A pill of flour
Columbia, South Carolina, 28 April 1916. Joseph Goldberger swallows a pill of wheat flour.1
Worked into the dough were skin scrapings from the sores of two patients at the state asylum, a little of their urine and the liquid stool of a third. All three had pellagra, a disease that doctors summed up as dermatitis, diarrhoea, dementia and death. Half an hour earlier he had taken bicarbonate of soda to weaken his stomach acid and give any germ in the pill a better chance.1, 2
On the third day a watery diarrhoea began and lasted about a week.1
Goldberger was a government doctor, and he was trying to catch pellagra on purpose. Most American doctors believed it was an infection, and it was killing thousands of people a year across the South.1, 2 If a man could swallow the disease and stay well, the germ theory was in trouble.
The disease had first been described in the 1700s, by a Spanish doctor who knew it as the rose.2, 3
The rose of Asturias
Gaspar Casal, a doctor in Oviedo in Asturias, knew no disease of the region more horrible or more stubborn.2, 3
A crust formed on the backs of the hands and feet. It began as redness and roughness and turned into a black, scabby crust, bone dry and split by cracks that ran down to the living flesh, with fierce pain and burning.3
The crusts came about the spring equinox. In summer they peeled away and left smooth, shining red marks like the scars of healed burns. Casal thought the rosy colour had given the disease its name, the mal de la rosa. And every spring the crust came back, like the swallow.3
Some patients bore a second mark. A rough, ash-brown band crossed the front of the neck from side to side, two fingers wide, "like a necklace", with a strip hanging down over the breastbone. Casal never saw it on anyone else, sick or well, and doctors still call it Casal's necklace.2, 3
The rose reached the mind as well as the skin. A man Casal calls only P. came to him as delirium began and said, "I don't seem to find or feel the things I touch with my hands, though they be hard and rough, nor do I find with my feet the ground I tread."3
Casal's patients were poor farmers who lived on bread and porridge of maize, with chestnuts, beans, cabbage, cheese and fruit. They hardly ever ate fresh meat, and could not afford salt pork even one day in ten. Casal thought the butter in milk could have mended their lean diet, but the poor skimmed it off and sold it.3
Casal heard of a woman who had gone mad with the rose and began to crave cow's butter. She sold everything she had to buy enough to eat almost her fill each day, and on that diet alone she came out free of both the rose and the madness.3
Casal decided the rose was a cross between leprosy and scurvy, and he was half right. Like scurvy, it comes from a missing vitamin. He died in 1759, and his account of the rose came out three years later.3, 4
By then farmers in northern Italy had the same disease. In 1771 Francesco Frapolli of Milan's great hospital described the sickness "which the common people call pelagra". The farmers ignored its summer scales until fear, sleeplessness, forgetting and sometimes mania set in, with a diarrhoea no remedy could stop, and they wasted away and died.5
Maize had come to Europe from the Americas, and wherever it became the bread of the poor, from Spain to Italy, Romania and Egypt, pellagra followed.2
The asylum disease
Pellagra was new to American doctors when Dr George Searcy found it in 1906 in an Alabama asylum. He counted 88 cases, and nearly two in three died. In 1908 South Carolina's asylum chief James Babcock saw the same new killer in his wards.2
Soon asylums, prisons and orphanages across the South reported it, then the poor at large. In 1915 pellagra caused more than a third of all the deaths at the Georgia State Asylum in Milledgeville.2 Between about 1906 and 1940 the American epidemic ran to some three million cases. At least a hundred thousand people died of it, half of them Black and more than two-thirds of them women.2, 6
Doctors argued over the cause. Some blamed spoiled maize.2 Others blamed an infection carried by an insect.7 A commission that went house to house in South Carolina's cotton-mill towns found no link with diet. Its doctors reported that the sick almost always lived in or next door to a house where someone already had it.2
Fear followed the disease, and people shunned the sick.8 In 1914 Babcock was forced to resign, accused of harming the state's name by drawing attention to it.2
Why the nurses stayed well
Goldberger came south in 1914. He specialised in epidemics, had come to America from Hungary as a boy, and had caught and survived many of the diseases he studied.2, 9
Touring asylums and orphanages, he noticed a fact others had written down without seeing what it meant. Patients fell ill with pellagra, some after ten or twenty years inside. The nurses and attendants never did, though they often lived on the same wards. "If pellagra be a communicable disease," he asked in print, "why should there be this exemption of the nurses and attendants?"10
Staff and patients seemed to eat the same food. The staff took the best and the greatest variety for themselves, and could eat outside.10 The patients were left with maize mush, molasses, gravy and biscuits.2
In two orphanages in Jackson, Mississippi, the disease struck children of six to twelve. Babies got what milk there was, and older children worked and ate a little better. Both mostly escaped.2, 11
From September 1914 Goldberger's team used federal money to give the children fresh meat, much more milk and eggs at breakfast. The rashes should have come back in the spring of 1915. Almost all of them stayed away. At one home, not one of the 67 children who had had pellagra the year before had it again.2, 11
Then the money ran out. The old food came back, and so did the disease. By the spring of 1916, 40 per cent of the orphans had pellagra.2
A pardon for a plate of grits
Many doctors found his diet idea absurd and attacked him for it.2 To convince them, he set out to cause pellagra with food alone.
The Mississippi state penitentiary had a prison farm east of Jackson where pellagra had never been known. Governor Earl Brewer offered a pardon to the convicts who would take part. Twelve white men volunteered, chosen because white men seemed the least likely to get it.12
They lived apart in a small screened cottage, under guard day and night. From April 1915 they ate scone-like biscuits, maize mush and grits, gravy, rice, cornbread, collard greens, sweet potatoes and cane syrup.12
In September the rash broke out on six of the eleven men still in the test. It showed first on the scrotum, which the doctors saw only because they examined the men stripped.12 Several tried to quit. One said he had been "through a thousand hells", and others pleaded to be shot.2
Goldberger was accused of torture, and Brewer of staging the whole thing to free two friends jailed for embezzlement.2
The next spring came the pill of flour. Goldberger tested the germ theory on "an animal species known to be susceptible, namely, man himself." Sixteen volunteers took part, thirteen of them doctors. The one woman was his wife, and she took only the injection of blood.1, 2
In seven rounds between April and June, volunteers were injected with patients' blood, had patients' nose secretions swabbed into their own noses, and swallowed scales, urine and stool. Goldberger took part in all seven.1
"When one considers the relatively enormous quantities of filth taken," he wrote, "the reactions experienced were surprisingly slight." Nobody caught pellagra.1 His critics replied that the volunteers must be naturally resistant.2
The South did not want his answer either. In 1921 a letter of Goldberger's on pellagra and poverty reached the press. President Warren Harding asked for a full report and suggested the Red Cross help, and newspapers wrote of famine and plague. A Georgia city wired its senator, "When this part of Georgia suffers from famine, the rest of the world will be dead!"2
Black tongue
Goldberger spent the rest of his life hunting the missing factor in food, the P-P factor, for pellagra-preventive.2, 14 Dogs gave him the way in. An employee at the Milledgeville asylum cut his hunting dogs' food by half and made up the rest with cornbread, to make them keener hunters. They came down with black tongue, a dog disease much like pellagra, in which the mouth fills with sores.2
Now Goldberger had pellagra in an animal. Sick dogs would not eat, so they were given yeast for their appetite. His team soon found the yeast was the richest source of the factor.2 When the Mississippi flooded in 1927, Goldberger had the Red Cross ship yeast into the flood country, and the expected outbreak of pellagra never came. When the yeast stopped, the disease came back.2
Goldberger saw pellagra as a disease of poverty, and thought its real cure was land reform.2, 13 He died of cancer in 1929, eight years before anyone knew what P-P was.7
In 1937, at the University of Wisconsin, Conrad Elvehjem's team pinned it down. P-P was nicotinic acid, now called niacin or vitamin B3, and it cured black tongue in dogs.14, 15 By then pellagra was already falling. Cotton's collapse in the Depression had pushed southern farmers to grow other crops, and in the Second World War nicotinic acid went into America's flour. Endemic pellagra disappeared.2, 14
In the Americas maize had long been ground with an alkali called lime water, which frees more of its nicotinic acid, and eaten with much else. No pellagra was known among the peoples who ate it that way.2
The bathing suit
A sauna supplement sold today mixes beetroot powder with fast-release niacin, the kind that turns the skin red and hot. Its seller says the body stashes toxins in fat cells and that niacin can "flush those toxins out" through blood flow and sweat. When the skin flushes, "embrace it as a sign the formula is working."16 A sauna blog gives the same advice, with twenty minutes of cardio before the heat.16
The recipe is older than the powder. Scientology's founder L. Ron Hubbard said he ran some research with nicotinic acid in 1950. "Its most startling effect was that it would turn on, in a red flush, a sunburn on the person's body in an exact pattern of a bathing suit!"17, 18
Hubbard decided the niacin did not cause the flush. "What it starts to do is immediately run out sunburn or radiation." In 1979 he built it into his Purification program, with running and long hours in a sauna to "sweat out the accumulated toxins."17
In 2005 a team in Heidelberg showed where the flush comes from. In mice, niacin locks onto a receptor called GPR109A, and immune cells in the skin answer by releasing prostaglandins, signalling chemicals that widen the skin's small blood vessels. Mice bred without the receptor did not flush at all.19
The red is the skin's own signal, made by its own cells.19
The swallow and the rose
Today vitamin B3 is studied as niacin, nicotinamide and nicotinamide riboside, and what the trials in people found is in the Research tab.
Casal's farmers watched the rose come back every spring, like the swallow. Goldberger swallowed the disease itself, and it never came.