NR-035Ingredient Atlas entry · Vitamin

Vitamin B3

Niacin (nicotinic acid), nicotinamide and nicotinamide riboside

A Spanish doctor's rose, an Alabama asylum, a Mississippi prison farm and a pill of flour and filth. For two centuries pellagra followed maize into the poorest kitchens of Europe and America, and in the American South it killed at least a hundred thousand people. Its cause was a missing vitamin. The red flush that vitamin brings on has a story of its own.

  • Found in: meat, fish, eggs, wheat flour
  • Doses differ by form, in mg a day
  • Often studied in people with a health condition
Peanuts in the shell, cracked open, shelled and peeled
Peanuts in the shell, cracked open, shelled and peeled. Photo by Ivar Leidus, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A pill of flour

Columbia, South Carolina, 28 April 1916. Joseph Goldberger swallows a pill of wheat flour.1

Worked into the dough were skin scrapings from the sores of two patients at the state asylum, a little of their urine and the liquid stool of a third. All three had pellagra, a disease that doctors summed up as dermatitis, diarrhoea, dementia and death. Half an hour earlier he had taken bicarbonate of soda to weaken his stomach acid and give any germ in the pill a better chance.1, 2

On the third day a watery diarrhoea began and lasted about a week.1

Goldberger was a government doctor, and he was trying to catch pellagra on purpose. Most American doctors believed it was an infection, and it was killing thousands of people a year across the South.1, 2 If a man could swallow the disease and stay well, the germ theory was in trouble.

The disease had first been described in the 1700s, by a Spanish doctor who knew it as the rose.2, 3

The rose of Asturias

Gaspar Casal, a doctor in Oviedo in Asturias, knew no disease of the region more horrible or more stubborn.2, 3

A crust formed on the backs of the hands and feet. It began as redness and roughness and turned into a black, scabby crust, bone dry and split by cracks that ran down to the living flesh, with fierce pain and burning.3

The crusts came about the spring equinox. In summer they peeled away and left smooth, shining red marks like the scars of healed burns. Casal thought the rosy colour had given the disease its name, the mal de la rosa. And every spring the crust came back, like the swallow.3

Some patients bore a second mark. A rough, ash-brown band crossed the front of the neck from side to side, two fingers wide, "like a necklace", with a strip hanging down over the breastbone. Casal never saw it on anyone else, sick or well, and doctors still call it Casal's necklace.2, 3

The rose reached the mind as well as the skin. A man Casal calls only P. came to him as delirium began and said, "I don't seem to find or feel the things I touch with my hands, though they be hard and rough, nor do I find with my feet the ground I tread."3

Casal's patients were poor farmers who lived on bread and porridge of maize, with chestnuts, beans, cabbage, cheese and fruit. They hardly ever ate fresh meat, and could not afford salt pork even one day in ten. Casal thought the butter in milk could have mended their lean diet, but the poor skimmed it off and sold it.3

Casal heard of a woman who had gone mad with the rose and began to crave cow's butter. She sold everything she had to buy enough to eat almost her fill each day, and on that diet alone she came out free of both the rose and the madness.3

Casal decided the rose was a cross between leprosy and scurvy, and he was half right. Like scurvy, it comes from a missing vitamin. He died in 1759, and his account of the rose came out three years later.3, 4

By then farmers in northern Italy had the same disease. In 1771 Francesco Frapolli of Milan's great hospital described the sickness "which the common people call pelagra". The farmers ignored its summer scales until fear, sleeplessness, forgetting and sometimes mania set in, with a diarrhoea no remedy could stop, and they wasted away and died.5

Maize had come to Europe from the Americas, and wherever it became the bread of the poor, from Spain to Italy, Romania and Egypt, pellagra followed.2

The asylum disease

Pellagra was new to American doctors when Dr George Searcy found it in 1906 in an Alabama asylum. He counted 88 cases, and nearly two in three died. In 1908 South Carolina's asylum chief James Babcock saw the same new killer in his wards.2

Soon asylums, prisons and orphanages across the South reported it, then the poor at large. In 1915 pellagra caused more than a third of all the deaths at the Georgia State Asylum in Milledgeville.2 Between about 1906 and 1940 the American epidemic ran to some three million cases. At least a hundred thousand people died of it, half of them Black and more than two-thirds of them women.2, 6

Doctors argued over the cause. Some blamed spoiled maize.2 Others blamed an infection carried by an insect.7 A commission that went house to house in South Carolina's cotton-mill towns found no link with diet. Its doctors reported that the sick almost always lived in or next door to a house where someone already had it.2

Fear followed the disease, and people shunned the sick.8 In 1914 Babcock was forced to resign, accused of harming the state's name by drawing attention to it.2

Why the nurses stayed well

Goldberger came south in 1914. He specialised in epidemics, had come to America from Hungary as a boy, and had caught and survived many of the diseases he studied.2, 9

Touring asylums and orphanages, he noticed a fact others had written down without seeing what it meant. Patients fell ill with pellagra, some after ten or twenty years inside. The nurses and attendants never did, though they often lived on the same wards. "If pellagra be a communicable disease," he asked in print, "why should there be this exemption of the nurses and attendants?"10

Staff and patients seemed to eat the same food. The staff took the best and the greatest variety for themselves, and could eat outside.10 The patients were left with maize mush, molasses, gravy and biscuits.2

In two orphanages in Jackson, Mississippi, the disease struck children of six to twelve. Babies got what milk there was, and older children worked and ate a little better. Both mostly escaped.2, 11

From September 1914 Goldberger's team used federal money to give the children fresh meat, much more milk and eggs at breakfast. The rashes should have come back in the spring of 1915. Almost all of them stayed away. At one home, not one of the 67 children who had had pellagra the year before had it again.2, 11

Then the money ran out. The old food came back, and so did the disease. By the spring of 1916, 40 per cent of the orphans had pellagra.2

A pardon for a plate of grits

Many doctors found his diet idea absurd and attacked him for it.2 To convince them, he set out to cause pellagra with food alone.

The Mississippi state penitentiary had a prison farm east of Jackson where pellagra had never been known. Governor Earl Brewer offered a pardon to the convicts who would take part. Twelve white men volunteered, chosen because white men seemed the least likely to get it.12

They lived apart in a small screened cottage, under guard day and night. From April 1915 they ate scone-like biscuits, maize mush and grits, gravy, rice, cornbread, collard greens, sweet potatoes and cane syrup.12

In September the rash broke out on six of the eleven men still in the test. It showed first on the scrotum, which the doctors saw only because they examined the men stripped.12 Several tried to quit. One said he had been "through a thousand hells", and others pleaded to be shot.2

Goldberger was accused of torture, and Brewer of staging the whole thing to free two friends jailed for embezzlement.2

The next spring came the pill of flour. Goldberger tested the germ theory on "an animal species known to be susceptible, namely, man himself." Sixteen volunteers took part, thirteen of them doctors. The one woman was his wife, and she took only the injection of blood.1, 2

In seven rounds between April and June, volunteers were injected with patients' blood, had patients' nose secretions swabbed into their own noses, and swallowed scales, urine and stool. Goldberger took part in all seven.1

"When one considers the relatively enormous quantities of filth taken," he wrote, "the reactions experienced were surprisingly slight." Nobody caught pellagra.1 His critics replied that the volunteers must be naturally resistant.2

The South did not want his answer either. In 1921 a letter of Goldberger's on pellagra and poverty reached the press. President Warren Harding asked for a full report and suggested the Red Cross help, and newspapers wrote of famine and plague. A Georgia city wired its senator, "When this part of Georgia suffers from famine, the rest of the world will be dead!"2

Black tongue

Goldberger spent the rest of his life hunting the missing factor in food, the P-P factor, for pellagra-preventive.2, 14 Dogs gave him the way in. An employee at the Milledgeville asylum cut his hunting dogs' food by half and made up the rest with cornbread, to make them keener hunters. They came down with black tongue, a dog disease much like pellagra, in which the mouth fills with sores.2

Now Goldberger had pellagra in an animal. Sick dogs would not eat, so they were given yeast for their appetite. His team soon found the yeast was the richest source of the factor.2 When the Mississippi flooded in 1927, Goldberger had the Red Cross ship yeast into the flood country, and the expected outbreak of pellagra never came. When the yeast stopped, the disease came back.2

Goldberger saw pellagra as a disease of poverty, and thought its real cure was land reform.2, 13 He died of cancer in 1929, eight years before anyone knew what P-P was.7

In 1937, at the University of Wisconsin, Conrad Elvehjem's team pinned it down. P-P was nicotinic acid, now called niacin or vitamin B3, and it cured black tongue in dogs.14, 15 By then pellagra was already falling. Cotton's collapse in the Depression had pushed southern farmers to grow other crops, and in the Second World War nicotinic acid went into America's flour. Endemic pellagra disappeared.2, 14

In the Americas maize had long been ground with an alkali called lime water, which frees more of its nicotinic acid, and eaten with much else. No pellagra was known among the peoples who ate it that way.2

The bathing suit

A sauna supplement sold today mixes beetroot powder with fast-release niacin, the kind that turns the skin red and hot. Its seller says the body stashes toxins in fat cells and that niacin can "flush those toxins out" through blood flow and sweat. When the skin flushes, "embrace it as a sign the formula is working."16 A sauna blog gives the same advice, with twenty minutes of cardio before the heat.16

The recipe is older than the powder. Scientology's founder L. Ron Hubbard said he ran some research with nicotinic acid in 1950. "Its most startling effect was that it would turn on, in a red flush, a sunburn on the person's body in an exact pattern of a bathing suit!"17, 18

Hubbard decided the niacin did not cause the flush. "What it starts to do is immediately run out sunburn or radiation." In 1979 he built it into his Purification program, with running and long hours in a sauna to "sweat out the accumulated toxins."17

In 2005 a team in Heidelberg showed where the flush comes from. In mice, niacin locks onto a receptor called GPR109A, and immune cells in the skin answer by releasing prostaglandins, signalling chemicals that widen the skin's small blood vessels. Mice bred without the receptor did not flush at all.19

The red is the skin's own signal, made by its own cells.19

The swallow and the rose

Today vitamin B3 is studied as niacin, nicotinamide and nicotinamide riboside, and what the trials in people found is in the Research tab.

Casal's farmers watched the rose come back every spring, like the swallow. Goldberger swallowed the disease itself, and it never came.

See what modern trials found

Myths and facts

In the record, or legend?

Every story you will read about this vitamin, checked against the oldest source we could find.

  • Goldberger swallowed pellagra patients' skin, urine and stool to show it was not catching

    In the record

    His own 1916 report, with his wife among the sixteen volunteers1, 2

  • Casal first described the disease in 1735

    Told, not shown

    The year later historians give. Casal's chapter, printed in 1762, names no year2, 3

  • Casal's necklace, a band of rough skin across the front of the neck

    In the record

    Casal's own description and figure3

  • Mississippi convicts were offered pardons to eat a pellagra diet

    In the record

    Goldberger and Wheeler's 1915 report12

  • Pellagra passes from person to person

    Legend

    No staff caught it in the asylums, a diet caused it, and fifteen volunteers swallowed patients' urine and stool without falling ill1, 10, 12

  • Liming maize is why the Americas' maize eaters never had pellagra

    Partly

    Lime frees more of the grain's nicotinic acid, but a varied diet probably mattered more2

  • The niacin flush is a sign toxins are being flushed out

    Legend

    The flush is widened skin blood vessels, set off by the skin's own prostaglandins16, 19

  • Niacin "runs out" old sunburn and radiation

    Legend

    Hubbard's idea, from research he said he ran in 1950. Mice without the niacin receptor do not flush17, 19

In the record means a source from the time, or a scholar quoting one, says it. Likely means a named expert's reasoned identification. Told, not shown means one interested party says it and nothing checks it. Partly means a real event sits under a bigger story. Legend means the earliest source is far too late or missing. Wrong date means the event is real but the popular date doesn't match the record.

Notes

Every fact in the story points to one of these. Where a translation is ours, the note says so.

Show all 19 notes Hide the notes
  1. Joseph Goldberger, "The transmissibility of pellagra. Experimental attempts at transmission to the human subject", Public Health Reports 31, no. 46 (17 November 1916), pp. 3159-3173, read at the Southern Medical Association, Atlanta, 16 November 1916; free in JSTOR's Early Journal Content, https://archive.org/details/jstor-4574262 . p. 3160: "the writer planned to test the question of the infectivity of the disease by experiment on an animal species known to be susceptible, namely, man himself"; "Some 20 individuals volunteered ... It was not practicable, however, to utilize more than 16 of them. These included 1 woman"; "Thirteen were physicians." p. 3161: "The materials used were blood, nasopharyngeal secretions, epidermal scales from pellagrous skin lesions, urine, and feces. The blood was administered by intramuscular or subcutaneous injection, the secretions by application to the mucosa of the nose and nasopharynx, scales, and excreta by mouth"; the scales and excreta were taken after sodium bicarbonate, "In order to reduce gastric acidity and thus minimize the possibly germicidal effect of the gastric juice." p. 3162 (experiment group 2): "On April 28, epidermal scales and urine were obtained from each of two patients and feces from a third at the State Hospital for Insane at Columbia, S. C."; the feces "was liquid"; the scales, urine and feces "were worked up into a pilular mass with wheat flour and in this form swallowed by volunteer G-J, 30 minutes after taking ... sodium bicarbonate"; "The alkali was intended to reduce gastric acidity and thus perhaps favor infection"; "For several days after the ingestion of the foregoing materials this volunteer experienced some light epigastric fullness and eructations of gas after a meal. On the third day a diarrhea with frequent, painless, watery, and rather gaseous evacuations developed. The diarrhea lasted about a week. It was still present on May 7". pp. 3162-3163 (group 3, 7 May, United States Pellagra Hospital, Spartanburg): five volunteers, G-J among them, swallowed scales, urine and feces; the pooled blood of three patients "were injected subcutaneously into each of the six volunteers", the sixth, G-MHF, receiving "blood only." pp. 3166-3167: "When one considers the relatively enormous quantities of filth taken the reactions experienced were surprisingly slight"; "None has developed any evidence justifying even a suspicion of pellagra." p. 3166: the experiments ran from 25 April to 25 June. p. 3170, list of volunteers: "G. J. — Medical officer, 42 years. Stationed at Washington, D. C. ... Participated in all seven experiments"; "G-MHF. — Housewife, 35 years. Resides at Washington, D. C. The only woman among the volunteers." We take G-J to be Goldberger himself (high confidence: the initials, his age and post, and Bollet, note 2, who says Goldberger took part). p. 3159: "There is a very widely held belief, at least in the United States, that pellagra is a communicable disease." That the disease was killing thousands is from note 2. ↩
  2. Alfred Jay Bollet, "Politics and pellagra: the epidemic of pellagra in the U.S. in the early twentieth century", Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine 65 (1992), pp. 211-221, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1285449/ (free full text on PMC, PMC2589605; the PMC site shows a bot check, so the PubMed page is linked). Page numbers below are worked out from the page numbers printed in the PMC text. p. 211: the epidemic "at its peak produced at least 250,000 cases and caused 7,000 deaths a year for several decades in 15 southern states"; Casal "first observed the disease in the town of Oviedo, in the Asturias region, where it was known as 'mal de la rosa'"; "Although Casal thought it was a peculiar form of leprosy, his descriptions were extremely accurate, and the rash in the exposed areas around the neck is still known as 'Casal's necklace'"; Casal's year is given as 1735 ("beginning in 1735, with the first description of the disease by Don Pedro Casal"; the first name is a slip for Gaspar); "American Indian corn, or maize, when introduced into the Old World". p. 212: "The use of corn as a staple food crop spread from Spain to southern France, Italy, Romania, Russia, and Egypt; pellagra followed"; the "spoiled corn" theory "remained popular" (the laws against selling mouldy corn that Bollet mentions were passed in Europe, "before the disease became common in the United States"); "Pellagra was a new disease to American physicians when the first cases began to be reported", and a single Georgia case of 1902 was "attributed to spoiled corn"; in 1906 Dr George H. Searcy "recognized pellagra at the Mount Vernon annex to the Bryce Hospital for Alabama Insane" and "described 88 cases, with a mortality rate of 64 percent"; in 1908 Dr James Babcock, superintendent of the State Hospital for the Insane in Columbia, South Carolina, "realized that patients in that hospital were dying of a new disease"; it "began to be recognized in inmates of prisons, orphanages, and in the general population." p. 213: "The syndrome was referred to as the 'three D's': dermatitis, diarrhea, and dementia; the fourth 'D' was death"; "In 1915, Milledgeville had 1,433 cases with 220 deaths-35 percent of all deaths in the institution." pp. 213-214: "During the period from 1915 to 1925, the first decade of reporting, 27,648 deaths from pellagra were recorded" (the story's "thousands a year"). p. 214 (with Stephen J. Mooney, Justin Knox and Alfredo Morabia, "The Thompson-McFadden Commission and Joseph Goldberger", American Journal of Epidemiology 180 (2014), pp. 235-244, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24966221/ , for the cotton-mill villages of South Carolina): the epidemic, "which lasted from about 1906 to 1940, resulted in roughly 3 million cases, with 100,000 deaths in the reporting states"; the Thompson-McFadden Pellagra Commission "studied cases in the cotton mill districts, conducting a house-to-house survey", found "no relationship between the disease and diet", and reported that "the disease occurred almost exclusively in people who lived in or next to the house of another person with pellagra." p. 215: "Babcock was forced to resign in 1914 ... accused of having brought injury to the reputation and progress of South Carolina by calling attention to the prevalence of pellagra in the state"; Goldberger's studies "pointed to social and economic factors as being responsible for the occurrence of pellagra, because of the effect they had on the diet of the poor"; a letter of Goldberger's on pellagra and poverty "reached the press" and "stimulated the newly inaugurated president, Warren Harding" (so 1921) to ask for "a complete report"; Harding "suggested that the Red Cross provide aid"; a congressman called the news reports of "famine and plague" in South Carolina an "utter absurdity"; a Georgia city wired Senator Tom Watson, "When this part of Georgia suffers from famine, the rest of the world will be dead!" p. 216: Goldberger was "another officer experienced in the study of epidemic infectious disease ... he had acquired and survived many of them"; he "had immigrated to the U.S. from Hungary at the age of six" (note 9 gives a later year); staff "ate first, taking the leanest portions of the meat and whatever variety was available"; inmates "were left with cornmeal mush, cane syrup or molasses, gravy, and biscuits"; "At orphanages, the pellagra occurred among children who were between six and 12, but rarely affected infants or older children ... infants were given whatever milk was available, and older children were given work to do and fed a little better"; from September 1914 the Jackson orphans got "a more varied diet, including fresh meat once a week and abundant milk" (Goldberger's own report, note 11, p. 3121, says fresh meat went up from once to three or four times a week). p. 217: "as soon as the federal funds ran out, the old diet was resumed and pellagra returned; during the spring of 1916, 40 percent of the children in the orphanages had the disease"; at the 1915 meetings "Goldberger was attacked and vilified", and "His conclusion that a more varied diet was needed ... was considered absurd"; at the Rankin prison farm "There had never been a case"; of the volunteers, "Several were so miserable that they tried to end the experiment prematurely, one saying, 'I have been through a thousand hells!' while others pleaded for a quick death from a bullet" (Bollet cites Goldberger and Wheeler's full 1920 report in Hygienic Laboratory Bulletin 120, which we could not read); "Goldberger was accused of torture, and Governor Brewer was accused of having arranged the whole experiment in order to be able to pardon two of the prisoners who were his friends, convicted of embezzlement"; "He had himself, his wife, and his associates injected with blood from pellagrins"; the results "were also dismissed, since pellagra was more common in women, and thus his staff must have been 'constitutionally resistant'"; "he called it 'PPF,' pellagra preventive factor." p. 218: black tongue "had developed in hunting dogs of an employee at the research facility at the Georgia State Asylum in Milledgeville, when the dogs were fed half their usual ration, supplemented with cornbread, supposedly to improve their hunting avidity"; in dogs fed a poor diet at Yale, "sores and hemorrhages in the mouth; the dried, crusted blood led to the name 'black tongue'", "An animal model of pellagra was sought ... A dog model came to Goldberger's attention almost accidentally"; "The sore mouth made the dogs unwilling to swallow (as occurred in human cases), and yeast was generally used to stimulate appetites. The Public Health Service investigators soon realized that yeast contained the 'pellagra preventive factor' and then found it to be the most potent source of this factor"; Goldberger "arranged to have the Red Cross ship large quantities of it into flood-stricken areas along the Mississippi River in 1927. The expected outbreak of pellagra did not occur ... After the emergency, yeast was no longer provided, and the usual level of pellagra returned to the area"; cheap synthetic vitamins "led to legislation in many states requiring their addition to commonly used foods." p. 219: "The Indians ground their corn into meal using lime water, and alkali has been demonstrated to increase the extraction of the nicotinic acid which is present in corn ... This practice may account for the absence of any known pellagra among the Indians, but it is more likely that a varied diet was the most important factor." Bollet's own sources include Elizabeth Etheridge, The Butterfly Caste (1972), which we could not read. ↩
  3. Gaspar Casal, Historia natural, y medica de el Principado de Asturias. Obra posthuma, ed. Juan Joseph García Sevillano (Madrid, 1762), chapter "De affectione, quae vulgo in hac regione mal de la Rosa nuncupatur", pp. 327-361, Wellcome Collection copy at https://archive.org/details/b30507601 . The chapter is in Latin, with one patient quoted in Spanish. Translations ours; the original words are in the source log. p. 327: he saw "nullam, vernacularum omnium affectionum, horribiliorem, contumacioremque eo, in hac regione esse" (no local disease in this region more horrible or more stubborn); the disease "unius tantum eorum [symptomatum] illud vulgare nomen sibi adoptat" (takes its common name from only one of its symptoms), "quaedam terrifica crusta" which begins as redness or roughness and becomes "crustam siccissimam, scabrosam, nigricantem, profundis saepissime intercissam fissuris, ad vivam usque carnem penetrantibus, cum eximio dolore, flagrantia, et molestia" (a very dry, scabby, blackish crust, often cut by deep cracks reaching the living flesh, with great pain, burning and distress), on the backs of the hands or feet ("metacarpis, vel metatarsis"). p. 328: the crusts begin "circa vernale aequinoctium"; in summer they come away, leaving "stigmata subrubra, exquisite polita, et splendentia; similia cicatricibus, quas sanatae ambustiones ... relinquere solent" (reddish marks, finely smooth and shining, like the scars healed burns leave); "Ex hoc roseo cicatricis colore, et splendore, illud nomen suam derivasse originem, verisimile est" (it is likely the name came from this rosy colour and shine of the scar); "singulis annis, vere novo (sicut Hirundo) maligna crusta redit" (every year, in the new spring, like the swallow, the crust returns). p. 329: in some patients a rough ash-brown band "in parte anteriore, et inferiore colli, quae, monilis instar, ab uno cervicis latere usque ad alterum ... duorum circiter digitorum lata" (on the front of the lower neck, like a necklace, from one side to the other, about two fingers wide), with a strip down the breastbone "sicut in figura repraesentatur" (as shown in the figure); "Nunquam tali nota hominem ullum (sive sanum, sive aegrotum) designatum invenire potui, praeter hos" (I never found anyone, healthy or sick, so marked except these). pp. 339-340, diet: "Maizium, seu Milium indicum est praecipuum alimentum" (maize is the main food) of nearly all the sufferers, as bread and porridge; also eggs, chestnuts, beans, peas, turnips, cabbage, milk, butter, cheese and tree fruit; "Rarissime carnes recentes" (very rarely fresh meat), because nearly all are "pauperes agricolae" (poor farmers) who cannot have salted meat "pro singulis diebus, quin nec pro decimoquoque" (every day, nor even every tenth); he also notes that most farmers of the province ate the same way and stayed strong. p. 343: compared with old, malignant scurvy, "parvum discrimen inter eos inveniet" (one will find little difference between them). pp. 351-352, his conclusion: "morbum hunc de la rosa peculiare quoddam genus esse, ex leprae, et scorbuti seminiis, singulari modo combinatis, consurgens. Ideoque appellari eum posse scorbutum lepriformem, aut lepram scorbuticam" (this mal de la rosa is a peculiar kind, arising from the seeds of leprosy and scurvy combined in a singular way, and so it could be called leprous scurvy or scorbutic leprosy). That scurvy comes from a missing vitamin: Wikipedia, "Scurvy", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scurvy : "a deficiency disease resulting from a lack of vitamin C". pp. 344-345: "Dudum ad me venit homo quidam, P." (some time ago a certain man, P., came to me), who had fallen "in quoddam deliramentorum principium" (into a beginning of delirium) and spoke these words: "No me parece, que encuentro, ni percibo las cosas, que toco con las manos, aunque sean duras, y asperas; ni hallo con los pies la tierra que piso." pp. 358-359: milk, "quod, butyri gratia, poterat proculdubio macredinem aliorum eduliorum corrigere" (which because of its butter could no doubt mend the leanness of their other foods), rarely reaches them unstripped, because the poor "separant butyrum a reliqua lactis materia, et vendunt" (separate the butter from the rest of the milk and sell it) to buy other necessities. p. 359: "Ex relatione nobilis cujusdam viri" (from the account of a certain nobleman), a woman still living who had fallen into madness from the disease began "desiderare, et anxie requirere butyrum lactis vaccini" (to crave and anxiously seek cow's butter), sold all she had to buy enough "pro quotidiano pastu, usque ad satietatem fere" (for her daily food, almost to her fill), and on that diet alone escaped "non tantum a morbo de la rosa, verum etiam a dementia" (not only from the mal de la rosa but also from the madness). Page numbers are as printed in the scan; read from the text layer and to be confirmed on the page images. ↩
  4. Wikipedia, "Gaspar Casal", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaspar_Casal : "(31 December 1681 – 10 August 1759)"; he practised in Oviedo and "described pellagra in a book published in 1762". The Spanish article (https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaspar_Casal) gives his birth as 1680 and says he worked in Asturias from 1717 to 1751. The 1762 title page calls the book "Obra posthuma" (note 3). ↩
  5. Francesco Frapolli, physician of the Ospedale Maggiore of Milan ("Mediolanensis Nosocomii majoris"), Animadversiones in morbum, vulgo pelagram (Milan, 1771; imprint "Mediolani. MDCCLXXI"), Wellcome Collection copy at https://archive.org/details/b31893946 . Translation ours. p. 8: the skin dries, splits and "in squamulas decidit albas veluti furfuraceas" (falls in small white scales like bran) on the hands, feet, chest and other parts exposed to the sun; this "morbum illum constituit, quem vulgo Pelagram vocant" (makes up the disease the common people call pelagra); pp. 8-9: after summer the skin returns to normal and "Pelagram negligunt Agricolae" (the farmers neglect the pelagra). p. 9: then "timorem, moeroremque, vigilias, vertiginesque, mentis oblivionem, ne dicam, fatuitatem, hypocondriaca deliria, alvi fluxum, et aliquando Maniam" (fear and sadness, sleeplessness, giddiness, forgetfulness, not to say stupidity, hypochondriac delusions, flux of the bowels and sometimes mania), wasting, and a "dyarrhaea colliquativa ... remediis omnibus contumacissima" (wasting diarrhoea most stubborn against all remedies), until they die "consumptos macie extremam" (consumed by extreme wasting). ↩
  6. Harry M. Marks, "Epidemiologists explain pellagra: gender, race, and political economy in the work of Edgar Sydenstricker", Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 58 (2003), pp. 34-55, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12680009/ : "Between 1900 and 1940, at least 100,000 individuals in the southern United States died of pellagra ... half of these pellagra victims were African-American and more than two-thirds were women." Abstract only; the full paper is paywalled. ↩
  7. Charles S. Bryan and Shane R. Mull, "Pellagra pre-Goldberger: Rupert Blue, Fleming Sandwith, and the 'vitamine hypothesis'", Transactions of the American Clinical and Climatological Association 126 (2015), pp. 20-45, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26330657/ : Goldberger "before his death from cancer in 1929"; "an insect-borne infection hypothesis, championed by the flamboyant European Louis Westerna Sambon." Abstract read; the full text is on PMC (PMC4530670), which shows a bot check. ↩
  8. K. Rajakumar, "Pellagra in the United States: a historical perspective", Southern Medical Journal 93 (2000), pp. 272-277, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10728513/ : "a culture of 'pellagraphobia' formed among the public. Patients were shunned and ostracized." Abstract only. ↩
  9. Wikipedia, "Joseph Goldberger", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Goldberger : born 16 July 1874 in Girált, Kingdom of Hungary; died 17 January 1929; an officer of the United States Public Health Service. It says he "immigrated to the U.S. with his parents in 1883", when he was eight or nine; Bollet (note 2) says six. The story says "as a boy". ↩
  10. Joseph Goldberger, "The etiology of pellagra. The significance of certain epidemiological observations with respect thereto", Public Health Reports 29, no. 26 (26 June 1914), pp. 1683-1686, https://archive.org/details/jstor-4570920 . p. 1683: "certain observations recorded in the literature of pellagra the significance of which appears entirely to have escaped attention"; at the Georgia State Sanitarium a case in "an inmate after 10 years residence." p. 1684: at the Jackson asylum, cases "in an inmate after 15 and in another after 20 years' residence"; the nurses "live right in the ward with and of necessity under exactly the same conditions as the inmates ... yet nurses and attendants living under identical conditions appear uniformly to be immune. If pellagra be a communicable disease, why should there be this exemption of the nurses and attendants?" p. 1685: "the nurses have the privilege — which they exercise — of selecting the best and the greatest variety for themselves. Moreover ... nurses and attendants have opportunities for supplementing their institutional dietary that the inmates as a rule have not." ↩
  11. Joseph Goldberger, C. H. Waring and David G. Willets, "The prevention of pellagra. A test of diet among institutional inmates", Public Health Reports 30, no. 43 (22 October 1915), pp. 3117-3131, https://archive.org/details/jstor-4572932 . The two Jackson orphanages appear as "M. J." and "B. J."; Bollet (note 2) names them the Methodist and Baptist orphanages. pp. 3120-3121: 79 cases were seen at "M. J." and 130 at "B. J." in 1914; "The milk supply was greatly increased"; p. 3121: "It had been the custom to serve the children with fresh meat but once a week; under the writers' direction it was increased to three or four times a week"; "Eggs, except in cooking or for the sick, had previously not entered" the diet, and the January 1915 menu has an egg six mornings a week. p. 3123: at "M. J.", of 67 children who passed the anniversary of their 1914 attack, "In none of the 67, following the change in diet, has there been observed so far this year any recognizable evidence of a recurrence"; at "B. J.", recurrence "In only 1 of these 105 pellagrins." ↩
  12. Joseph Goldberger and G. A. Wheeler, "Experimental pellagra in the human subject brought about by a restricted diet", Public Health Reports 30, no. 46 (12 November 1915), pp. 3336-3339, https://archive.org/details/jstor-4572984 . p. 3336: the farm of the Mississippi State Penitentiary, "about 8 miles east of Jackson ... some 3,200 acres"; "there is no history of the occurrence or presence of pellagra on this farm"; twelve convicts, "accepting the offer of a pardon made them by Gov. Brewer", volunteered; "White adult males were selected because, judged by the incidence in the population at large, these would seem to be least susceptible to the disease"; on 1 July "one of the volunteers was released because of the development of a prostatitis. This left 11 men"; quartered in "a small, screened, one-storied cottage" and "under guard day and night"; the diet was changed "at noon April 19, 1915." p. 3337: the bill of fare of biscuits, fried mush, grits, brown gravy, rice, corn bread, cabbage, collards, sweet potatoes, cane syrup, and coffee with sugar. p. 3338: "Of the 11 volunteers, not less than 6 developed symptoms, including a 'typical' dermatitis"; first noted "between September 12 and September 24, 1915"; "in all our cases the skin lesions were first recognized on the scrotum ... It would probably have escaped us but for the fact that it was our routine to examine these men ... completely stripped." ↩
  13. Alessandra Parodi, David Neasham and Paolo Vineis, "Environment, population, and biology: a short history of modern epidemiology", Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 49 (2006), pp. 357-368, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16960306/ : "The 'cure' Goldberger proposed was land reform." Abstract only. ↩
  14. Douglas J. Lanska, "Historical aspects of the major neurological vitamin deficiency disorders: the water-soluble B vitamins", Handbook of Clinical Neurology 95 (2010), pp. 445-476, abstract at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19892133/ : "During the depression, the collapse of cotton as an economically viable crop facilitated crop diversification, which contributed to an abrupt decline in pellagra mortality in the early 1930s. In 1937 Elvehjem isolated the P-P (pellagra preventive) factor, identified it as nicotinic acid (niacin), and demonstrated that nicotinic acid and nicotinic acid amide cure black tongue in dogs ... Vitamin fortification of foodstuffs during World War II ultimately eradicated endemic pellagra in the United States." Abstract only. That the wartime enrichment put nicotinic acid into flour: Wikipedia, "Niacin", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niacin , "in 1942, when flour enrichment with nicotinic acid began". ↩
  15. C. A. Elvehjem, R. J. Madden, F. M. Strong and D. W. Woolley, "Relation of nicotinic acid and nicotinic acid amide to canine black tongue", Journal of the American Chemical Society 59 (1937), pp. 1767-1768, https://doi.org/10.1021/ja01288a509 (DOI checked on Crossref, September 1937). Cited for the title, the year and the authors; paywalled, not read. Wikipedia, "Conrad Elvehjem", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conrad_Elvehjem : he "became a full professor in 1936" at the University of Wisconsin, and "In 1937 he identified two vitamins, nicotinic acid, also known as niacin, and nicotinamide"; "he found that nicotinic acid cured black tongue in dogs". ↩
  16. The supplement page: "Promix Detox Flush", https://thefeed.com/products/promix-detox-flush (read 14 November 2026): "Your body stashes environmental toxins in fat cells"; "immediate-release niacin can mobilize that stored fat and flush those toxins out through enhanced blood flow and sweating"; "The flush is normal and will occur—embrace it as a sign the formula is working." A sauna blog, "Niacin use in sauna for detox" (Substack, 9 September 2023), https://howtoescapecorporate.substack.com/p/niacin-use-in-sauna-for-detox : "Niacin is thought to help remove toxins from the body"; take niacin, then "do 20 minutes of cardio", then "get into the sauna"; "Wipe the sweat off your body, those are the toxin coming out." ↩
  17. L. Ron Hubbard, Clear Body, Clear Mind: The Effective Purification Program (Los Angeles: Bridge Publications, 1990), read in a scan without its title page, page numbers as printed. p. 11: "I worked out and released in 1977 a regimen called 'The Sweat Program'" to sweat out drug residues. p. 12: the Purification program includes "Exercise, in the form of running, to stimulate the circulation" and "Prescribed periods in a sauna, which, accompanied by certain vitamins and other nutrients, enable one to sweat out the accumulated toxins." The book's introduction: "In 1979 his researches ... culminated in the Purification program." p. 23 (the scan garbles the number; it falls between pp. 22 and 24): "five hours exercise and sauna daily has been found to be ideal", with most of the time in the sauna. p. 36: "I conducted some research using niacin in 1950. At that time we referred to niacin as nicotinic acid"; "Its most startling effect was that it would turn on, in a red flush, a sunburn on the person's body in an exact pattern of a bathing suit!" p. 37: "Niacin all by itself does not turn on any flush. What it starts to do is immediately run out sunburn or radiation." Doses in the book are left out here. ↩
  18. Wikipedia, "L. Ron Hubbard", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L._Ron_Hubbard : "an American author and the founder of Scientology." Wikipedia, "Purification Rundown", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purification_Rundown , says Hubbard "put forward his ideas about niacin" in his book All About Radiation (1957 in the Hubbard article) and that the program "forms the basis" of programs run by Scientology-affiliated groups such as Narconon. ↩
  19. Zoltán Benyó and others, "GPR109A (PUMA-G/HM74A) mediates nicotinic acid-induced flushing", Journal of Clinical Investigation 115 (2005), pp. 3634-3640, https://www.jci.org/articles/view/23626 (also PMC1297235), from the University of Heidelberg's pharmacology institute. Abstract: "mice lacking PUMA-G did not show nicotinic acid-induced flushing"; the effect "involves release of PGE(2) and PGD(2), most likely from immune cells of the skin"; the flush is a side effect, "although harmless". Introduction: flushing "consists of a cutaneous vasodilation accompanied by a burning sensation mainly affecting the upper body and face." In mice the receptor is PUMA-G, the mouse form of the human GPR109A; the story uses the human name. ↩