The milk of a sick cow
Devon, December 1878. A five-year-old cow has tuberculosis spread through her right lung.1
Her milk went to Alexander Wynter Blyth, the county analyst, a doctor whose job was testing food for fraud.1, 2 That winter he had a bigger question. If tuberculosis could pass to people in the milk of diseased cows, he wrote, a way of telling such milk apart would be "of the most vital importance."1
He spent the whole winter taking milk to pieces, more than a hundred samples of it. He curdled the casein with acid and a stream of carbon dioxide, which left "a yellow whey almost perfectly clear." He boiled the whey, added nitrate of mercury, and from the thick flakes that fell he drew out a colouring matter. He named it lactochrome, the colour of milk. Dried, it formed "bright red-orange resin-like masses."1, 3, 4
It would not sit still to be measured. Lactochrome "easily decomposes, and is difficult to purify," and his attempts to weigh it gave answers a hundred times apart.1
The sick cows let him down. A cow "suffering from very acute disease may give milk, differing in no essential feature from normal milk," he found. In one cow so ill after calving that her pulse could not be felt, the milk still held "much lactochrome."1
Blyth had put a name to the yellow of whey. Fifty-four years later, chemists in Heidelberg would say their new vitamin was the same thing.4
Rats that stopped growing
No famous disease led to this vitamin, the way beriberi led to vitamin B1. Young rats fed on purified food simply stopped growing.4
In 1915 Elmer McCollum and his assistant Marguerite Davis found that a little milk powder or wheat germ kept such rats growing. Whatever did it, in milk whey and in wheat germ, survived an hour of steam under pressure. McCollum soon called it water-soluble B.4
Water-soluble B turned out to be a crowd. In 1927 Harriette Chick and Margaret Roscoe argued that it held at least two vitamins, B1, which prevented beriberi, and a sturdier B2 that survived heat. The same year a British committee defined vitamin B2 as the heat-stable factor that Joseph Goldberger had just named the pellagra-preventing factor, after years spent on pellagra, a disease of the poor in the American South.4 For a while it was also called vitamin G.4, 5
Testing one food extract on the rats took three to four weeks, and the animals had to keep coming.4
Five thousand litres of milk
Heidelberg, 1933. Richard Kuhn's laboratory is working through milk by the thousand litres.6, 7
Kuhn was thirty-two and had run the chemistry side of a medical research institute on the banks of the river Neckar since 1929.6, 7 The Hungarian-born children's doctor Paul György had asked him to pull vitamin B2 out of rat liver, and the search soon spread to plants and foods from animals.6, 8
One clue made it possible. The rats' growth factor glowed yellow-green in solution, and light destroyed it. By that glow the chemists could pick it out.4 From 5,300 litres of skim milk Kuhn's team freed about a gram of a pure yellow substance, and called it lactoflavin.7 A gram of the same yellow took the dried whites of 34,000 eggs. Kuhn called it the "beautiful yellow substance."6
Then Nazi rule reached the laboratory. The young chemist Edgar Lederer had begun new ways of purifying these yellow pigments. He was a Jew with left-wing views, and in 1933 he fled to France. The new regime's police came for him four days too late.6 György was born into a Jewish family, and he moved to Cambridge in England the same year.8
Light gave the chemists their way in. Under ultraviolet light, lactoflavin lost its sugar chain and became lumiflavin, which formed crystals. From lumiflavin's structure they worked out lactoflavin's. By 1935 Kuhn's team in Heidelberg and Paul Karrer's in Zurich had each made it from scratch.4, 7, 9
The yellow enzyme
In Berlin in 1932, the biochemist Otto Warburg and Walter Christian drew a yellow enzyme out of yeast, a protein that helped burn sugar with oxygen. Its colour faded as it worked and came back with oxygen, so the yellow was doing the work.4, 10
Kuhn kept in close touch with Warburg. He saw that his lumiflavin matched a substance made from Warburg's yellow enzyme, and that the vitamin was part of it.6, 7, 10
In 1933 a young Swede, Hugo Theorell, arrived at Warburg's institute on a Rockefeller fellowship. He purified the yellow enzyme with an electrical method of his own. Then, in cold dilute acid, he pulled the yellow off the protein, which turned colourless. Neither part worked alone. Mixed back together, one to one, they did.10 Warburg called him a master of enzyme research.11
Kuhn believed for a while that he could rebuild the enzyme from lactoflavin and Theorell's protein. In Berlin they already knew he was wrong. The yellow part was lactoflavin with a phosphate attached, and the phosphate was what tied it to the protein.10
It was the first time anyone had found the working role of a vitamin.4 When Karrer shared the 1937 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, partly for vitamin B2 and its yellow relatives, the prize-giving speech compared a vitamin to a small key that opens a heavy door.12
Named for the wrong disease
By 1935 the pellagra link was in trouble. On a diet without the heat-stable factors, György's rats got a pellagra-like rash whether they were given lactoflavin or not. In Cambridge he showed with Thomas Birch and Leslie Harris, and Conrad Elvehjem's group in Wisconsin showed at the same time, that the yellow vitamin was not Goldberger's pellagra factor. Elvehjem's group went on to find the real one, the vitamin now called niacin.4, 8
In 1937 a council of the American Medical Association named the vitamin riboflavin, for its sugar part and its yellow colour. It kept the number 2 anyway.4, 13
What a lack of it does to people was shown by a doctor who had started his career under Goldberger.14 In 1938 William Sebrell of the US Public Health Service and his colleague Roy Butler put eighteen women on a diet short of riboflavin. After three to four months, ten had sores at the corners of their mouths. Niacin did nothing for them. Riboflavin healed them.4, 14, 15
In a fuller report the next year, the sores came back when the riboflavin stopped and healed again when it started.4 It looked like pellagra at the mouth, without pellagra's spreading rash, and doctors called it pellagra without pellagra.13 Riboflavin deficiency has never been known to kill.4
A prize he could not take
Kuhn was awarded the 1938 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, for his work on carotenoids and vitamins. Hitler had forbidden Germans to accept it. Kuhn received the medal and diploma in 1949, but never the money.7, 16
He never joined the Nazi Party, and party officials and the Gestapo called him politically reliable. As acting head of the whole institute from 1934, he demanded that Otto Meyerhof, a Jewish Nobel laureate who ran its physiology branch, be told to dismiss three Jewish researchers. The Kaiser Wilhelm Society ran the institute, and it refused. In 1942, as president of the German Chemical Society, he gave a speech hailing Mussolini, the Japanese emperor and Hitler.17
From 1941 he ran a secret chemical warfare laboratory for the army inside the institute, in rooms left empty after Meyerhof fled. In 1943, with his gas laboratory running, he sought the brains of "young and healthy men," most likely from people who had been executed. In the spring of 1944 Kuhn and his doctoral student Konrad Henkel made soman, a nerve gas stronger than tabun and sarin.17
That year he helped approve money for phosgene gas experiments on prisoners at the Natzweiler-Struhof concentration camp, which killed at least four Roma or Sinti. After the war he called the experiments "scientifically outstandingly profound."17 In 2005 the Society of German Chemists dropped its Richard Kuhn Medal. He had led it in the 1960s.17
Three dates and a glow
Open a 2012 scientific review of riboflavin's discovery and you meet Blyth in three different years. Its summary has him first noticing the glowing pigment in milk in 1872. Its text gives 1879, and its table of milestones gives 1897. Its source for Blyth is a vitamin maker's web page that no longer exists.4, 18
In 1872 Blyth was a club doctor in Worcester, writing up an outbreak of smallpox.2 His milk paper came out in 1879, on the work of the winter before.1
The glow has travelled further. The review says his lactochrome "glowed with a yellow-green fluorescence when exposed to light," and Wikipedia and a University of Bristol chemistry page say much the same.4, 13, 19 Blyth's own paper never mentions a glow. It describes a red-orange resin, and a solution that let most of the red and yellow light through. His 1882 handbook on food analysis never mentions one either, and adds that lactochrome gave whey its yellow colour, and butter its colour too.1, 3
The vitamin does glow. Theorell won his own Nobel Prize in 1955, for his work on enzymes like the yellow one. In his lecture he set on an ultraviolet lamp a flask of the enzyme's yellow part, so weak that it did not look yellow, and it shone.10, 11 The glow turns up in the work of the 1930s, not in Blyth's, and the trail back from Wikipedia ends at the vitamin maker's lost page.4, 10, 12, 18
Brewed by a cotton mould
Karrer's way of making the vitamin led to its manufacture, and for decades it was made by chemical synthesis.12, 20 Today it is brewed by fermentation, mainly with the bacterium Bacillus subtilis and a mould called Ashbya gossypii.20 Ashbya was first found in 1926, spoiling the fibres of growing cotton.21
It is E101 on a food label, a yellow colouring for sweets and drinks.19 What the body does not need leaves quickly in the urine, and turns it bright yellow.13
What studies of vitamin B2 in people have found on thinking, mood, sleep and energy is in the Research tab.22
That winter in Devon, Blyth could not tell a sick cow's milk from a healthy one. He found its colour instead, and now a cotton mould brews it by the tank.