support the hypothesis ... These effects of selenium require confirmation in an independent trial of appropriate design". Abstract only read. ↩
  14. US Food and Drug Administration, Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition, "Summary of qualified health claims subject to enforcement discretion", Selenium & Cancer, Docket No. 02P-0457, letters of 21 February and 28 April 2003, archived copy (2008) at https://webarchive.library.unt.edu/eot2008/20080916040602/http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/~dms/qhc-sum.html . Claim (1): "Selenium may reduce the risk of certain cancers. Some scientific evidence suggests that consumption of selenium may reduce the risk of certain forms of cancer. However, FDA has determined that this evidence is limited and not conclusive." Eligible foods: "Dietary supplements containing selenium". "The disclaimer (i.e., Some scientific evidence suggests...) is placed immediately adjacent to and directly beneath the claim (i.e., Selenium may reduce the risk), with no intervening material, in the same size, typeface, and contrast as the claim itself". ↩
  15. Scott M. Lippman and colleagues, "Effect of selenium and vitamin E on risk of prostate cancer and other cancers: the Selenium and Vitamin E Cancer Prevention Trial (SELECT)", JAMA 301, no. 1 (2009), pp. 39-51, https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2008.864 (the publisher refuses automated link checks), free author manuscript at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3682779/ (PMC shows a bot check; PubMed https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19066370/ ). "35,533 Men were accrued and randomly assigned at 427 participating sites in the United States, Canada and Puerto Rico between August 22, 2001, and June 24, 2004", to selenium, vitamin E, both, or placebo. "On September 15, 2008, the independent DSMC met, reviewed data from the second formal interim analysis, and recommended the discontinuation of study supplements because the alternative hypothesis of no evidence of benefit from either study agent was convincingly demonstrated". "There were nonsignificant increased risks of prostate cancer in the vitamin E arm (p=0.06 ...) and of Type 2 diabetes mellitus in the selenium arm (p=0.16; RR=1.07 ...)". "Selenium or vitamin E, alone or in combination, did not prevent prostate cancer in this population". ↩
  16. Marco Vinceti and colleagues, "Selenium for preventing cancer", Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2018, issue 1, CD005195, https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD005195.pub4 (the publisher refuses automated link checks), free at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6491296/ (PMC shows a bot check; PubMed https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29376219/ ). Authors' conclusions: "Well-designed and well-conducted RCTs have shown no beneficial effect of selenium supplements in reducing cancer risk (high certainty of evidence). Some RCTs have raised concerns by reporting a higher incidence of high-grade prostate cancer and type 2 diabetes in participants with selenium supplementation." Results: "A hypothesis generated by the Nutritional Prevention of Cancer Trial ... has not been confirmed." ↩
  17. Healthline, "7 Science-Based Health Benefits of Selenium", https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/selenium-benefits , datePublished 20 August 2019, dateModified 6 February 2023 (read 14 November 2026): "May reduce your risk of certain cancers. In addition to decreasing oxidative stress, selenium may help lower the risk of certain cancers." The heading, "May reduce your risk of certain cancers", uses nearly the same words as the FDA's 2003 claim, "Selenium may reduce the risk of certain cancers" (note 14); no source shows the site took them from the FDA. ↩