NR-036Ingredient Atlas entry · Vitamin

Vitamin B5

Pantothenic acid, a B vitamin

A young doctor in Madras with fifty-three patients whose feet were on fire, a chemist whose eyes ached when he read, black rats that went grey and six prison volunteers fed through a tube in Iowa. The vitamin was named in 1933 for turning up everywhere, which is why it took two decades to show what life without it does to a person. In between, tablets sold to bring back the colour of grey hair were seized and destroyed.

  • Found in: meat, eggs, mushrooms, avocado and wholegrains
  • Dose not stated in the one study on its own
  • Mostly studied inside blends
A whole avocado and a halved avocado
A whole avocado and a halved avocado. Photo by Ivar Leidus, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Kal erichal

Madras, the mid-1940s. The patients come to the hospital because their feet are on fire.1

They call it kal erichal, Tamil for burning of the feet. It starts in the sole near the ball of the big toe and spreads until the whole sole burns. It can strike in bursts of excruciating agony, then leave them alone for the rest of the day. Some wrap their feet in a wet cloth. Beads of sweat stand out where it burns, and hard ground hurts so much that some lie in bed most of the time.1

Coluthur Gopalan was a doctor in his twenties from the Nutrition Research Laboratories in the hill town of Coonoor. He worked in the nutrition clinic of the Government Stanley Hospital. He had seen fifty-three of them. All were poor and all ate rice, living mostly on rice gruel and cheap vegetables. Thirty-nine were women, and twenty-seven of those had given birth a few weeks before the burning began.1, 2, 3

He tried yeast extract first, and all thirteen patients who took it got better. So he went looking for the vitamin inside it. Thiamine did nothing for the next ten, and niacin did no better. Riboflavin healed the sore tongues and cracked mouths that most of them also had, but the burning went on at full strength, and a few said it was worse. Then he injected ten patients with calcium pantothenate, a salt of pantothenic acid, the vitamin now called B5. All ten improved, and faster than on yeast. The burning was the first thing to go.1, 4

He wrote that the disease was "probably the result of deficiency of pantothenic acid in the diet".1

The vitamin was thirteen years old. It had been named by an American chemist born in Ootacamund, 19 kilometres from Coonoor.3, 5

From all sides

Roger Williams was born there in 1893, the youngest of six children of American missionaries, and taken to America by ship at two.5

His eyes ached whenever he read for more than a short time, from an eye condition that nobody could name until about 1930, aniseikonia. The special glasses he got at nearly fifty were only a moderate success. He liked to say the condition left him more time to think while others were reading.5

His oldest brother, Robert, had seen the diseases of poor diet while growing up in India, and in 1936 he isolated and made thiamine, vitamin B1.5

Roger chose yeast. His doctoral thesis at Chicago in 1919 was "The Vitamine Requirement of Yeast", and leading biochemists of the day tried to talk him into working with animals instead. He stayed with yeast, and took it to Oregon State College.5

There, in 1933, he announced a new substance that yeast needed to grow. It turned up in almost every food he tested. He called it pantothenic acid, from the Greek pantothen, "from all sides", and his paper's title made the same boast, "a growth determinant of universal biological occurrence".4, 5

Grey rats

The animals showed what going without it does. In 1938 Agnes Fay Morgan, who ran home economics at the University of California, reported black rats whose fur went grey on a diet short of B vitamins. Copper did nothing, though it cured an older kind of greying in rats. Her group found that dogs and silver foxes went grey on such a diet too.6, 7

In 1940, once the vitamin could be made in the laboratory, Paul György and C. E. Poling cured grey rats with it.4, 6

Others fed black and piebald rats a diet with everything but pantothenic acid. In three to seven weeks their fur went grey, scant and coarse. Their noses grew inflamed, their whiskers caked with a red crust that looked like blood, and their adrenal glands bled. Given the vitamin, the grey rats turned black again within a month.6

Pigs kept without it stamped and pranced in a gait like a goose step. In several species animals died suddenly, often as their adrenal glands bled.8

The anti-grey-hair vitamin

In September 1941 Science News Letter ran the headline "Anti-Gray Hair Vitamin Succeeds in Human Subjects". It was not pantothenic acid but para-aminobenzoic acid, then one of the newest B vitamins, and it had brought "a marked darkening" to the grey hair of thirty people.9

In January 1942 the Journal of the American Medical Association pointed out that "confirmatory reports (of the clinical work) by qualified investigators have not yet appeared". Science News Letter reported that the editorial's writer thought pantothenic acid, which cured greying in animals, had the better claim to be "the anti-gray hair vitamin, if there is such a vitamin".10

The shops did not wait. In April 1943 Time reported that at least a fourth of all retail drug sales were synthetic vitamins or vitamin concentrates, and that pantothenic acid was "popular as a possible preventive of grey hair".11

In September 1944 the American Beauty Products Company of Chicago sent thirty-nine and a half dozen bottles of calcium pantothenate tablets to Denver, with a hundred copies of its catalogue. "Anti-Gray Hair and Nail Vitamins," it announced. "Now you can sell Calcium Pantothenate Vitamins to your patrons." It promised that Good Housekeeping tests had shown an "88% return of hair color".12

The United States took the bottles themselves to court, in United States v. 39½ Dozen Bottles of Calcium Pantothenate Tablets and 100 Booklets. They called the claims false and misleading because the tablets were "not of value" for what the catalogue promised. No owner came forward to defend them. In February 1945 the court ordered the bottles and the catalogues destroyed.12

Eighty years later a supplement shop's blog offers "4 Proven Calcium Pantothenate Benefits for Hair Growth & Color". Further down, it admits there is "no concrete scientific proof" that the vitamin prevents or reverses grey hair.13

In every organ

Boston, the 1940s. Fritz Lipmann, a German-born biochemist at the Massachusetts General Hospital, was studying how living cells fix a small chemical tag, an acetyl group, onto drugs and other molecules. He used pigeon liver, which did it fast.14

His extracts kept losing a second ingredient the reaction needed, one that survived boiling but vanished as they aged. He found it in boiled extracts of every organ, in microbes and in yeast, and nothing known could stand in for it.14

His team purified it from pig liver and asked Williams's laboratory for help. There Beverly Guirard at first found almost none of the known vitamins. Then she noticed that the longer the sample sat with digesting enzymes, the more pantothenic acid her test picked up. The vitamin was locked inside. When she broke the sample down with acid, about a ninth of it turned out to be pantothenic acid.14

Lipmann called it "a most exciting event for our group". The missing ingredient was coenzyme A, and the vitamin was built into it. In 1953 the find won him a share of the Nobel Prize.4, 14

His team went on to find coenzyme A in every living cell they tested, in animals, plants and microbes. That was why the vitamin was everywhere.14

Ping-pong in Iowa

Gopalan's patients were short of riboflavin too. To learn what people suffer without this one alone, doctors had to take it away, and it was in nearly every food. By 1958 Robert Hodges, William Bean and Margaret Ohlson had spent seven years on it at the State University of Iowa.1, 8, 15

Their volunteers came from the Anamosa State Reformatory. It is a stone prison with crenellated towers, begun by prisoners in the 1870s, that looks like a medieval fortress.8, 16

In one test six healthy men were fed through a stomach tube for fifteen weeks. Earlier tests had used a predigested formula, foul-smelling and very disagreeable even by tube. This time it was forced down under pressure instead. Each man also had black coffee, two bottles of cola and a ration of hard sweets a day. Close care and games kept them going, ping-pong among them.8

Two got a diet without pantothenic acid. Two got the same diet with a drug that blocks it. Two got the vitamin. None of them knew his diet was any different from the others'.8

As the weeks went on, the two on the blocker turned irritable, restless and quarrelsome, swinging between drowsiness and sleeplessness. They came back from their daily walk exhausted and broke into heavy sweats at the slightest thing, or none at all. Then the two on the bare diet began to feel the same. The two on the blocker often woke with numb hands.8

All four ended up staggering, and their ping-pong went to pieces. Often they refused their walk and lay in bed all day. One man's soles burned for a few days, the way the feet had burned in Madras.8

When the vitamin went back in, the numbness and weakness eased, but the tiredness and some irritability stayed.8

They had reported in 1954 that people needed it. Writing up a later test on four more prison volunteers in 1959, they put it without a "probably". "Our subjects were ill as a result of pantothenic acid deficiency."15

A detective story

In 1995 Lit-Hung Leung, a surgeon at the Hong Kong Central Hospital, offered "a radically different theory" of acne. He blamed a lack of pantothenic acid, "a vitamin hitherto not known to cause any deficiency syndrome in humans". By then the burning feet of Madras and the sick men of Anamosa had been in medical journals for decades.1, 8, 17

Two years later he set out his case at length. Reading the research on acne gave "the impression of reading a detective story", with a victim, clues and suspects, but no culprit. Leung's culprit was a shortage of pantothenic acid.18

To pick an amount he took as his guide the huge doses of vitamin C that Linus Pauling had long urged. A hundred patients of Chinese descent, aged ten to thirty, took enormous amounts by mouth and rubbed a cream of it on their skin.18

He called the response "as prompt as it is impressive", with moderate cases under "complete control in about 8 weeks". No one in his report was left untreated for comparison.18

In 2014 a team in New York pitted a pantothenic-acid-based supplement against dummy pills in 48 people with mild to moderate acne. After twelve weeks the supplement group had fewer spots, and the authors asked for more trials.19

In 2020 the health website Healthline named Leung as "one of the first people to question whether pantothenic acid could help with acne". It noted the snag, that deficiency "is extremely rare in people because this essential nutrient is found in most foods", and that its very name means "from everywhere". Then it called the results so far "promising".20

From everywhere

Today pantothenic acid deficiency is so rare that no country requires it to be added to food. What studies in people found for thinking, mood, sleep and energy is in the Research tab.4

In 1958 Gopalan's laboratory moved down from the hills to Hyderabad, and he went on to run it. Back in 1946 the Indian Medical Gazette's editor had added a note to his paper. Years before, he had seen many cases of burning feet in Hyderabad, "for which there was then no explanation and no treatment".1, 2, 21

Doctors also call it Grierson-Gopalan syndrome, after him and James Grierson, a British medical officer who described it in 1826.2

Williams named his vitamin for being everywhere. In the burning feet of Madras, Gopalan had probably found the people it missed.

See what modern trials found

Myths and facts

In the record, or legend?

Every story you will read about this vitamin, checked against the oldest source we could find.

  • Pantothenic means "from everywhere"

    In the record

    Williams took the name from the Greek pantothen, "from all sides", for a substance he found in almost every food he tested4, 5

  • Burning feet in South India came from too little vitamin B5

    Likely

    Yeast extract and calcium pantothenate injections ended the burning in all the patients given them, while thiamine, niacin and riboflavin did not. He wrote "probably". There was no untreated comparison group, and nearly all his patients also showed signs of low riboflavin. Gopalan noted that the yeast extract held far less of the vitamin than the injections seemed to need, and put its success down to the B vitamins working together1

  • Grey rats turned black again on vitamin B5

    In the record

    Rats fed a diet without it went grey in three to seven weeks and got their colour back within a month once it was added. Some laboratories could not repeat it. This page read the 1942 summary of these studies, not the original papers6

  • Vitamin B5 brings back the colour of grey hair

    Legend

    Shown only in animals. The 1941 reports in people were for a rival vitamin, and in 1942 JAMA said they were still unconfirmed. US courts ordered "anti-gray hair" tablets destroyed in 1944 and 1945 when no one came forward to defend the claims, and the marketing went on "despite the lack of any human trial evidence"4, 9, 10, 12

  • Good Housekeeping tests showed 88% got their hair colour back

    Told, not shown

    The figure comes from a seller's catalogue, quoted in the FDA's notice of the February 1945 judgment. No Good Housekeeping report was found for this page12

  • Prisoners volunteered for the 1950s deficiency tests

    In the record

    The papers thank "the volunteers from Anamosa State Reformatory" and its warden, and none of the six knew which diet he was on. They do not say what, if anything, the men were offered8, 15

  • Large amounts of vitamin B5 clear acne

    Told, not shown

    Leung's 1997 report on a hundred patients had no comparison group. A 2014 placebo trial of a commercial pantothenic-acid-based supplement in 48 people, 41 of them assessed, reported fewer spots after twelve weeks. Its authors noted that milder spots "may resolve on their own by chance" and called for more trials. The Research tab does not cover skin18, 19

In the record means a source from the time, or a scholar quoting one, says it. Likely means a named expert's reasoned identification. Told, not shown means one interested party says it and nothing checks it. Partly means a real event sits under a bigger story. Legend means the earliest source is far too late or missing. Wrong date means the event is real but the popular date doesn't match the record.

Notes

Every fact in the story points to one of these. Where a translation is ours, the note says so.

Show all 21 notes Hide the notes
  1. C. Gopalan, "The 'burning-feet' syndrome", Indian Medical Gazette 81 (January 1946), pp. 22-26, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5236161/ (PMID 21025573; PMC may show a bot check). Gopalan signs as "Clinical Research Assistant, Nutrition Research Laboratories, Coonoor (From the Nutrition Clinic and the Research Ward, Government Stanley Hospital and the Nutrition Research Laboratories, Coonoor)"; the Stanley Hospital was in Madras (his acknowledgments thank the "Surgeon-General, Madras"). P. 22: the condition "appears to be common among the poor in South India"; "Outbreaks of 'burning feet' have previously been reported among malnourished populations and have often occurred in jails." "Only 8 cases in the series of 53 cases investigated had monthly incomes per family of over Rs. 50"; "All the patients were rice-eaters, mostly living on rice gruel and cheap vegetables"; "the present series included 39 females and 14 males"; "A history of delivery, a few weeks prior to the development of the symptoms, was given by 27 of the 39 female patients". "A burning sensation in the extremities is the characteristic feature of these cases, and it is to obtain relief from this that the patient comes to the hospital ... patients describe their complaint by the Tamil words 'Kal erichal' which literally mean burning of the feet." "The sensation of burning starts in the soles of the feet round about the ball of the great toe and seems to spread therefrom to involve the soles completely ... The burning may be quite mild and tolerable, but is frequently most intense and incapacitating. It may come on in paroxysms, the patient having excruciating agony for a short period" (p. 23) "and then remaining free from the symptom for the rest of the day. Some patients seem to obtain relief by wrapping their feet in a wet cloth. Others find the contact of their feet with cold or hot objects intolerable and prefer to leave their feet alone." "The feet feel sore when brought into contact with hard ground, and consequently the patient may be bed-ridden most of the time." "An interesting feature observed in several cases is hyperidrosis of the affected parts, visible beads of perspiration may stand out, and the feet may be moist to the touch", limited to where the burning is felt. Treatment (p. 23): "The response of the cases to intensive treatment with vegemite (marmite substitute) was first studied ... Definite improvement was obtained in all the 13 cases"; "The next step was to attempt to discover the factor in marmite responsible for the curative effect." Thiamine by injection in a group of 10: "No improvement was obtained in any of these cases." Nicotinic acid (niacin) in 8: "equally ineffective". Riboflavin in 12: "rapid subsidence of the associated signs, glossitis, angular stomatitis, ocular symptoms, etc., but the burning sensation continued with unabated severity; indeed a few patients reported that this was worse at the end of treatment." Calcium pantothenate "injected intramuscularly": "Definite improvement was obtained in all the ten cases. The improvement was more striking and rapid than that obtained with vegemite ... The burning sensation was the first symptom to disappear under the treatment." P. 24: "The striking improvement obtained with calcium pantothenate suggests that the disorder is probably the result of deficiency of pantothenic acid in the diet and that the improvement obtained with marmite is due to its pantothenic acid content." Some patients in each group were treated as outpatients on their usual diet, to rule out the hospital diet as the cause (Table I note). There was no untreated group. Signs of riboflavin deficiency: "Only 5 of the 53 cases reported on here did not show signs suggestive of ariboflavinosis" (p. 22). Gopalan also cites Peraita's 1942 report of a similar syndrome among famine victims of the Spanish civil war (p. 24). The editor's note (p. 26): "From personal experience the editor can record the very common occurrence of 'burning feet' in Hyderabad, Deccan, where years ago he saw many such cases for which there was then no explanation and no treatment." The paper gives no dates for the cases; it was printed in January 1946, so they were seen before then, hence "the mid-1940s". P. 24 adds that the yeast extract probably supplied "a quantity much less than that apparently needed when pantothenic acid was given alone", and that its good results "probably resulted from the mutual potentiation of action of the closely interrelated vitamins of the B2 complex"; "a combination of riboflavin and pantothenic acid is likely to yield better results than pantothenic acid alone". "Outbreaks of 'burning feet' have previously been reported among malnourished populations and have often occurred in jails" (p. 22). Yeast extract here is the paper's "vegemite (marmite substitute)". ↩
  2. Wikipedia, "Coluthur Gopalan", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coluthur_Gopalan : born 29 November 1918 in Salem, Madras Presidency (so 27 when the paper was printed in January 1946), died 3 October 2019; "The Bengal Famine of 1942 deeply impacted him and he turned to nutritional research"; "In the late 1950s, when the Nutrition Research Laboratory moved to Hyderabad and turned to the National Institute of Nutrition, Gopalan took over as director"; "While the condition was described in 1826 by a British medical officer James Grierson, Gopalan also described this condition in 1946"; "The burning feet syndrome is also known as Grierson-Gopalan syndrome" (an alternative name beside "burning feet syndrome"). Also Wikipedia, "Burning feet syndrome", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burning_feet_syndrome ("also known as Grierson–Gopalan syndrome"). Grierson's 1826 paper ("On the burning feet of natives", Transactions of the Medical and Physical Society of Calcutta 2) and the Royal Society memoir of Gopalan (doi 10.1098/rsbm.2021.0022) were not read for this page. ↩
  3. Wikipedia, "Coonoor", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coonoor : "a taluk and a municipal town of the Nilgiris District in the Indian state of Tamil Nadu ... 19 km from Ooty, the district headquarters"; "Coonoor is one of the principal hill stations of then Madras Presidency, second only to Ooty". Williams's birthplace, Ootacamund, is the same town as Ooty (Wikipedia, "Roger J. Williams", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roger_J._Williams , birth place "Ootacamund, Nilgiris District, Madras Presidency"). Wikipedia gives "12 miles (19 km) from Ooty". ↩
  4. Wikipedia, "Pantothenic acid", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantothenic_acid : "Pantothenic acid (vitamin B5) is a B vitamin and an essential nutrient"; "Calcium pantothenate – a salt – may be used in manufacturing because it is more resistant than pantothenic acid to factors that deteriorate stability"; "Williams went on to determine the chemical structure in 1940." "Its name comes from the Greek πάντοθεν pantothen, meaning 'from everywhere', because pantothenic acid, at least in small amounts, is in almost all foods"; "Williams dubbed the compound 'pantothenic acid', deriving the name from the Greek word pantothen, which translates as 'from everywhere'. His reason was that he found it to be present in almost every food he tested." "All animals need pantothenic acid in order to synthesize coenzyme A (CoA), which is essential for cellular energy production and for the synthesis and degradation of proteins, carbohydrates, and fats." "When found in foods, most pantothenic acid is in the form of CoA or bound to acyl carrier protein (ACP)." "In rodents, there can be loss of hair color, which led to marketing of pantothenic acid as a dietary supplement which could prevent or treat graying of hair in humans (despite the lack of any human trial evidence)." "According to the Global Fortification Data Exchange, pantothenic acid deficiency is so rare that no countries require that foods be fortified." The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1953 was divided between Hans Krebs, "for his discovery of the citric acid cycle", and Fritz Lipmann, "for his discovery of co-enzyme A and its importance for intermediary metabolism": https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1953/summary/ . The Research tab covers studies in people on thinking, memory, mood, stress, sleep, energy, tiredness and quality of life, not skin or hair. ↩
  5. D. R. Davis, M. L. Hackert and L. J. Reed, "Roger John Williams, August 14, 1893-February 20, 1988", Biographical Memoirs (Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences, 2008), https://www.nasonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/williams-roger.pdf (the site may show a bot check). Williams was born "in Ootacumund, India, as the youngest of six children of American missionary parents. His parents brought him to the United States at two years of age by ship across the Pacific." "It was discovered later that he had severe aniseikonia, an eye condition that caused eyestrain whenever he read for more than a short time. Aniseikonia was unknown until about 1930. His condition was corrected with only moderate success by special glasses in 1941, but by that time he was already nearly 50 years old. Rather than feel sorry about his condition, Roger would state that his affliction gave him more time to think when others might be reading." His oldest brother "Robert, who was eight years older than Roger, saw firsthand the effect of nutritional deficiency diseases while growing up in India. In 1910 ... Robert learned that a syrup made from rice polishings could cure beriberi. Twenty-six years later Robert isolated and synthesized vitamin B1, which he named thiamine." Ph.D. Chicago 1919, thesis "The Vitamine Requirement of Yeast" (the bibliography's 1919 paper is "The vitamine requirement of yeasts"); assistant professor at the University of Oregon from 1920; "From 1932 to 1939 he was a professor at Oregon State College. During his time in Oregon, he discovered and characterized pantothenic acid ... Patents on its synthesis were given to Research Corporation. Royalties amounted to many hundreds of thousands of dollars per year, a substantial portion of which was ploughed back into scientific research each year." "He pursued his research with yeast despite attempts by outstanding biochemists of that period to persuade him to work with animals. This persistence led to his discovery of the yeast growth factor, pantothenic acid, which he announced in 1933, and led to the subsequent acceptance of this compound as an essential cog in the biochemical machinery of all cells and as a vitamin for many species." "He had named his new vitamin pantothenic acid (Greek pantothen, from all sides). He continued with folic acid, the vitamin isolated from spinach leaves (Latin folium, leaf), and avidin, the egg-white protein that tenaciously binds to biotin (Latin avidus, to covet)." In 1939 he moved to the University of Texas at Austin, where he founded the Biochemical Institute in 1940. The memoir's bibliography lists R. J. Williams, C. M. Lyman, G. H. Goodyear, J. H. Truesdail and D. Holaday, "Pantothenic acid, a growth determinant of universal biological occurrence", Journal of the American Chemical Society 55 (1933), pp. 2912-2927, which was not read in full for this page. The memoir spells the town "Ootacumund"; it is now Ooty (Udhagamandalam). The memoir dates the discovery only to "his time in Oregon"; Wikipedia ("Roger J. Williams") places it in his years at the University of Oregon (1920-32). The 1933 announcement falls in his Oregon State years. ↩
  6. J. K. Woods, "A comparison of various diets in the study of achromotrichia and growth of rats", MS thesis, Kansas State College of Agriculture and Applied Science, 1942, https://archive.org/details/comparisonofvari00wood , review of earlier work. Woods does not describe Morgan's diet; his ref. 30 is A. F. Morgan, B. B. Cook and H. G. Davison, "Vitamin B2 deficiencies as affected by dietary carbohydrate", Journal of Nutrition (1938), pp. 27-43, not read for this page. P. 2: "Grey hair was observed in rats fed on a bread and whole milk diet as early as 1923. It was later shown by Gorter that this type of greyness was due to a deficiency of copper in the diet. In 1938, Morgan et al (30) reported a greying of black rats in which copper had no curative effect." P. 4: "In 1938, Williams et al separated pantothenic acid, a yeast growth factor, from liver. Jukes (20) and Woolley, Waisman, and Elvehjem (52), working with samples furnished by Williams, found it to be identical with the filtrate (chick antidermatitis) factor." P. 5: "In 1938 ... Morgan, Cook, and Davison (30) reported greying in ... black rats"; Morgan and Simms (31, Journal of Nutrition, 1939) "also found that dogs and silver foxes became grey on the filtrate factor free diet." Pp. 5-6: earlier reports doubting pantothenic acid "were made by several workers before pure pantothenic acid was available ... Gyorgy and Poling (15) found synthetic pantothenic acid to have a curative action". P. 6: "Unna, Richards, and Sampson (45) fed black and piebald rats on a diet adequate except for the absence of pantothenic acid. They observed greying of the fur in three to seven weeks along with retardation of growth, the appearance of scant coarse fur, inflammation of the nose, 'blood-caked' whiskers, and adrenal hemmorrhages. Development of the achromotrichia and other lesions in normal rats was prevented by the addition of [calcium pantothenate]. It restored, within three to four weeks, the black pigmentation to the rats which had become grey." P. 7: "McElroy et al (26) found the red deposit around the nose and on the whiskers of pantothenic acid deficient rats to be coproporphyrin from the Harderian gland and not blood as it had been previously believed." "Not all workers have been able to maintain complete fur color through the use of pure Ca pantothenate. Williams (47) reported the failure of either pantothenic acid concentrate or synthetic Ca pantothenate to prevent or cure rat achromotrichia." Woods's ref. 47 is R. R. Williams, "Inefficacy of pantothenic acid against the graying of fur", Science 92 (1940), pp. 561-562, not Roger J. Williams (his ref. 48). The thesis also notes conflicting reports (p. 3). P. György and C. E. Poling, "Pantothenic acid and nutritional achromotrichia in rats", Science 92 (1940), pp. 202-203, https://doi.org/10.1126/science.92.2383.202 (the site may show a bot check), was not read in full for this page. Page numbers are the thesis's printed numbers. ↩
  7. Wikipedia, "Agnes Fay Morgan", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agnes_Fay_Morgan : "She was the longtime chair of the home economics program at the University of California"; "Morgan's lab conducted significant research into the nutritional composition of foods and the biochemistry of vitamins, especially pantothenic acid (vitamin B5)." ↩
  8. R. E. Hodges, M. A. Ohlson and W. B. Bean, "Pantothenic acid deficiency in man", Journal of Clinical Investigation 37 (1958), pp. 1642-1657, https://www.jci.org/articles/view/103756 (free mirror https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1062846/ ). From the Metabolism Section, Department of Medicine, State University of Iowa, Iowa City. P. 1642: "For the past seven years we have been studying the role of pantothenic acid in human nutrition" (so from about 1951); in animals "Strange variations occur in the color of the fur ... In swine a peculiar neuropathy causes queer stamping and a prancing gait resembling a goose step ... Sudden death has been noted in several species, often precipitated by hemorrhagic destruction of the adrenal glands." P. 1643: "We selected six healthy men"; none "was aware that his regimen differed in any way from that of the other five subjects". Pp. 1643-1644: "Previously we had digested the casein with pancreatin in order to get it to go through the gastric tube. The resulting acid mixture had a foul odor and was very disagreeable even when taken by stomach tube ... In the present study, a pressure system was devised to force the mixture through the tube. This obviated the need for pancreatin and sodium bicarbonate." P. 1644: one pair got "the basic diet devoid of pantothenic acid", one pair the same diet plus omega-methyl pantothenic acid (the "antagonist pair"), and the "control pair" the diet with pantothenic acid added; "Formerly we had found that 10 weeks was the longest period that the subjects could be kept on the experimental regimen of tube feeding. In this study it was possible to tube feed them for 15 weeks, largely because of very close personal care of the subjects, by having better recreational activities, and by the devoted cooperation of the nurses and attendants on the metabolic ward, not to mention the willingness of the subjects to continue a very difficult program." "Each subject received his 'food' by stomach tube at 11:30 a.m. and at 5:30 p.m. ... Each subject had six cups of black coffee, two bottles of Coca Cola®, and 100 Gm. of hard candy daily." P. 1645: "the antagonist pair developed serious personality changes with irritability, restlessness, quarrelsomeness; and alternate periods of somnolence and insomia ... They began to complain of excessive fatigue after their daily walk. They would break out in a profuse sweat after trifling provocation or none at all. A little later the two men in the deficient group began to note similar complaints ... All four men had a staggering gait and showed deterioration of their skill at pingpong. Frequently they refused to go for their daily walks, preferring to lie in bed all day." "One subject developed paresthesias and 'burning' of the soles of his feet which lasted only a few days and subsided spontaneously during the same phase of the test. Numbness of the hands, most distressing in the morning before arising, was fairly frequent in the two subjects receiving the antagonist." Pp. 1650-1651: "Administration of pantothenic acid was followed by improvement of the paresthesias and muscle weakness, but fatigue and some degree of irritability persisted." P. 1656: "The authors wish to thank the volunteers from Anamosa State Reformatory, the Warden, Mr. Ray Purcell, and the Chairman of the Board of Control, Mr. Robert C. Lappen". The study was funded by the National Institutes of Health, with help from the National Vitamin Foundation, the Nutrition Foundation, Eli Lilly and Burroughs Wellcome (p. 1642). The paper gives the men's ages as 19 to 35 (p. 1643). The paper does not say what the volunteers were offered. ↩
  9. "Anti-Gray Hair Vitamin Succeeds in Human Subjects: 'Cure' of 30 Patients With Para-Aminobenzoic Acid Announced in Report to American Chemical Society", Science News Letter 40 (20 September 1941), p. 179, https://www.sciencenews.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/1941/09/00964018.ap071156.07a00020.pdf (JSTOR scan): "'A marked darkening' of previously gray hair and growth of 'new natural colored hairs' in 30 human beings has been achieved by small daily doses of one of the newest of the vitamin B group, para-aminobenzoic acid, Dr. Gustav J. Martin, of the Warner Institute for Therapeutic Research, and S. Ansbacher, of the research laboratory of the International Vitamin Corporation, New York City, announced at the meeting of the American Chemical Society at Atlantic City"; the patients were treated "under the direction of Dr. Benjamin F. Sieve, of Boston City Hospital". The report gives "cure" in quotation marks. ↩
  10. "Scientists Still Uncertain Whether Vitamins Darken Hair", Science News Letter 41 (31 January 1942), pp. 68-69, https://www.sciencenews.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/1942/01/00964018.ap070273.07a00070.pdf (JSTOR scan), on an editorial in the Journal of the American Medical Association of 24 January 1942. P. 68: "Medical scientists and nutritionists are still uncertain whether vitamins will darken gray hair, and if so, which vitamin is the true anti-gray hair remedy". Pp. 68-69: "'Confirmatory reports (of the clinical work) by qualified investigators have not yet appeared,' states the Journal." The clinical work is the para-aminobenzoic acid reports by Dr. B. F. Sieve (p. 68). P. 69: "Lack of a different vitamin, pantothenic acid, causes graying in animals which can be cured by doses of this vitamin but not of para-aminobenzoic acid, according to reports from two different groups of scientists"; "The evidence is stronger for pantothenic acid being the anti-gray hair vitamin, if there is such a vitamin, than for para-aminobenzoic acid, in the opinion of the writer of the Journal's editorial." The last quote is the Science News Letter's wording, not the editorial's, which was not read for this page. ↩
  11. "Science: Vitamin Bandwagon", Time, 26 April 1943, https://content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,802710,00.html : "From the meeting of the National Wholesale Druggists Association in Chicago last week came an astonishing fact: at least a fourth of all retail drug sales are synthetic vitamins or vitamin concentrates"; "Pantothenic acid is popular as a possible preventive of grey hair." ↩
  12. US Food and Drug Administration, Notices of Judgment under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, Foods, No. 8499 (issued June 1946), "Misbranding of American Calcium Pantothenate Tablets. U. S. v. 39½ Dozen Bottles of Calcium Pantothenate Tablets and 100 Booklets. Default decree of condemnation and destruction", National Library of Medicine, https://collections.nlm.nih.gov/ocr/nlm:fdanjid-ffnj08499-case : "LIBEL FILED: December 12, 1944, District of Colorado. ALLEGED SHIPMENT: On or about September 6, 1944, by the American Beauty Products Co., from Chicago, Ill. PRODUCT: 39½ dozen bottles ... of calcium pantothenate tablets, and 100 copies of an accompanying booklet entitled 'City Catalog No. 80,' at Denver, Colo." Statements "in the booklets were false and misleading, since the article was not of value in the conditions suggested or implied by the statements: 'Anti-Gray Hair and Nail Vitamins (Calcium-Pantothenate-Dextrotrotatory) Now you can sell Calcium Pantothenate Vitamins to your patrons. Good Housekeeping Bureau experiments of 16 months showed that 88 percent of men and women subjected to the tests showed positive evidence of a return of natural hair color ... For Gray Hair * Newest Vitamin Discovery. Good Housekeeping tests showed 88% return of hair color.'" "DISPOSITION: February 21, 1945. No claimant having appeared, judgment of condemnation was entered and the product and booklets were ordered destroyed." The notice's "booklet" is the catalogue in the story. It was not the only case: in January 1944 calcium pantothenate tablets shipped from Seattle by Adolphus Hohensee were seized in Los Angeles because label claims on "preventing and correcting premature graying of the hair were false and misleading since the article would have no effect on the color of gray hair" (Notice of Judgment, Drugs and Devices, No. 1357, issued April 1946, https://collections.nlm.nih.gov/ocr/nlm:fdanjid-ddnj01357-case ), and the court ordered them destroyed in April 1944. ↩
  13. "4 Proven Calcium Pantothenate Benefits for Hair Growth & Color", a supplement seller's blog, 31 March 2025, https://my.nanosingaporeshop.com/blogs/wellbeing/calcium-pantothenate-benefits-stop-gray-hair (read 16 November 2026; no archive copy could be made from here): "There is no concrete scientific proof that calcium pantothenate benefits directly prevents or reverses gray hair." The page also mentions, without a date or a link, "a study involving two girls with premature graying of hair", which was not traced for this page. ↩
  14. F. Lipmann, "Development of the acetylation problem: a personal account", Nobel Lecture, 11 December 1953, https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/lipmann-lecture.pdf , pp. 417-424. P. 417: acetylation was chosen as a test because "any results obtained with this method could be generalized over the whole metabolic territory concerning the transfer of active acetate including such reactions as citrate, acetoacetate and lipid synthesis"; acetylation of sulfonamide was studied in pigeon liver, which was "found to harbour an exceedingly potent acetylation system". P. 418: "we became aware of the participation of a heat-stable factor which disappeared from our enzyme extracts on aging or dialysis. This co-factor was present in boiled extracts of all organs, as well as in micro-organisms and yeast. It could not be replaced by any other known cofactor. Therefore, it was suspected that we were dealing with a new coenzyme." P. 420: "Finding pig liver a good source for the coenzyme, we set out to collect a reasonably large quantity of a highly purified preparation ... In this task we were very fortunate to have the help of the great experience of Dr. Roger Williams' laboratory. Dr. Beverly Guirard, who occupied herself with this preparation, at first seemed not to find any appreciable amounts of the known vitamins. However, she became aware of the fact that on prolonged enzymatic treatment, the value of pantothenic acid, as determined microbiologically, did slightly increase. This gave the hint that the coenzyme may not release the pantothenic acid so easily ... In confirmation, she found on acid hydrolysis of the coenzyme, considerable amounts of [beta-alanine] corresponding to 11 per cent of pantothenic acid in this preparation which, as we now know, was 40 per cent pure." "The appearance of a B-vitamin in the preparation was of course a most exciting event for our group". Pp. 423-424: "CoA was found present in all living cells, animals, plants and microorganisms. Furthermore, the finding that all cellular pantothenic acid could be accounted for by CoA made it clear that CoA represented the only functional form of this vitamin." (Later work found some bound to acyl carrier protein too; note 4.) The joint paper is F. Lipmann, N. O. Kaplan, G. D. Novelli, L. C. Tuttle and B. M. Guirard, Journal of Biological Chemistry 167 (1947), p. 869. A ninth is the story's rounding of 11 per cent. Lipmann was born in Koenigsberg, studied in Germany, worked in Copenhagen from 1932 and moved to the United States in 1939; "in 1941 [he] joined the research staff of the Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston": Nobel biography, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1953/lipmann/biographical/ . ↩
  15. R. E. Hodges, W. B. Bean, M. A. Ohlson and Roberta Bleiler, "Human pantothenic acid deficiency produced by omega-methyl pantothenic acid", Journal of Clinical Investigation 38 (1959), pp. 1421-1425, https://doi.org/10.1172/JCI103918 (free mirror https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC442097/ ). P. 1421 (Introduction, summing up the team's earlier studies): "Its importance in human nutrition remained long in doubt, however, because of its presence in nearly all foods eaten by man. In 1954 we reported that pantothenic acid was essential in human nutrition"; "This study and subsequent ones demonstrated that young men fed a purified, partly synthetic diet deficient in pantothenic acid, became ill after about 12 weeks (1, 2). By adding omega-methyl pantothenic acid to the deficient diet, we were able to induce illness in about four weeks (3-5) ... Whatever the mechanism, our subjects were ill as a result of pantothenic acid deficiency. Most recovered promptly when large doses of this vitamin were given." "Four healthy young men were selected from prison volunteers. They ranged in age from 22 to 29." The acknowledgments thank the "volunteers and Warden Ray Purcell of the State Reformatory at Anamosa, Iowa". ↩
  16. Wikipedia, "Anamosa State Penitentiary", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anamosa_State_Penitentiary : commissioned in 1872; "a quarry from which to obtain the building stone, forced-labour for the construction process was imported in the Spring of 1873 in the form of 20 prisoners from Fort Madison"; the building has "massive outer walls and crenelated towers that give it the appearance of a medieval fortress"; in operation from 1874; the infobox gives "built 1875-1899", so the prisoners began it and later work went on for decades. In the 1950s papers it is the Anamosa State Reformatory. ↩
  17. L. H. Leung, "Pantothenic acid deficiency as the pathogenesis of acne vulgaris", Medical Hypotheses 44 (1995), pp. 490-492, https://doi.org/10.1016/0306-9877(95)90512-x (PubMed abstract https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7476595/ ). Department of General Surgery, Hong Kong Central Hospital. Abstract: "Here, I wish to suggest a radically different theory for its pathogenesis and relate its basic pathology to a deficiency in pantothenic acid, a vitamin hitherto not known to cause any deficiency syndrome in humans ... A complete cure of this condition is effected by a very liberal replacement therapy with the vitamin." Only the abstract was read; PubMed indexes the paper as a "Controlled Clinical Trial", which this page could not check. His first name is from note 20. ↩
  18. L.-H. Leung, "A stone that kills two birds: how pantothenic acid unveils the mysteries of acne vulgaris and obesity", Journal of Orthomolecular Medicine 12 (1997), pp. 99-114, http://orthomolecular.org/library/jom/1997/pdf/1997-v12n02-p099.pdf . P. 99: "In reviewing the numerous studies that deal with the pathogenesis of acne vulgaris, and one gets the impression of reading a detective story. There is the victim. The facts are all there. There are all the clues, as well as the suspects. But the culprit cannot be identified." P. 105: "For decades, the medical profession has tied their hands with a fiction of their own device. They held, contrary to the facts, that nutritional requirements can be met through a well balanced diet, and that dietary supplements, including vitamins, are not required." P. 106: "In trying to determine the actual amount of pantothenic acid necessary to relieve acne patients of their symptoms, Linus Pauling's experience with vitamin C provides a good guideline. Pauling had for a long time recommended vitamin C in high dosages"; "One hundred patients of Chinese descent were included in the study, 45 males and 55 females. The age ranged from 10-30"; patients were also "asked to apply a cream consisting of [pantothenic acid] to the affected area"; "With this treatment regimen, the response is as prompt as it is impressive"; "In cases with moderate severity, the condition is normally in complete control in about 8 weeks". The amounts are left out on purpose. The report describes no untreated or placebo group. ↩
  19. M. Yang, B. Moclair, V. Hatcher, J. Kaminetsky, M. Mekas, A. Chapas and J. Capodice, "A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of a novel pantothenic acid-based dietary supplement in subjects with mild to moderate facial acne", Dermatology and Therapy 4 (2014), pp. 93-101, https://doi.org/10.1007/s13555-014-0052-3 (free text https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4065280/ ). Manhattan Medical Research, New York; subjects were "recruited at 2 dermatology sites", which the paper does not name. The study ran for 12 weeks. "Forty-eight subjects were enrolled and 41 were evaluable. There was a significant mean reduction in total lesion count in the pantothenic acid group versus placebo at week 12"; "Further randomized, placebo-controlled trials are warranted." "Finally, there is always a possibility that milder, non-inflammatory lesions may resolve on their own by chance". The supplement was a commercial product, and its maker is not named here. ↩
  20. S. Kester, "Pantothenic Acid for Acne: Does It Work and How to Use", Healthline, 22 June 2020 (medically reviewed by Sara Perkins, MD), https://www.healthline.com/health/pantothenic-acid-for-acne-does-it-work-and-how-to-use : "Dr. Lit-Hung Leung was one of the first people to question whether pantothenic acid could help with acne. In 1997, he published a research paper in The Journal of Orthomolecular Medicine"; "there's one big problem with this theory: Vitamin B-5 deficiency is extremely rare in people because this essential nutrient is found in most foods. In fact, it's so widely available that even its name, 'pantothenic,' means 'from everywhere.'" "As of right now, there's limited research as to whether pantothenic acid can help with acne. One study, however, has shown positive results. The 8-week study ... found that taking a pantothenic acid-based dietary supplement significantly reduced blemishes"; "It may also help clear up acne. While more research needs to be done on this theory, the results so far have been promising." Healthline's "8-week study" appears to be the earlier feasibility study that the 2014 paper (note 19) mentions ("daily oral supplementation of a nutritional agent containing pantothenic acid for 8 weeks was feasible and safe"), not the 12-week trial. ↩
  21. Wikipedia, "National Institute of Nutrition, Hyderabad", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Institute_of_Nutrition,_Hyderabad : established "1918 (Coonoor), 1958 (Hyderabad)"; "The facility moved to Hyderabad in 1958 and in 1969 was renamed the National Institute of Nutrition"; "founded in 1918 by Sir Robert McCarrison. It was originally a single room laboratory at the Pasteur Institute, Coonoor, Tamil Nadu for the study of Beriberi, and was called the Beri-Beri Enquiry Unit." Gopalan became its director in the late 1950s (note 2). ↩