NR-042Ingredient Atlas entry · Vitamin

Vitamin D3

Cholecalciferol (D3) and ergocalciferol (D2)

Old women viewing London's dead, a Cambridge professor, an iron maker's wife, a missionary in Japan, a lamp in hungry Berlin and a patent in Wisconsin. Rickets puzzled doctors for three centuries, and in the last they argued whether a spoon of fish oil or the sun cured it. Both were right, and calling the cure a vitamin is only half true.

  • Found in: oily fish, eggs, fortified foods
  • Doses range from small daily amounts to large weekly or one-off doses
  • Often weeks to months long
Morning sun over a misty field and trees
Morning sun over a misty field and trees. Photo by Dietmar Rabich, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A new word in the bills

London, 1634. The weekly bills of the dead name a new disease.

When anyone in the city died, the bell tolled or a grave was ordered from the sexton, and word went to the searchers. They were "ancient Matrons, sworn to their Office". They went to the body, looked it over, asked questions and decided what had killed it. Every Tuesday night each parish clerk handed in the week's burials. On Wednesday the Bills of Mortality were printed, and on Thursday they went out to every family that paid four shillings a year.1

That year the searchers used a word no bill had used before, the rickets, for a disease that softened and bent children's bones. Fourteen people died of it.2

Nearly thirty years later Captain John Graunt read back through the old bills and asked whether rickets was a new disease, or an old one with a new name. Nothing in the earlier bills looked more like it than "liver-grown", and some years' bills even lumped the two together. So he added them up. In the early years liver-grown deaths held about level while the rickets came on top, so rickets was "a new Disease over and above".2 It was spreading fast. There were 190 deaths in 1649, 260 the next year, and 521 in 1660, and when Graunt published his findings in 1662 the rickets were "never more numerous than now", and "still increasing".2, 3

The keel of a ship

In 1645 a young Englishman named Daniel Whistler wrote his medical thesis at Leiden on "the Disease of English Children Which is Popularly Termed The Rickets". He offered a learned name for it, pædossplanchnosteocaces, and nobody took it up.4, 5

Five years later the College of Physicians in London put its name to a whole book, De rachitide. Seven other Fellows began it with Francis Glisson, Regius professor of physic at Cambridge. In the end the rest left him to weave the whole work alone, afraid that otherwise its parts would come out "deformed, misshapen and heterogeneous".6 It appeared in 1650 and in English a year later.

Glisson's team had opened the bodies of children who died of it. The head was bigger than normal and the face full, but the arms and legs were wasted, and the skin hung "loose like a Glove". The wrists and ankles swelled at the ends of the bones. The narrow chest came to a point "like the Keel of a Ship, or the breast of a Hen", and the ribs were knotted where they met the breastbone.7

As near as they could find out, the disease had first been noticed about thirty years before in Dorset and Somerset, in the west of England, and had spread from there to London, Oxford and Cambridge. In the northern counties it was hardly known.8 For a Latin name they set themselves rules. It had to be easy to say, easy to remember, and "of no undecent length". They chose rachitis, from the Greek for the spine, which sat close enough to the people's word.8 Across Europe it became "the English disease".6, 9

Rickets comes mainly from too little vitamin D, which the skin makes when sunlight falls on it.9, 10 Nobody in 1650 knew either half of that sentence.

A hogshead of fish oil

The first remedy turned up by accident, for another illness, and nowhere near the sea. At the Manchester Infirmary, the house surgeon Robert Darbey wrote in 1782, "an accidental circumstance" had shown that cod liver oil could ease chronic rheumatism. A woman was cured, fell ill again a year later "with double violence", and was cured again, so a physician tried it on others. By 1789 the infirmary was getting through nearly a hogshead of it a year.11

Manchester was a dim place to find it. In 1824 a local paper blamed the town's name for rain on its narrow streets. "The sun's rays seldom fall on its pavements."11

In 1824 too, a German doctor named Schütte published case notes on cod liver oil from Bergen, in Norway, which he said had been known only to the tanners. His first patient was the wife of an iron maker, Peter Wiebel, who had lost the use of her legs. Her husband brought the oil home from his travels, and after two weeks she walked again.12 Schütte also recorded that in 1814 a man named Friedrich Kraus had given it to his own two sons, aged five and three, for the English disease. Schütte guessed that the oil worked through tiny amounts of something no chemist could find.12

No rickets in Japan

Theobald Palm was born in Ceylon, trained as a doctor in Edinburgh, and went to Japan as a medical missionary. In ten years there, from 1875 in the port of Niigata and for a year in Tokyo, he never met a case of rickets. In 1884 he came back to practise in Wigton, in Cumberland, and met rickety children there.13

So Palm wrote to other missionaries. From China, Mongolia, India, Morocco and Ceylon the answer was the same, rickets was rare or unknown, although the children there lived among filth, bad water and dysentery. In Britain the disease filled the coal towns and the big cities, and in Glasgow it was everywhere, while the Highlands, farther north, hardly knew it.13 Palm could explain all of it only one way. In 1890 he urged sunbaths, and moving rickety children "as early as possible from large towns to a locality where sunshine abounds".13 A Polish doctor, Jędrzej Śniadecki, had said much the same in 1822. Both were largely ignored.13

Porridge and puppies

Edward Mellanby took the question into the laboratory. From the middle of the First World War he fed puppies on milk with oatmeal and rice and watched their bones.14 Over five years he dieted nearly four hundred of them, and in the early experiments, he admitted, "any puppy which could be procured was investigated".14 The puppies on his plain diets grew rickety. Cod liver oil cured them, and Mellanby decided that rickets came from a missing food factor that dissolved in fat, perhaps the one already named vitamin A.10, 14

At Johns Hopkins, Elmer McCollum tested that idea. He bubbled oxygen through cod liver oil until its vitamin A was gone, and the oil still cured rickets. In 1922 he gave the cure in the oil a letter of its own. It was the fourth vitamin, so it became vitamin D.15

A lamp in Berlin

Berlin, winter 1918. The British blockade had left German children hungry, and rickets was everywhere.13, 16 Kurt Huldschinsky, a children's doctor, sat rickety children under a quartz mercury-vapour lamp, an "artificial mountain sun" as his paper called it, and X-rayed their bones. They hardened. When he lit only one arm, both arms healed, so whatever the light made had to travel round the body.13, 16

In post-war Vienna, from 1919 to 1922, Harriette Chick's team from London found that cod liver oil cured rickety children, and so did summer sunlight and the lamp.10, 17 In New York in 1921 Alfred Hess cured babies with plain sunshine.18 The spoon and the sun did the same work.

Sunshine for sale

By 1924 Harry Steenbock, at the University of Wisconsin, was shining ultraviolet light on rats, on the air in their cages and on their food. Lit food cured rickety rats. Unlit rats got better too, if they ate a lit rat's droppings from the sawdust or licked the oils from its fur.10, 13

Steenbock spent three hundred dollars of his own to patent the process. In 1925 he and two of the university's deans set up the Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation to hold it, on a hundred dollars from each of nine alumni.19 Quaker Oats took the first licence in 1927 and put the vitamin in its breakfast cereal. Milk followed.19 In 1936 Schlitz sold "the beer with Sunshine Vitamin D", and told drinkers to "Drink it daily — for health with enjoyment."20

The licences made the foundation millions. Margarine, the cheap rival to butter and "one of the foods of the poor", got no licence from a foundation in a dairy state until the war. When the foundation sued a rival company for using its process, Steenbock was asked about it. "In general," he said, "we have been unsympathetic with those developments."21 In 1944 a federal appeals court threw the patents out. People had been making vitamin D for as long as there had been history, the judges wrote, every time they left cut hay to dry in the sun.21

The chemists caught up. Adolf Windaus in Göttingen won the 1928 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for work on sterols, the chemical family of cholesterol, and their link to vitamins. In 1937 he and his colleague Bock took the raw material that sunlight turns into vitamin D from the skin of pigs. Its product was vitamin D3, the form human skin makes.10, 22

Too much of a good thing

By the 1950s British babies were getting vitamin D in dried milk, in cereals and in cod liver oil. Some of them stopped eating, lost weight, vomited and grew constipated, with too much calcium in their blood. In Dundee alone, eighteen infants were treated in four years, and seventeen of them had been fed on fortified dried milk. Three of the eighteen died.23 Doctors then learned that makers had been adding the vitamin to dried milk and cereals "in amounts considerably in excess of the stated contents", to allow for losses on the shelf.23

In June 1957 an MP asked the Minister of Health about a report that "some infants are receiving unnecessarily large quantities of vitamin D".24 That December a minister told the House that from the next month the cod liver oil the government gave out through its Welfare Foods Service would carry half the vitamin.24

Why only some babies? Part of the answer came in 2011. Most children with the disorder carry a broken gene, CYP24A1, and cannot switch off the hormone the body makes from vitamin D.25

The vitamin that isn't

"Did you know that Vitamin D isn't actually a vitamin?" asked a supplement seller's blog in 2015, and answered that it "is considered a pro-hormone".26 Harvard Health Publishing agrees that it is "not technically a vitamin".27

The name was a guess made in a food laboratory. McCollum called it a vitamin in 1922 because it came out of cod liver oil, and in his day a vitamin was something the body had to eat.15 Fifteen years later Windaus made D3 by shining light on a substance from pig skin, and in time it was shown that human skin does the same in the sun.10, 22 Then laboratories in Wisconsin and Cambridge found what the body does with it. The liver changes it once and the kidney changes it again, into a hormone that runs the body's calcium. In 1971 Hector DeLuca's team identified that last form from 1,600 chick intestines, and Egon Kodicek's group in Cambridge called it "a new kidney hormone".10, 28

So the claim is half right. What the skin makes, or a spoon delivered, is not itself the hormone, only its starting point, which is what a pro-hormone is. But for children with no sun on their skin, from Manchester's narrow streets to Glasgow's, D was exactly what McCollum called it, a food they could not do without.11, 13

Sun on the pavements

In 1660 the searchers of London counted 521 deaths from rickets.2 The cure was there all along, twice over, in the livers of cod and in the sky above the narrow streets.

Your skin still makes D3 from sunlight, out of the same substance Windaus found in pig skin.10 What the modern trials of vitamin D on mood, sleep and thinking found is in the Research tab.

See what modern trials found

Myths and facts

In the record, or legend?

Every story you will read about this vitamin, checked against the oldest source we could find.

  • Rickets first appears in London's Bills of Mortality in 1634

    In the record

    Graunt counted 14 deaths in the 1634 bills and none in the bills from 1629, when causes were first listed, to 16332

  • Rickets began in Dorset and Somerset

    Told, not shown

    Glisson's committee reported it "as neer as we could gather from the Relation of others", about thirty years before 1650. Other writers found older traces abroad8, 6

  • Cod liver oil entered medicine as a cure for rickets

    Legend

    It came into the Manchester Infirmary for chronic rheumatism. Its first recorded use for rickets is a father's in 1814, reported in a German paper of 182411, 12

  • Sunlight's role in rickets was first seen by Theobald Palm in 1890

    Partly

    Palm gathered the evidence across countries, but Śniadecki had written about it in Poland in 182213

  • Light on one arm healed rickets in both arms

    In the record

    Huldschinsky's X-rays in Berlin, 191913

  • Steenbock's foundation refused to license vitamin D margarine

    In the record

    His own testimony, quoted in the 1944 appeals court opinion, which notes one wartime exception21

  • Vitamin D isn't really a vitamin, it is a pro-hormone

    Partly

    The skin makes it in sunlight and the kidney turns it into a hormone. For children without sun it had to come from food, which is how rickets was cured10, 15, 28

In the record means a source from the time, or a scholar quoting one, says it. Likely means a named expert's reasoned identification. Told, not shown means one interested party says it and nothing checks it. Partly means a real event sits under a bigger story. Legend means the earliest source is far too late or missing. Wrong date means the event is real but the popular date doesn't match the record.

Notes

Every fact in the story points to one of these. Where a translation is ours, the note says so.

Show all 28 notes Hide the notes
  1. John Graunt, Natural and Political Observations ... upon the Bills of Mortality (London, 1662), ch. 1 §§10-11 (pp. 16-17 of the fifth edition, 1676, which Hull reprints), in C. H. Hull (ed.), The Economic Writings of Sir William Petty, together with the Observations upon the Bills of Mortality (Cambridge, 1899), vol. 2, p. 346, https://archive.org/details/economicwritings02pett : "When any one dies, then, either by tolling, or ringing of a Bell, or by bespeaking of a Grave of the Sexton, the same is known to the Searchers, corresponding with the said Sexton. The Searchers hereupon (who are ancient Matrons, sworn to their Office) repair to the place where the dead Corps lies, and by view of the same, and by other enquiries, they examine by what Disease or Casualty the Corps died. Hereupon they make their Report to the Parish Clerk, and he, every Tuesday night, carries in an Accompt of all the Burials and Christnings happening that Week, to the Clerk of the Hall. On Wednesday the general Accompt is made up and printed, and on Thursday published and dispersed to the several Families who will pay four Shillings per Annum for them." Graunt describes the system of his own day. ↩
  2. Graunt, Observations, ch. 3 §§19-24 (pp. 35-36 of the 1676 edition), Hull ed. vol. 2, pp. 357-358: "of the Rickets we find no mention among the Casualties, until the Year 1634, and then but of 14 for that whole Year"; "the Question is, Whether that Disease did first appear about that time; or whether a Disease, which had been long before, did then first receive its Name"; he found "that Livergrown was the nearest. For in some years I find Livergrown, Spleen, and Rickets, put all together, by reason (as I conceive) of their likeness to each other"; he added the 77 liver-grown of 1634 to the 14 rickets and compared them with the 82 liver-grown of 1633, "All which shewed me, that the Rickets was a new Disease over and above"; "in the Year 1629, when no Rickets appeared, there were but 94 Livergrowns; and in the Year 1636 there were 99 Livergrown, although there were also 50 of the Rickets", though by 1660 liver-grown had fallen to 15; "the Rickets were never more numerous than now, and that they are still increasing; for Anno 1649, there were but 190, next year 260, next after that 329, and so forwards ... until the Year 1660, which produced the greatest of all"; 1660, "viz. 521". Causes of death were first added to the yearly bill in 1629 (ch. 1 §6, Hull p. 342). The 1665 and 1676 title pages read "By Capt. John Graunt, Fellow of the Royal Society"; the 1662 one reads "By John Graunt, Citizen of London" (Hull p. 658). ↩
  3. Hull ed. vol. 2, p. 317, "Note on Graunt's Observations": the first edition "was published between 25 January, 1662, the date of the first epistle dedicatory, and 5 February, 1662, when Graunt presented fifty copies to the Royal Society". ↩
  4. Alfred F. Hess, Rickets, including Osteomalacia and Tetany (Philadelphia, 1929), pp. 27-28, https://archive.org/details/ricketsincluding0000hess : "In 1645 Daniel Whistler, an Englishman, took his degree of Doctor of Medicine at Leyden and published in Latin an inaugural thesis on rickets entitled: 'Inaugural Medical Disputation on the Disease of English Children Which is Popularly Termed The Rickets'"; "At that time Whistler was but twenty-six years of age". Hess reports the thesis as dating the disease's first notice to about twenty-six years before. The Latin title, as the DNB gives it (note 5), is De morbo puerili Anglorum, quem patrio idiomate indigenae vocant The Rickets. ↩
  5. Norman Moore, "Whistler, Daniel", Dictionary of National Biography (London, 1900), vol. 61, p. 9, https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Dictionary_of_National_Biography,_1885-1900/Whistler,_Daniel : the Leiden dissertation, read 18 October 1645, "is his only published work, and is the first printed book on rickets"; "He proposes the name 'Pædossplanchnosteocaces' for the disease, but no subsequent writer has used the word." ↩
  6. Hess, Rickets (1929), pp. 29-31: Glisson's treatise "was published in Latin in 1650 with the imprimatur of the Censors of the College of Physicians"; "At first seven other Fellows of the Royal College collaborated in its composition, later three of this number were appointed a committee, but finally Glisson's knowledge and activity became so overshadowing, that the others 'committed the whole work to be woven by him alone'"; "A year later the work appeared in English, in a translation made by Phil. Armin"; "For over thirty years he was Regius Professor of Physic at Cambridge"; the disease became known abroad as "die englische Krankheit" because of Glisson's description (p. 31); Hess adds that Glisson "was clearly mistaken in his historical conception of rickets", since it had been described abroad earlier. The 1651 English preface (sig. A2) reads that the other two of the committee "committed the first Stuff of the whole Work to be woven by him alone, lest at length the parts should arise deformed, misshapen and heterogeneous to themselves" (Glisson, Treatise, note 7). ↩
  7. Francis Glisson, George Bate and Ahasuerus Regemorter, A Treatise of the Rickets, trans. Phil. Armin (London, 1651), ch. 2, pp. 10-12, https://archive.org/details/b30335693 : the outward signs in "all those whom hitherto we have beheld to perish by this affect": "The Head bigger then ordinary, and the Face fat and in good constitution in respect of the other parts"; "The external members, and the muscles of the whole Body were slender and extenuated"; "The whole Skin ... appeareth lank and hanging, and loose like a Glove"; "About the joynts, especially in the wrests and ankles certain swellings are conspicuous ... in the very ends of the bones"; "The Brest is outwardly lean, and very narrow ... the Stern also is somwhat pointed, like the Keel of a Ship, or the breast of a Hen", with the margin gloss for "Stern", "That part of the brest where the ribs meet"; "The top of the ribs to which the stern is conjoyned with gristles are knotty". Spelling as printed, long s modernised. ↩
  8. Glisson, Treatise (1651), ch. 1, pp. 3-6: "this Disease was first known (as neer as we could gather from the Relation of others after a sedulous enquiry) about thirty years since, in the Counties of Dorset and Somerset, lying in the western part of England, since which time the observation of it hath been derived unto other places, as London, Oxford, Cambridge, and almost all the Southern and Western parts of the Kingdom: in the Northern Counties this affect is very rarely seen"; "The most receaved and ordinary Name of this Disease is, The Rickets"; the rules for a Latin name, among them "That it should be sufficiently familiar, easie of Pronounciation, accomodated to the Memory, of no undecent length"; the name chosen, Greek rhachitis, "the Spinal Disease ... For the Spine of the Back, is the first and principal among the parts affected", and "the English Name Rickets ... may be readily deduced from the Greek word Rachitis". ↩
  9. Wikipedia, "Rickets", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rickets : "a condition that results in weak or soft bones in children and may have either dietary-deficiency or genetic causes. Symptoms include bowed legs, stunted growth"; "The most common cause of rickets is a vitamin D deficiency"; "It is sometimes known 'the English Disease' in some foreign languages (e.g. German: Die englische Krankheit ...)". ↩
  10. H. F. DeLuca, "History of the discovery of vitamin D and its active metabolites", BoneKEy Reports 3 (2014): 479, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3899558/ : Mellanby fed "the diet consumed by the Scottish people ... primarily oatmeal ... to dogs that he inadvertently kept indoors and away from sunlight"; he "could cure the disease by providing cod liver oil and he therefore assumed that it was possible that vitamin A was responsible"; Steenbock "began to irradiate rats, their food and the air in their cages with UV light" and "patented the process" (his papers of 1924 and 1925); "In 1935, 7-dehydrocholesterol was isolated by Windaus et al. and vitamin D3 was identified in 1937 by the Windaus and Bock. Vitamin D3 is the natural form of vitamin D formed in the skin as a result of UV irradiation of 7-dehydrocholesterol. This then raised the question of whether vitamin D is a true vitamin"; the forming of vitamin D3 in skin was not proven until 1978, in rat skin; the liver step (25-OH-D3) came from DeLuca's laboratory, and "Fraser and Kodicek demonstrated that the conversion ... takes place in the kidney"; "From 1600 chick intestines, a metabolite was isolated" and identified as 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3, published in 1971 by DeLuca's group (Holick, Schnoes and DeLuca, refs. 71-72), by Kodicek's group (ref. 74) and by Norman's (ref. 75); vitamin D "must first be metabolized to a blood form, 25-OH-D3, that in itself is not directly biologically active, but be further metabolized to 1,25-(OH)2D3 to carry out its functions in calcium, phosphorus and bone metabolism", the kidney product being "the final hormone". DeLuca places Huldschinsky in Vienna; he worked in Berlin (notes 13, 16). ↩
  11. Hess, Rickets (1929), pp. 401-402: "The earliest reference to its medicinal use, which we have been able to find, does not emanate from a district bordering on the sea but from the inland city of Manchester, England"; Robert Darbey, "the house surgeon and apothecary", in a letter of 1782 printed by Thomas Percival: "about ten years since, an accidental circumstance discovered to us a remedy which has been used with great success" (for chronic rheumatism); a woman was cured, and "about a twelve-month afterward her complaint returned with double violence, and the same remedy restored her to health again"; "Encouraged by this second recovery Dr. Kay, one of the physicians of the infirmary prescribed it for other patients"; Percival, 1789: "this medicine is dispensed so largely in the hospital here, that near a hogshead of it is annually consumed". Footnote, p. 401, quoting the Manchester Gazette of October 1824: "We think Manchester does not deserve the character for humidity which it has obtained ... The narrowness of its streets, we imagine, has gained for this town its character for frequent rain. The sun's rays seldom fall on its pavements, which consequently continue long wet." ↩
  12. Hess, Rickets (1929), pp. 349 and 403: Schütte's 1824 paper, "Observations on the Value of Bergen Cod-liver Oil" (translated by Hess); the first case, "The wife of the iron manufacturer, Peter Wiebel", lost the use of her legs after "pain in the hips"; "Her husband, who in the course of his business had to travel a great deal, brought from abroad cod-liver oil which was only known to the tanners ... after being used for two weeks, the woman could walk once more". Hess reads this case as osteomalacia, the adult form of rickets. Schütte: "Friedrich Kraus was the first, as far as I know, to use Bergen cod-liver oil for the English Disease; in 1814 he gave it to both his sons, one five years and the other three years of age." Hess: "He suggests that the potency of cod-liver oil may be due to imponderable amounts of substances which produce marked changes in the body, but cannot be determined by the chemist." ↩
  13. R. W. Chesney, "Theobald Palm and his remarkable observation: how the sunshine vitamin came to be recognized", Nutrients 4 (2012): 42-51, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3277100/ : Palm, born in Colombo, trained at Edinburgh, "spent 10 years in Japan, moving to Niigata, a treaty port, in 1875"; "in 1884 he returned to practice in England; specifically Wigton, Cumberland"; "He had spent a year in Tokyo and never encountered rickets, nor had he seen it in the smaller city of Niigata"; "medical missionaries from China, Mongolia, India, Morocco, Ceylon, and other parts of Japan rarely or never encountered rickets"; children there "were exposed to filth, inadequate sanitation, unsafe water and dysentery, yet they were free of rickets"; rickets "abounded in the UK in large towns and industrialized regions"; "the universality of rickets in Glasgow, and its scarcity in the Highlands"; Palm recommended "the use of sunbaths" and relocating rachitic children "as early as possible from large towns to a locality where sunshine abounds and the air is dry and bracing" (T. A. Palm, "The geographical distribution and etiology of rickets", The Practitioner 45 (1890): 270-279, 321-342, quoted in Chesney); "Palm's observations were largely ignored"; Śniadecki in 1822 "noted less rickets in children from rural districts", and his book On the Physical Education of Children said "the direct action of the sun was important in the cure and prevention of rickets" (via W. Mozołowski, Nature 143 (1939): 121, quoted in Chesney). On Berlin: "During World War I, the German and Austro-Hungarian empires were under a stiff blockade imposed by the British navy"; "Kurt Huldschinsky, a Berlin pediatrician ... irradiated them with quartz mercury-vapor lamps"; "From serial views of limb X-ray studies, Huldschinsky demonstrated that light shined on only one arm cured rickets in both arms. He theorized that a chemical was synthesized in response to UV light that could diffuse throughout the affected child." Steenbock's group "demonstrated that the irradiated rats could transfer the curative factor if non-irradiated rats ate the excreta in the sawdust of the cage, or if they licked the oils from the fur of the irradiated rats". Huldschinsky's 1919 paper was titled "Heilung von Rachitis durch künstliche Höhensonne" (healing of rickets by artificial mountain sun). ↩
  14. Edward Mellanby, Experimental Rickets, Medical Research Council Special Report Series no. 61 (London, 1921), https://archive.org/details/experimentalrick00mellrich : p. 4, the work covers "an investigation into the cause of rickets extending over the last five years"; p. 5, "any puppy which could be procured was investigated"; "The work to be described has been done on a very large scale involving the dieting of nearly 400 puppies"; p. 17, a basal diet "consisting of milk and equal parts of oatmeal and rice". Mellanby held that confinement indoors was not the main cause (p. 16: "puppies could be confined under very close conditions and yet, if well fed during this period, the disease did not develop"). In the closing acknowledgements (p. 77): "Much of this research has been carried out at the Household and Social Science Department, King's College for Women (Univ. of London)", where the feeding began "in the earlier days", and "The greater part of the feeding of the puppies was done at the Field Laboratory, Cambridge". His first report was in the Lancet, 1919, i. 407 (cited p. 78). ↩
  15. DeLuca (2014), as note 10: "McCollum ... decided to test the hypothesis of whether vitamin A was responsible for healing rickets. He bubbled oxygen through cod liver oil that destroyed vitamin A and found that this preparation was no longer able to prevent xerophthalmia and vitamin A deficiency, but it still retained the ability to cure rickets. McCollum et al. correctly concluded that the factor that cures rickets is a new vitamin, which they called vitamin D" (E. V. McCollum and others, Journal of Biological Chemistry 53 (1922): 293). Vitamins A, B and C had been named before it. ↩
  16. Wikipedia, "Kurt Huldschinsky", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurt_Huldschinsky : a Berlin pediatrician who served as a field medic in the First World War; "in the winter of 1918/1919, he successfully demonstrated how rickets could be treated with mercury vapour lamps"; "As Dr. Huldschinsky was Jewish ... he needed to flee Nazi Germany so he, his Christian wife Maria (née Straßer) and their only child, Eva, emigrated to Egypt in 1934"; he died in Alexandria in 1940. ↩
  17. Wikipedia, "Harriette Chick", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harriette_Chick : "In 1919, together with Dr. Elsie Dalyell, she led a team ... from the Lister Institute and the Medical Research Council (United Kingdom) to study the relation of nutrition to childhood bone disease in post-war Vienna. They ... proved that fat-soluble vitamins present in cod liver oil, or exposure to ultraviolet light, could cure and prevent rickets in children." Her own account is H. Chick, "Study of rickets in Vienna 1919-1922", Medical History 20 (1976): 41-51, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1081690/ . ↩
  18. Hess, Rickets (1929), p. 107: "In 1921 we were able to show the curative effect of sunshine in cases of infantile rickets" (A. F. Hess and L. J. Unger, New York). ↩
  19. Wikipedia, "Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wisconsin_Alumni_Research_Foundation : "Steenbock used $300 of his own money to file for a patent"; nine alumni "would eventually contribute $100 each"; the charter was filed on 14 November 1925, backed by Deans Russell and Slichter; WARF "licensed the technology to Quaker Oats for use in their breakfast cereals"; its vitamin D licensing "culminated in its enrichment of milk". Wikipedia, "Harry Steenbock": "On February 19, 1927, WARF completed its first licensing agreement with the Quaker Oats company." US patent 1,680,818 was applied for in 1924 and issued in 1928. ↩
  20. Jay R. Brooks, "Beer In Ads #1440: Health With Enjoyment", Brookston Beer Bulletin, 19 January 2015, https://brookstonbeerbulletin.com/beer-ads-1440-health-enjoyment/ : a 1936 Schlitz advertisement, "Schlitz, the beer with Sunshine Vitamin-D"; "Beer is good for you — but Schlitz, the beer with Sunshine Vitamin D, extra good for you. Drink it daily — for health with enjoyment." ↩
  21. Vitamin Technologists, Inc. v. Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation, 146 F.2d 941 (9th Cir., decided 24 November 1944), text from the Caselaw Access Project, https://static.case.law/f2d/146/cases/0941-01.json : the foundation "brought its complaint below alleging that appellant Vitamin Technologists, Inc. ... were making an infringing use" of its process; "Dr. Steenbock's continuing interest in the management of appellee's business is apparent from his testimony regarding the refusal of licensing of the irradiation of oleomargarine, one of the foods of the poor, with the antirachitic vitamin D"; "Q. Do any of your licensees in this country irradiate or fortify oleomargarine under your process? A. No, — no, in general, we have been unsympathetic with those developments"; "the only time the Wisconsin corporation has permitted the irradiation of oleomargarine was under the recent pressure of the war need and the demand of the Federal Government"; "Appellee has shown its receipts from its licenses to December 31, 1939, to be $7,478,5[8]8, of which Dr. Steenbock received or was allocated $760,000" (the last digits are unclear in the scanned text); the University of Wisconsin is in "a state of powerful vested interests in dairy enterprises"; "It is an undisputed fact that man in all historic time has used the process of cutting hays, whereby ... their pro-vitamin containing sap ... is exposed to sun irradiation"; "Thereby the sun's ultra violet rays have created vitamin D". The court held the challenged patent claims invalid. ↩
  22. Wikipedia, "Adolf Windaus", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolf_Windaus : Nobel Prize in Chemistry, 1928, "for his work on sterols and their relation to vitamins"; head of the chemical institute at Göttingen from 1915; 7-dehydrocholesterol found "in hog skin, and later human skin", and "the new irradiation product was named Vitamin D3, or cholecalciferol". The 1937 paper is A. Windaus and F. Bock, "Über das Provitamin aus dem Sterin der Schweineschwarte" (on the provitamin from the sterol of pig rind), Zeitschrift für physiologische Chemie 245 (1937). ↩
  23. R. G. Mitchell (Department of Child Health, University of St Andrews), "Idiopathic hypercalcaemia of infants", Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 17 (1958): 71-74, https://doi.org/10.1079/PNS19580013 : "During the past 4 years, eighteen infants with the simple type of idiopathic hypercalcaemia have been treated in Dundee"; onset "from the 3rd to the 9th month"; "the principal symptoms being anorexia, loss of weight, vomiting and constipation"; "it has only recently become known that ergocalciferol was being added to dried milk and cereal foods in amounts considerably in excess of the stated contents, in order to allow for possible deterioration"; "Seventeen of the eighteen infants were fed on dried cow's milk fortified with ergocalciferol" (p. 72); "Three of the eighteen infants died during the course of the illness" (p. 73). ↩
  24. Hansard, House of Commons, 3 June 1957, vol. 571 col. 886, https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1957/jun/03/children-vitamins : J. E. B. Hill asked the Minister of Health, "in view of the Report of the Central Health Services Committee that some infants are receiving unnecessarily large quantities of vitamin D", for assurance that young children "still need adequate supplements of this vitamin" and that "National cod liver oil is one of the ideal sources", a question asked in defence of cod liver oil. Hansard, 16 December 1957, vol. 580 cols. 21-22, https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1957/dec/16/cod-liver-oil : the Parliamentary Secretary spoke of "the cod liver oil at present provided through the Welfare Foods Service" and said "The new type of oil with a lower vitamin content, which is advised by the Cohen Committee, and which will be supplied next month", would give half the vitamin D of the old one; an MP noted "occasional attacks on the use of cod liver oil" in the newspapers. ↩
  25. K. P. Schlingmann and others, "Mutations in CYP24A1 and idiopathic infantile hypercalcemia", New England Journal of Medicine 365 (2011): 410-421, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21675912/ : the study notes "the increased incidence of idiopathic infantile hypercalcemia in Britain in the 1950s during a period of high vitamin D supplementation in fortified milk products"; CYP24A1 "encodes 25-hydroxyvitamin D 24-hydroxylase, the key enzyme of 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) degradation"; recessive mutations were found in six affected children, with "a complete loss of function in all CYP24A1 mutations". Its patients were modern cases, not the British infants of the 1950s. University of East Anglia, "80 year old medical mystery that caused baby deaths solved", news release, 26 January 2023, https://www.uea.ac.uk/about/news/article/80-year-old-medical-mystery-that-caused-baby-deaths-solved : the condition "can be fatal in babies", and "around 10 per cent of patients experiencing symptoms do not have the genetic mutation". ↩
  26. Ron Ledoux, "Did you know that Vitamin D isn't actually a vitamin?", Blue Sky Vitamin blog, 5 August 2015, https://blueskyvitamin.com/blogs/news/did-you-know-that-vitamin-d-isnt-actually-a-vitamin : "Vitamin D is considered a pro-hormone and not actually a vitamin. While vitamins are nutrients that cannot be synthesized by the body and must be acquired through the diet or supplements, the body is capable of producing its own vitamin D through the action of sunlight on the skin." A seller's page, cited as an example of the claim. ↩
  27. Harvard Health Publishing, "Vitamin D and your health: breaking old rules, raising new hopes", 13 September 2021, https://www.harvardhealth.org/healthy-aging-and-longevity/vitamin-d-and-your-health-breaking-old-rules-raising-new-hopes : "Although vitamin D is firmly enshrined as one of the four fat-soluble vitamins, it is not technically a vitamin ... it breaks the other rules for vitamins because it's produced in the human body". ↩
  28. D. E. M. Lawson, D. R. Fraser, E. Kodicek, H. R. Morris and D. H. Williams, "Identification of 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol, a new kidney hormone controlling calcium metabolism", Nature 230 (1971): 228-230 (DeLuca's ref. 74, note 10). Kodicek kept the phrase in 1973: E. Kodicek, "A new kidney hormone 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol controlling calcium metabolism", Bibliotheca Nutritio et Dieta 19 (1973): 78-79, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4780682/ ; T. M. Chalmers, E. Kodicek and others, "1-Alpha-hydroxycholecalciferol as a substitute for the kidney hormone 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol in chronic renal failure", Lancet 2 (1973): 696-699, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4125790/ . ↩