NR-034Ingredient Atlas entry · Vitamin

Vitamin B2

Riboflavin, a B vitamin

A sick cow's milk in Devon, five thousand litres of skim milk in Heidelberg, a yellow enzyme taken apart in Berlin and eighteen women on a thin diet in America. The yellow of whey had a name for fifty years before anyone knew it was a vitamin. It was tied to the wrong disease, it turned out to work inside an enzyme, and the chemist who first purified it made a nerve gas. The yellow-green glow that histories give the man who named it is missing from his own paper.

  • Found in: milk, eggs and mushrooms
  • Doses from under 1 mg to 400 mg a day
  • Few studies give it on its own
A whole button mushroom
A whole button mushroom. Photo by 0x010C, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The milk of a sick cow

Devon, December 1878. A five-year-old cow has tuberculosis spread through her right lung.1

Her milk went to Alexander Wynter Blyth, the county analyst, a doctor whose job was testing food for fraud.1, 2 That winter he had a bigger question. If tuberculosis could pass to people in the milk of diseased cows, he wrote, a way of telling such milk apart would be "of the most vital importance."1

He spent the whole winter taking milk to pieces, more than a hundred samples of it. He curdled the casein with acid and a stream of carbon dioxide, which left "a yellow whey almost perfectly clear." He boiled the whey, added nitrate of mercury, and from the thick flakes that fell he drew out a colouring matter. He named it lactochrome, the colour of milk. Dried, it formed "bright red-orange resin-like masses."1, 3, 4

It would not sit still to be measured. Lactochrome "easily decomposes, and is difficult to purify," and his attempts to weigh it gave answers a hundred times apart.1

The sick cows let him down. A cow "suffering from very acute disease may give milk, differing in no essential feature from normal milk," he found. In one cow so ill after calving that her pulse could not be felt, the milk still held "much lactochrome."1

Blyth had put a name to the yellow of whey. Fifty-four years later, chemists in Heidelberg would say their new vitamin was the same thing.4

Rats that stopped growing

No famous disease led to this vitamin, the way beriberi led to vitamin B1. Young rats fed on purified food simply stopped growing.4

In 1915 Elmer McCollum and his assistant Marguerite Davis found that a little milk powder or wheat germ kept such rats growing. Whatever did it, in milk whey and in wheat germ, survived an hour of steam under pressure. McCollum soon called it water-soluble B.4

Water-soluble B turned out to be a crowd. In 1927 Harriette Chick and Margaret Roscoe argued that it held at least two vitamins, B1, which prevented beriberi, and a sturdier B2 that survived heat. The same year a British committee defined vitamin B2 as the heat-stable factor that Joseph Goldberger had just named the pellagra-preventing factor, after years spent on pellagra, a disease of the poor in the American South.4 For a while it was also called vitamin G.4, 5

Testing one food extract on the rats took three to four weeks, and the animals had to keep coming.4

Five thousand litres of milk

Heidelberg, 1933. Richard Kuhn's laboratory is working through milk by the thousand litres.6, 7

Kuhn was thirty-two and had run the chemistry side of a medical research institute on the banks of the river Neckar since 1929.6, 7 The Hungarian-born children's doctor Paul György had asked him to pull vitamin B2 out of rat liver, and the search soon spread to plants and foods from animals.6, 8

One clue made it possible. The rats' growth factor glowed yellow-green in solution, and light destroyed it. By that glow the chemists could pick it out.4 From 5,300 litres of skim milk Kuhn's team freed about a gram of a pure yellow substance, and called it lactoflavin.7 A gram of the same yellow took the dried whites of 34,000 eggs. Kuhn called it the "beautiful yellow substance."6

Then Nazi rule reached the laboratory. The young chemist Edgar Lederer had begun new ways of purifying these yellow pigments. He was a Jew with left-wing views, and in 1933 he fled to France. The new regime's police came for him four days too late.6 György was born into a Jewish family, and he moved to Cambridge in England the same year.8

Light gave the chemists their way in. Under ultraviolet light, lactoflavin lost its sugar chain and became lumiflavin, which formed crystals. From lumiflavin's structure they worked out lactoflavin's. By 1935 Kuhn's team in Heidelberg and Paul Karrer's in Zurich had each made it from scratch.4, 7, 9

The yellow enzyme

In Berlin in 1932, the biochemist Otto Warburg and Walter Christian drew a yellow enzyme out of yeast, a protein that helped burn sugar with oxygen. Its colour faded as it worked and came back with oxygen, so the yellow was doing the work.4, 10

Kuhn kept in close touch with Warburg. He saw that his lumiflavin matched a substance made from Warburg's yellow enzyme, and that the vitamin was part of it.6, 7, 10

In 1933 a young Swede, Hugo Theorell, arrived at Warburg's institute on a Rockefeller fellowship. He purified the yellow enzyme with an electrical method of his own. Then, in cold dilute acid, he pulled the yellow off the protein, which turned colourless. Neither part worked alone. Mixed back together, one to one, they did.10 Warburg called him a master of enzyme research.11

Kuhn believed for a while that he could rebuild the enzyme from lactoflavin and Theorell's protein. In Berlin they already knew he was wrong. The yellow part was lactoflavin with a phosphate attached, and the phosphate was what tied it to the protein.10

It was the first time anyone had found the working role of a vitamin.4 When Karrer shared the 1937 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, partly for vitamin B2 and its yellow relatives, the prize-giving speech compared a vitamin to a small key that opens a heavy door.12

Named for the wrong disease

By 1935 the pellagra link was in trouble. On a diet without the heat-stable factors, György's rats got a pellagra-like rash whether they were given lactoflavin or not. In Cambridge he showed with Thomas Birch and Leslie Harris, and Conrad Elvehjem's group in Wisconsin showed at the same time, that the yellow vitamin was not Goldberger's pellagra factor. Elvehjem's group went on to find the real one, the vitamin now called niacin.4, 8

In 1937 a council of the American Medical Association named the vitamin riboflavin, for its sugar part and its yellow colour. It kept the number 2 anyway.4, 13

What a lack of it does to people was shown by a doctor who had started his career under Goldberger.14 In 1938 William Sebrell of the US Public Health Service and his colleague Roy Butler put eighteen women on a diet short of riboflavin. After three to four months, ten had sores at the corners of their mouths. Niacin did nothing for them. Riboflavin healed them.4, 14, 15

In a fuller report the next year, the sores came back when the riboflavin stopped and healed again when it started.4 It looked like pellagra at the mouth, without pellagra's spreading rash, and doctors called it pellagra without pellagra.13 Riboflavin deficiency has never been known to kill.4

A prize he could not take

Kuhn was awarded the 1938 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, for his work on carotenoids and vitamins. Hitler had forbidden Germans to accept it. Kuhn received the medal and diploma in 1949, but never the money.7, 16

He never joined the Nazi Party, and party officials and the Gestapo called him politically reliable. As acting head of the whole institute from 1934, he demanded that Otto Meyerhof, a Jewish Nobel laureate who ran its physiology branch, be told to dismiss three Jewish researchers. The Kaiser Wilhelm Society ran the institute, and it refused. In 1942, as president of the German Chemical Society, he gave a speech hailing Mussolini, the Japanese emperor and Hitler.17

From 1941 he ran a secret chemical warfare laboratory for the army inside the institute, in rooms left empty after Meyerhof fled. In 1943, with his gas laboratory running, he sought the brains of "young and healthy men," most likely from people who had been executed. In the spring of 1944 Kuhn and his doctoral student Konrad Henkel made soman, a nerve gas stronger than tabun and sarin.17

That year he helped approve money for phosgene gas experiments on prisoners at the Natzweiler-Struhof concentration camp, which killed at least four Roma or Sinti. After the war he called the experiments "scientifically outstandingly profound."17 In 2005 the Society of German Chemists dropped its Richard Kuhn Medal. He had led it in the 1960s.17

Three dates and a glow

Open a 2012 scientific review of riboflavin's discovery and you meet Blyth in three different years. Its summary has him first noticing the glowing pigment in milk in 1872. Its text gives 1879, and its table of milestones gives 1897. Its source for Blyth is a vitamin maker's web page that no longer exists.4, 18

In 1872 Blyth was a club doctor in Worcester, writing up an outbreak of smallpox.2 His milk paper came out in 1879, on the work of the winter before.1

The glow has travelled further. The review says his lactochrome "glowed with a yellow-green fluorescence when exposed to light," and Wikipedia and a University of Bristol chemistry page say much the same.4, 13, 19 Blyth's own paper never mentions a glow. It describes a red-orange resin, and a solution that let most of the red and yellow light through. His 1882 handbook on food analysis never mentions one either, and adds that lactochrome gave whey its yellow colour, and butter its colour too.1, 3

The vitamin does glow. Theorell won his own Nobel Prize in 1955, for his work on enzymes like the yellow one. In his lecture he set on an ultraviolet lamp a flask of the enzyme's yellow part, so weak that it did not look yellow, and it shone.10, 11 The glow turns up in the work of the 1930s, not in Blyth's, and the trail back from Wikipedia ends at the vitamin maker's lost page.4, 10, 12, 18

Brewed by a cotton mould

Karrer's way of making the vitamin led to its manufacture, and for decades it was made by chemical synthesis.12, 20 Today it is brewed by fermentation, mainly with the bacterium Bacillus subtilis and a mould called Ashbya gossypii.20 Ashbya was first found in 1926, spoiling the fibres of growing cotton.21

It is E101 on a food label, a yellow colouring for sweets and drinks.19 What the body does not need leaves quickly in the urine, and turns it bright yellow.13

What studies of vitamin B2 in people have found on thinking, mood, sleep and energy is in the Research tab.22

That winter in Devon, Blyth could not tell a sick cow's milk from a healthy one. He found its colour instead, and now a cotton mould brews it by the tank.

See what modern trials found

Myths and facts

In the record, or legend?

Every story you will read about this vitamin, checked against the oldest source we could find.

  • Blyth named the yellow colouring matter of whey lactochrome

    In the record

    His own paper of 1879, on work from the winter of 1878 to 18791

  • Blyth found riboflavin in milk in 1872

    Wrong date

    His milk paper is from 1879. In 1872 he was a club doctor in Worcester. A 2012 review gives 1872, 1879 and 1897 in different places1, 2, 4

  • Blyth's lactochrome glowed yellow-green

    Told, not shown

    His 1879 paper and his 1882 book describe a red-orange resin and never mention a glow. The trail ends at a vitamin maker's web page that now returns "page not found"1, 3, 4, 18

  • A gram of the vitamin took more than 5,000 litres of milk

    In the record

    The 1938 Nobel presentation speech gives about a gram from 5,300 litres of skim milk. One 2012 review says 15,0004, 6, 7

  • Vitamin B2 was the pellagra-preventing factor

    Partly

    So defined by a British committee in 1927, when "vitamin B2" meant the whole heat-stable part of vitamin B, and that part did hold the pellagra factor. The yellow vitamin was not it. György's group and Elvehjem's showed that in 1935, and the factor proved to be nicotinic acid, now niacin4

  • Kuhn's team was the first to isolate it

    In the record

    The Nobel Prize's history of his institute and the 1938 presentation speech. The 2012 review's table credits Kuhn's 1933 work with matching it to Blyth's lactochrome (we did not see the 1933 papers)4, 6, 7

In the record means a source from the time, or a scholar quoting one, says it. Likely means a named expert's reasoned identification. Told, not shown means one interested party says it and nothing checks it. Partly means a real event sits under a bigger story. Legend means the earliest source is far too late or missing. Wrong date means the event is real but the popular date doesn't match the record.

Notes

Every fact in the story points to one of these. Where a translation is ours, the note says so.

Show all 22 notes Hide the notes
  1. A. Wynter Blyth, "The composition of cows' milk in health and disease", Journal of the Chemical Society, Transactions 35 (1879): 530-538, https://archive.org/details/sim_journal-of-the-chemical-society-transactions_1879_35 . P. 530: "a research on the constituents of milk, which has occupied the author during the whole of the past winter"; p. 531, among its aims, "to see if it were possible by the determination of every constituent to distinguish whether the source of a given sample of milk was healthy or the reverse". P. 531: the casein is "precipitated in a flocculent condition by the cautious addition of acetic acid, and to complete this precipitation carbonic anhydride is passed through the liquid", "leaving a yellow whey almost perfectly clear"; "The yellow whey is now boiled to get rid of the albumin"; to it "a slight excess of the ordinary solution of nitrate of mercury used for urea estimation is added, and a dense flocculent precipitate falls". P. 532: the mercury precipitate is "a mixture of galactin, lactochrome, any trace of albumin ... and similarly any trace of urea"; after the galactin is removed, "an alkaloidal colouring matter, for which I propose the name of 'lactochrome,' may be separated by the addition of nitrate of mercury solution". Pp. 532-533: "Lactochrome itself ... is in the form of bright red-orange resin-like masses, softening at 100° C., very soluble in hot alcohol ... it is freely soluble in water. Concentrated solutions give a simple spectrum, allowing most of the red and yellow rays to pass through. No bands were discovered"; "The amount of lactochrome has not been estimated in any satisfactory manner, for it easily decomposes, and is difficult to purify"; estimates "have varied from 0·1 to 0·001 per cent. in milks differing in no essential feature". P. 534: "from more than 100 milks examined during the last winter". Pp. 535-536: "If the idea should be in part or wholly true, that consumption and similar maladies may be transmitted to man by the ingestion of milk from diseased cows, some method, whether physical or chemical, of distinguishing such milks, becomes of the most vital importance"; the analyses "rather appear to show that a cow even suffering from very acute disease may give milk, differing in no essential feature from normal milk, while, on the other hand, trivial and severe local affections of the udder, characterised by bloody or purulent discharges, are easily to be recognised". P. 536: "A Cow suffering from Parturient Apoplexy; Pulse Imperceptible ... Third day after Calving ... there was much lactochrome." P. 537: "Phthisis—A Cow five years old with Extensive Tubercular Deposit in Right Lung. The Dam was also Scrofulous", analysed on "Dec. 7, 1878" and in "Feb., 1879". The paper does not say where the cows were. Blyth lived and worked in Devon that winter, as county analyst (note 2); "a healthy Devon cow" (p. 534, beside "a Guernsey cow", p. 535) and the 1882 book's "Devonshire cows" (note 3) may name the breed rather than the place. The source's word for the lung is "Extensive Tubercular Deposit". The paper never mentions fluorescence or a glow (we searched the whole volume's text for "fluoresc"). Page numbers are from the volume's running heads. ↩
  2. P. Selley, "Alexander Wynter Blyth", Medical Gentlemen (a site on the doctors of nineteenth-century Devon), https://medicalgentlemen.co.uk/blyth : he qualified at King's College Hospital, London, in 1870, "then worked in general practice as the surgeon to the Worcester Amalgamated Friendly Societies. This was a club, members paying four shillings annually for their health care. In his report of 1872 he reported a local outbreak of smallpox affecting 32 patients, five of whom died"; Medical Officer of Health for four rural sanitary authorities (Bideford, South Molton, Dulverton and Okehampton) from 1873, and "The following year was also appointed C[ounty Analyst]"; "He was retained as Devon County Analyst" after moving to Marylebone at the end of 1879; "He was first to isolate 'Lactochrome' now known as Riboflavine or vitamin B2, in 1879." Wikipedia, "Alexander Wynter Blyth", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Wynter_Blyth : in 1874 he "became County Analyst for Devon" and lived in Barnstaple; his duties included "the analysis of food and drugs for adulteration". ↩
  3. A. Wynter Blyth, Foods: Their Composition and Analysis (London: Charles Griffin, 1882), pp. 211-212, https://archive.org/details/b21507120 : "In 1879, the author studied this body and decomposed it, and came to the conclusion that lacto-proteine, as a single definite substance, had no existence; but that the mercury precipitate was composed of two substances ... to which the names of galactine and lactochrome respectively were ascribed"; lactochrome "is in the form of bright red, orange, resin-like masses, softening at 100°, freely soluble in water"; "There appears little doubt that lactochrome is the cause of the yellow colour of milk whey, and also the colouring-matter of butter." Section 118: in 1864 E. Millon and Commaille "obtained a precipitate from the yellow whey by means of a solution of mercury nitrate", the precipitate in which Blyth found and named lactochrome in 1879. Section 119: "Two bitter principles ... were separated from the milk of Devonshire cows by the author in 1879." The book's text never uses "lactochrome" with "fluorescence"; it uses the word only for other substances (we searched the whole text). ↩
  4. C. A. Northrop-Clewes and D. I. Thurnham, "The discovery and characterization of riboflavin", Annals of Nutrition and Metabolism 61 (2012): 224-230, https://doi.org/10.1159/000343111 (the publisher's page blocks bots; abstract free on PubMed, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23183293/ ; an author's copy is posted at https://www.chm.bris.ac.uk/motm/vitaminB2/AnnNutrMetab2012riboflavin.pdf ). Abstract, p. 224: "The first observation of a pigment in milk with yellow-green fluorescence can be traced to the English chemist Alexander Wynter Blyth in 1872". P. 225: "In 1879, Alexander Wynter Blyth ... is credited as being the first person to isolate a water-soluble material from cow milk whey that glowed with a yellow-green fluorescence when exposed to light and gave it the name lactochrome [3], 'lacto' from the milk and 'chrome' meaning color"; its reference 3 is "DSM Nutritional Products: Vitamin basics; vitamin B2 history ... (accessed September 10, 2012)". Table 1, p. 226: "1897 Blyth Isolation of lactochrome, a water-soluble, yellow fluorescent material from milk whey"; "1933 Kuhn Isolation of lactoflavin from milk. Lactoflavin was the growth component in B-2 factor and had the same characteristics as the factor isolated by Blyth"; "1934–35 Kuhn and Karrer Independently described the structure of riboflavin". Introduction, p. 224: "deficiency has never been fatal". P. 225: "No nutritional deficiency disease like beriberi, pellagra or xerophthalmia led to the research and discovery of riboflavin"; "it was the impairment of growth when animals were placed on semi-synthetic diets that initiated the research"; "McCollum and assistant Marguerite Davis (1887–1967) [6] produced three papers in 1915 which showed a diet containing 2% of wheat embryo or milk powder with polished rice, casein, salts, and butter fat provided enough of an 'essential accessory' to support growth of young rats"; "the water-soluble accessory factor in milk whey and wheat embryo could be heated by autoclave at 15 pounds pressure for 1 h without loss of activity"; "By 1916, McCollum and his graduate student Cornelia Kennedy thought that there were two accessory factors in the diet: water-soluble B ... and fat-soluble A". Pp. 225-226: Goldberger "was put in charge of investigating the cause of pellagra in the southern states of the USA" and "noted ... the poverty and monotony of the diets consumed by sufferers" (p. 226); "In 1927, the British Committee on Accessory Food Factors defined vitamin B2 as 'the more heat-stable, water soluble dietary factor recently described and named pellagra-preventive (P-P) factor by Goldberger and colleagues in 1926'"; Harriette Chick (1875-1977) and Margaret Honora Roscoe "suggested that the water-soluble B ... was not one substance but at least two: (1) an anti-neuritic (anti-beriberi) vitamin B1 and (2) vitamin B2". P. 227: "To test each extract from each of these foods for growth-promoting activity required a period of 3–4 weeks and a constant supply of prepared animals"; the reference list (p. 230) includes A. Bourquin and H. C. Sherman, "Quantitative determination of vitamin G (B2)" (1931). P. 227: "an early observation established that one of the active growth-promoting components (riboflavin) in the growth experiments had a yellow-green fluorescence which was visible in near-neutral solution and was destroyed by exposure to visible light for 6–24 h. Using these characteristics, they were able to identify lactoflavin" (this passage cites György's 1954 retrospect, "Early experiences with riboflavin"; we did not read the 1930s papers themselves). P. 227: György "found that the appearance of the pellagra-like dermatitis reported by Goldberger could be reproducibly obtained by a B2-deficient diet whether or not lactoflavin was present"; "working with Birch and Leslie Julius Harris ... György and colleagues were able to show independent of and simultaneously with Conrad Elvehjem's ... group in Wisconsin that riboflavin was different from the specific pellagra-preventing factor of Goldberger and colleagues. Elvehjem's group went on to identify nicotinic acid (niacin) as the pellagra-preventing component" (reference 15, Birch, György and Harris, 1935); pp. 226-227 give Birch's full name, Thomas William Birch. P. 228: "The first isolation of the colored component was from milk in 1933 [19], and it was termed lactoflavin and corresponded to the lactochrome of Blyth" (reference 19 is Kuhn, György and Wagner-Jauregg, 1933, which we did not see; Table 1 credits the link to Kuhn in 1933); "a breakdown product of lactoflavin, lumiflavin, in which the ribose residue was removed by irradiation with ultraviolet light, which they were able to crystallize. After determining the structure of lumiflavin, they were able to extrapolate enough information to synthesize lactoflavin"; "the name riboflavin was proposed and adopted in 1937 by the Council of Pharmacy and Chemistry of the American Medical Association"; "riboflavin still retains the name vitamin B2 as it was the first vitamin isolated from the B-2 complex"; the review gives the milk for a gram as "15,000 liters of milk or the dried albumin from 34,000 eggs", citing the Nobel Prize site (note 6, which now says over 5,000). Pp. 228-229: "In 1932, Otto Heinrich Warburg (1883–1970) and Walter Christian extracted a yellow enzyme ('Gelbes Ferment') from brewer's yeast", which "enabled them to link the oxidation of glucose-6-phosphate (G6P) to molecular oxygen". P. 229: the "old yellow enzyme provided the first biochemical role for a vitamin"; in Sebrell and Butler's 1939 report, the lesions "disappeared following daily administration of synthetic riboflavin, reappeared on discontinuation of the riboflavin, and disappeared again on reinstitution of the riboflavin treatment" (13 of 18 women in that report), by "William Henry Sebrell (1901–1992) and Roy Edwin Butler (1902–1974)". The review gives Julius Wagner-Jauregg (1857-1940) as Kuhn and György's partner; the Nobel Prize site and the 1933 paper's author list give Theodor Wagner-Jauregg. ↩
  5. Wikipedia, "Riboflavin", History: "Circa 1937, riboflavin was also referred to as 'Vitamin G'", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riboflavin . In 1931 Bourquin and Sherman's title still used "vitamin G (B2)" for the whole heat-stable factor (note 4). ↩
  6. Nobel Prize Outreach, "Richard Kuhn and the Chemical Institute: Double bonds and biological mechanisms", https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/themes/richard-kuhn-and-the-chemical-institute-double-bonds-and-biological-mechanisms : "On October 1, 1929, Richard Kuhn became first of the four KWImF research directors to move into the new laboratory on the banks of the Neckar River"; "In 1933, he began a collaboration with the physician Paul György on the B family of vitamins. They were the first to isolate and purify vitamin B2 (riboflavin)"; "György initially asked Kuhn to isolate vitamin B2 from the livers of rats upon which he had been experimenting, but they quickly expanded their efforts, purifying flavin pigments from plants and animal materials. Extraction with traditional solvents proved ineffective and Lederer began to develop new chromatographic techniques to purify the materials"; "purification of one gram of the 'beautiful yellow substance', as Kuhn called it, required over 5,000 liters of milk or the dried albumin from 34,000 eggs"; "As a Jew with leftist political views, Lederer was forced to flee to France in March of 1933. Fortunately, the Gestapo was four days too late when they came to arrest him at the KWImF. At this juncture, Theodor Wagner-Jauregg took over as the key figure in the collaboration with György". The Gestapo was founded in Prussia on 26 April 1933 (Wikipedia, "Gestapo", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gestapo ), so either the month or the name of the police in this account is loose; Wikipedia, "Edgar Lederer", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edgar_Lederer , says only that "In 1933" he "escaped to Paris"; Kuhn "called it both lactoflavin and ovoflavin because they had first abstracted it from milk and egg whites"; "Kuhn, who had remained in close contact with Warburg since coming to Heidelberg, quickly realized that his lumiflavin was probably the same substance as Warburg's oxidation enzyme and proposed that vitamin B2 is its precursor". Kuhn was born on 3 December 1900 (note 7, biography). ↩
  7. Nobel Prize in Chemistry 1938, presentation speech, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/chemistry/1938/ceremony-speech/ : "From 5,300 litres skim milk Kuhn and his collaborators succeeded in liberating about 1g of a pure yellow substance, Lactoflavin"; "A breakdown product of the Lactoflavin, which was called Lumiflavin, could be identified with a substance previously prepared from the yellow ferment occurring in yeast. By drawing up a structural formula for Lumiflavin ... Kuhn furnished a key to the chemical clarification of Lactoflavin"; the footnote: "Owing to political conditions at the time, Professor Kuhn was prevented from accepting the prize. In 1949 he received the gold medal and the diploma." The speech names "von Szent-Györgyi and Wagner-Jauregg" as Kuhn's partners, where the papers name Paul György. Kuhn's biography on the same site, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/chemistry/1938/kuhn/biographical/ , gives his birth in Vienna on 3 December 1900 and his post as head of the chemistry institute of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Medical Research in Heidelberg from 1929; the prize facts page, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/chemistry/1938/kuhn/facts/ , gives the motivation "for his work on carotenoids and vitamins". ↩
  8. Wikipedia, "Paul György", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Gyorgy : born in Nagyvárad, Hungary, "to a Jewish family"; a "biochemist, nutritionist, and pediatrician"; at Heidelberg from 1920 "until 1933, when the political unrest in Germany spurred his move to the Nutrition Laboratory at the University of Cambridge in England". ↩
  9. Wikipedia, "Riboflavin", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riboflavin : "The first total synthesis of riboflavin was carried out by Richard Kuhn's group", citing R. Kuhn, K. Reinemund, F. Weygand and R. Ströbele, "Über die Synthese des Lactoflavins (Vitamin B2)", Berichte der deutschen chemischen Gesellschaft 68 (1935): 1765-1774 (not seen); its History section dates Kuhn's synthesis to 1934. The 2012 review's Table 1 has "1934–35 Kuhn and Karrer Independently described the structure of riboflavin" (note 4). P. Karrer, K. Schöpp, F. Benz and K. Pfaehler, "Synthesen von Flavinen III", Helvetica Chimica Acta 18 (1935): 69-79, as listed in note 4 (not seen). Dean Burk's original article on Kuhn in the Dictionary of Scientific Biography, on the same Encyclopedia.com page as note 17, says he "synthesized and structurally identified the vitamin". ↩
  10. H. Theorell, "The nature and mode of action of oxidation enzymes", Nobel Lecture, 12 December 1955, pp. 482-485, https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/theorell-lecture.pdf : "When in 1933 I went on a Rockefeller fellowship to Otto Warburg's institute in Berlin, Warburg and Christian had in the previous year produced a yellow-coloured preparation of an oxidation enzyme from yeast"; "The yellow colour ... faded away on reduction and returned on oxidation with e.g. oxygen, so that it was evident that the yellow pigment had to do with the actual enzymatic process"; "I decided to try to purify the yellow enzyme, using for the purpose electrophoretic methods worked out by myself"; "With dialysis against diluted hydrochloric acid at low temperature the yellow pigment was separated from the protein, which then became colourless. In the enzyme test the flavin part and the protein separately were inactive, but if the flavin part and the protein were mixed at approximately neutral reaction the enzyme effect returned, and the original effect came back when one mixed them in the molecular proportions 1 : 1"; "For a while Richard Kuhn believed he was able to resynthesize the yellow ferment by bringing together lactoflavin and my colourless protein component; when his work was published, however, we were already aware in Berlin that his assumption was not correct"; the natural pigment "proved to be a lactoflavin phosphoric acid ester ... and it was obvious that the phosphoric acid served to link the pigment part to the protein". In the lecture's second demonstration, "A flask containing FMN-solution so diluted that its yellow colour is not descernible to the eye is placed on a lamp giving long-wave ultraviolet light. The solution gives a strong, yellow fluorescence". FMN is riboflavin's phosphate, the yellow part of the enzyme. On his work of 1934, p. 483: the yellow pigment's "strong yellow fluorescence disappeared with linking to the protein". Kuhn and Hermann Rudy later joined the phosphate form, FMN, to the protein of Warburg's enzyme and made "the very first partial synthesis of a fully functional enzyme" (note 4, p. 229). ↩
  11. Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1955, presentation speech, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1955/ceremony-speech/ : Theorell's first discovery came in 1933-1935, "as a Fellow of the Rockefeller Foundation", with Otto Warburg; his biography on the same site, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1955/theorell/biographical/ : "For his work on the nature and effects of oxidation enzymes he was awarded the Nobel Prize for Physiology or Medicine for 1955"; "He now made his great classical discovery of the splitting and recombination of the yellow enzyme. «Meister der Enzymforschung», Warburg called him after this scientific achievement." ↩
  12. Nobel Prize in Chemistry 1937, presentation speech, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/chemistry/1937/ceremony-speech/ : one half of the prize to Paul Karrer "in recognition of his researches concerning carotenoids and flavins, and the vitamins A and B2", the other half to Norman Haworth; "Karrer's method of producing this compound has led to a technical production of the substance"; "We may perhaps compare the very effect of the vitamin to that of a key. A heavy door may thus resist the strongest blows and knocks, but can easily be opened by the aid of a small key – always provided that the right key is found." The same speech: "Flavins are natural substances of a light yellow colour which often glisten, or fluoresce to the green." ↩
  13. Wikipedia, "Riboflavin", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riboflavin . The name comes from ribose and flavin, "from Latin flavus, 'yellow'"; riboflavin deficiency "causes stomatitis symptoms similar to those seen in pellagra, but without the widespread peripheral skin lesions", so it was "sometimes called 'pellagra sine pellagra' (pellagra without pellagra)", citing W. H. Sebrell and R. E. Butler, "Riboflavin deficiency in man (ariboflavinosis)", Public Health Reports 54 (1939): 2121-2131; on the review: "In 1879, Blyth isolated a water-soluble component of cows' milk whey, which he named 'lactochrome', that fluoresced yellow-green when exposed to light"; riboflavin "consumed in excess of nutritional requirements is not stored; it is either not absorbed or is absorbed and quickly excreted in urine, causing the urine to have a bright yellow tint". ↩
  14. Wikipedia, "William H. Sebrell Jr.", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_H._Sebrell_Jr%2E : he "joined the Public Health Service (PHS) in 1926"; "He began his research career under Dr. Joseph Goldberger"; he "first recognized and described the dietary deficiency disease, ariboflavinosis"; director of the National Institutes of Health from 1950. ↩
  15. S. Gower Smith and D. W. Martin, "Cheilosis successfully treated with synthetic vitamin B6", Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine 43 (1940): 660-663, https://doi.org/10.3181/00379727-43-11295 : "Sebrell and Butler produced these lesions in 10 out of 18 women subsisting on a riboflavin-deficient diet. The lesions developed in a period of 94 to 130 days. They failed to respond to nicotinic acid but responded to riboflavin", and on p. 660 defines the lesions as "stomatitis (sores in the corners of the mouth, perleche, cheilosis)"; it cites W. H. Sebrell and R. E. Butler, "Riboflavin deficiency in man: a preliminary note", Public Health Reports 53 (1938): 2282-2284. Smith and Martin's own paper is about vitamin B6; we cite it for its account of Sebrell and Butler, whose 1938 note it prints as page "2882" (the journal page is 2282). We could not read Sebrell and Butler's own reports: theirs was a US Public Health Service study, but which state or institution, and how the women were chosen, is not known to us. ↩
  16. Nobel Prize facts, "Forced to decline the Nobel Prize", https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/facts/nobel-prize-facts/ : "Adolf Hitler forbade three German Nobel Prize laureates, Richard Kuhn, Adolf Butenandt and Gerhard Domagk, from accepting the Nobel Prize. All of them could later receive the Nobel Prize diploma and medal, but not the prize amount." The facts page for Kuhn says he "received his Nobel Prize one year later, in 1939" (note 7). ↩
  17. F. Schmaltz, "Kuhn, Richard", Complete Dictionary of Scientific Biography (Gale, 2008), on Encyclopedia.com, https://www.encyclopedia.com/people/science-and-technology/chemistry-biographies/richard-kuhn : "Kuhn became provisional head of all four institutes in March 1934"; "Even though Meyerhof himself faced persecution as a Jew, Kuhn, as provisional director, in a letter to the general administration of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society (KWS), demanded that Meyerhof should be instructed to dismiss three Jewish researchers working at the institute. Kuhn's demand was rejected by the general administration of the KWS"; "Kuhn never joined the Nazi Party. However, party officials and the Gestapo described him as politically reliable and loyal to the regime"; "In March 1938 Kuhn was appointed president of the DChG [German Chemical Society], a post he held until 1945. In a speech as president of the DChG in 1942, Kuhn praised the 'fighting front' of the nations that had joined the Anti-Komintern powers, hailing Mussolini, the Japanese emperor, and Hitler"; a "secret laboratory for chemical warfare research at the KWI for Medical Research ... led by Kuhn, was set up ... in January 1941 as an outpost of the gas defense department of the Army Ordnance Office", in "rooms at the Institute of Physiology, which were available as a result of the displacement of Otto Meyerhof, who had fled Germany in September 1938"; "In the spring of 1944 Kuhn and his PhD candidate Konrad Henkel synthesized Soman, which proved to be stronger than Tabun and Sarin"; "In the spring of 1943 Kuhn asked the secretary-general of the KWS, Ernst Telschow, to support his search for the brains of 'young and healthy men,' presumably for nerve gas research. The sources indicate that these brains were most likely taken from execution victims. If and to what extent cerebrums were indeed delivered ... has not yet been established with certainty"; Kuhn and Karl Brandt "authorized the use of funds from the Reich Research Council for the phosgene experiments on prisoners, carried out by the physician Otto Bickenbach, in the gas chamber of the concentration camp Natzweiler-Struhof in 1944 ... His experiments had caused at least four Roma or Sinti (Gypsies) to suffocate painfully. Kuhn justified the experiments as 'scientifically outstandingly profound'" (Kuhn to Eber, 5 August 1947); in 2005 (the board's statement was printed in May 2006) the Society of German Chemists (GDCh) "declared their intention to no longer award the Richard Kuhn Medal", named for the "Nobel Prize laureate of the year 1938 and President of the GDCh in 1964–65"; the society he led from 1938 to 1945 was the German Chemical Society (Deutsche Chemische Gesellschaft, DChG), not the GDCh. Dean Burk's earlier article on the same page, from the original Dictionary of Scientific Biography, says Kuhn "showed vitamin B2, isolated and crystallized from milk and named lactoflavin, to be part of Warburg's 'yellow enzyme' and he synthesized and structurally identified the vitamin". Otto Meyerhof was director of the institute's physiology branch and a Nobel laureate (Schmaltz's entry). ↩
  18. The review's source for Blyth (note 4, reference 3) is DSM Nutritional Products, "Vitamin basics; vitamin B2 history", http://www.vitamin-basics.com/index.php?id=55 , accessed by the authors in 2012. The address now returns a "page not found" error (checked 16 November 2026), and DSM's later vitamin history page, https://www.dsm.com/markets/anh/en_US/Compendium/vitamin_basics.html (cited by the Bristol page, note 19), now redirects to the company's home page (checked 16 November 2026). An archived copy exists in the Wayback Machine (capture of 21 May 2012), but we could not open it. ↩
  19. P. May, "Vitamin B2 (Riboflavin): more than just a food colouring", Molecule of the Month, University of Bristol School of Chemistry, February 2018, https://www.chm.bris.ac.uk/motm/vitaminB2/vitaminb2h.htm : "In 1879, an English chemist by the name of Alexander Wynter Blyth ... isolated a water-soluble material from cow-milk whey that glowed yellowy-green when exposed to light. He called it lactochrome"; its sources include the 2012 review and DSM's vitamin history page; riboflavin is used "as a colouring additive due to its bright yellow-orange colour, and has been given the European E-number E101", seen "in the ingredients list of drinks and sweets". ↩
  20. J. L. Revuelta, R. Ledesma-Amaro, P. Lozano-Martinez, D. Díaz-Fernández, R. M. Buey and A. Jiménez, "Bioproduction of riboflavin: a bright yellow history", Journal of Industrial Microbiology and Biotechnology 44 (2017): 659-665, abstract, https://doi.org/10.1007/s10295-016-1842-7 (free abstract on PubMed, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27696023/ ; the publisher's page blocks bots): "Riboflavin was produced industrially by chemical synthesis for many decades. At present, the development of economical and eco-efficient fermentation processes, which are mainly based on Bacillus subtilis and Ashbya gossypii strains, has replaced the synthetic process at industrial scale." ↩
  21. Wikipedia, "Eremothecium gossypii" (also called Ashbya gossypii), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eremothecium_gossypii : "It was originally isolated from cotton as a pathogen causing stigmatomycosis by Ashby and Nowell in 1926. This disease affects the development of hair cells in cotton bolls"; S. F. Ashby and W. Nowell, "The fungi of stigmatomycosis", Annals of Botany 40 (1926): 69-84. ↩
  22. Nooroots Ingredient Atlas, vitamin B2, Research tab, /pages/vitamin-b2-research : the page "covers only studies in people that measured thinking, memory, mood, stress, sleep, energy, tiredness or quality of life, not all research on vitamin B2". ↩